Andrew J. McCabe: Allstate Insurance

We've been with Allstate for 20 years and the Andrew McCabe agency has always been extremely helpful. I just contacted them recently to see if the price of our auto insurance could be lowered, and they were able to drop the price and also made some suggestions that would help lower it even more. Overall it's been a great experience.

I have enjoyed my AllState insurance for the last 4 years. They work well with me, and are great at answering my questions. I have considered going other places, as I am always shopping around for deals when it comes to insurance, but the coverage is great for the price they have, and I love the perks for safe driving. Would recommend AllState to anyone.

This is our first experience with Andy McCabe and so far we have been very satisfied with his knowledge of the marketplace and responsiveness to our needs. Which, by the way, is why we left our former carrier who became complacent in handling our account. I’m also confident in the support team he has behind him.
Alex Antonio

Andrew is an awesome person to work with go above and beyond what ordinary agents will do, trustworthy and honesty, would definitely recommend him to anyone that I know looking to purchase a home.

Working with Connor is been really pleasant, very helpful on any issues and very polite with customers, well at least with me.

Multiple policy discounts and renewal processes have been very easy to manage.

Been with the McGabe agency for years with motorcycle and Pick-up insurance. Been very happy with the service as well as the insurance. I highly recommend this agency.

They're really on top of things.Always trying to give me the best deal and making sure I'm satisfied.The rates are really low which being retired and on a fixed income,really helps

Came over to McCabe from another agency. Transition went extremely well. Service is great and I feel like I’m with a very professional agency.

Always very helpful when I have questions, and they are always willing to review my policies to see where I can save money.

The staff at Allstate Insurance is very knowledgeable, courteous, and answers any questions I have. I have my home and car insurance through them in which cost is very reasonable.

The McCabe group has been very responsive and extremely helpful in our transition from GA to WI

Doris, our Allstate rep at McCabe, is extremely helpful and responsive to our questions. When we were in a minor traffic accident, she guided us through the process so that it was handled easily. We are also in the process of updating our policy. Doris is making sure that we know about money-saving aspects of Allstate that will save us over a hundred dollars on our insurance rates. We are grateful to Doris and all the other professional Allstate employees with whom we have interacted.

Connor Kelly explored all the options and explained to me the best coverage that fits me. Easy to work with.

Doris is the best. One of the few service relationships I can always count on. Just this week we asked for quotes on insurance for an EV and she called us right up with options.

McCabe Agency has been very helpful. John has answered all my questions promptly.

Look no further for quality insurance providers…they are knowledge professionals who will help you

When I was first searching for new home insurance, and later new car insurance, they were both friendly AND helpful ... and made picking the right plan for me easy -- and far more cost effective than my previous provider. It pays to check in or check others.

Allstate in Bayview helped me through insuring my first home. Though the deal ultimately fell through, the experience was hassle free. I received quick professional responses. I decided to buy renters insurance as well as car insurance from here. No issues and easy to use app.

The team at this office is so helpful! I've talked with Arika, Mike & Terra on our Homeowner's and Auto policies & they've gone above and beyond. They always respond quickly to any questions and follow through. Really appreciate that they make sure we're covered but don't push extra coverage we don't need.

Great customer service, would definitely recommend for anyone in the Milwaukee area! 😊