Pappaceno's Pizza

Best wings in Orchard Park. Consistently good service everytime I've ordered. I will choose them every single time over other places like Duffs when it comes to wings.

Best pizza ever! Easily beats Bella's and Nino's. Everything is amazing, and I definitly recommend the white pizza. After trying Pappaceno's, eating any other pizza is disapointing. I'm no food critic, but I like to think my opinion is very valuable. Try pappaceno's immediately.

The atmosphere is a little drab. But I guess most people just get take out.very good pizza. And wings. Much better than the fancier place up the road.

It may be a little small inside, but don't let looks deceive you because this is where you'll find the best pizza in the area. Not only is the pizza great, but their subs and wings are fantastic too. I'll be coming here for food as long as they keep making it.

Ordered pizza and wings. Everything was hot and delicious.

The pizza and subs are delicious here . The sheet pizzas and buckets of wings are totally worth it for a get together (especially if you live in op.) The mozzarella cheese is so fresh . Something about the sauce here hits different in such a good way- not too spicy, not too sweet. There is something very home-like about the environment. The delivery guy, Rod, is also super nice. Definitely would recommend this spot !

Very good pizza , friendly staff , inviting environment , 11/10 would recommend , I will be returning in a few days for more 👍

My wife and I just ordered a white pizza, stuffed hot peppers and a steak & spinach sub. Everything was absolutely delicious. My wife said its the best steak sub she has had from anywhere. Pappacenos is the most consistent pizzeria in town.

Good food for a decent price. Very convenient location for the apartments behind it. Wait times are reasonable. My only real issue with the place has been that they close quite early for a pizza place. I work second shift and cannot get their food after work. If they were open an hour later I would be a much more regular customer. Outside of this, no real complaints.

Had THE BEST !!!! STEAK HOAGIES IN BUFFALO‼‼‼‼‼Cooked just as ORDERED! Finely chopped cherry hot 🌶 peppers, in the finely chopped steak ,provolone cheese, mushrooms, onions X-Tra Mayo and X-tra toasted yum yum!!!!! And There wings are awesome also garlic parm and bbq back on the fire for that char broil taste!!!!and very friendly staff ‼‼🥰👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼Thumbs up☮

Best pizza I've had in the Buffalo area. We drive 20+ minutes just to get their pizza about once a week. Great people work there too. Only pizza place that I will eat more than one slice. The sauce is addicting. It's right in the village of Orchard Park, nextdoor to Noco .

Best white pizza & chicken wings around! Friendly staff. Great price for the amount if food you get! A++

The best pizzeria in Orchard Park, hands down. They have the best blend of good food and good prices. We don't even bother with the other pizzerias anymore. Staff is always friendly to us, we're really good customers!

Recently moved to Orchard Park from South Buffalo... And to be completely honest I was a Nino's fan but after having Pappaceno's I will never go back to Nino's or anyother pizzeria... Great pizza, Great subs and the best wings around, period..!! Also the staff are extremely friendly and helpful..!!

Double cheese double Pep extra saucy headlight Lee Bates it will be the best pizza you will ever have! I've been going here for years best place in Buffalo New York and surrounding areas

Pappacianos is definitely the best pizza in town with great food and better prices. Lunch specials are great for lunch and can count on timely deliveries

Sal one of the owners great guy. Food is always spot on. Prices very good, as is the special of the week sub. Only suggestion is to order the wings well done.

Chicken and spinach sub caught my eye on the menu and it was amazing!

Ive been in Buffalo my hole life..Honest!! THEY HAVE THE BEST PIZZA IVE EVER HAD!!!!TAKE A TRIP. ITS SO WORTH IT!! HAND MADE MOUTH WATERING THE FERRARI OF PIZZA!!

Sometimes it's the smallest places that have the BEST food. I am ADDICTED to their pizza!
Best in Buffalo in my opinion.