Edgewater Restaurant

Absolutely love this restaurant. Definitely one of my new favorites around the area. We went for my HB birthday with no reservation and they sat us down right away. We picked the corner on the outdoor area. The service was great and attentive, the food was delicious and pretty big portions. I definitely recommend the fried ravioli and the lobster pasta 🍝 drinks were also very good, actually I had one of the best margaritas here!
Will definitely come back!

I ordered the lobster pasta, a 16oz ribeye and almond creme cake with a couple of cocktails. It was one of my favorite meals I've ever had. The staff was great, attentive and I am excited to return again soon. Thank you all.

Loved this restaurant! I am always looking for good food on the water and this place was lovely! We called memorial day weekend on Sunday and expected a wait but they took walk ins and sat us right away! We were able to sit outside on their deck with the heaters going. The view was really nice and food was delicious. We got focaccia bread, lobster pasta and chicken parm. Really delicious! Mine came with a nice amount of lobster which was nice to see. The staff was nice and we’ll definitely be back!

Great restaurant, went on a random Wednesday in the middle of July and it was packed. They had a wait for outdoor dining however they were able to sit us inside right away. Food was amazing. Definitely recommend the lamb chops and mussels for appetizers.

We are staying at the Bay Breeze Retreat (name of home on AirBnB) in Hampton Bays and this is 10 mins away. Perfect spot for brunch and more. We loved everything we ate and drank. Great service and views. Don’t miss it if you’re in the area.

Place was great. Not too pricey, considering the location, with great food and service.

Hands down Brittany is a fantastic waitress, you should all be so lucky to have Brittany for your server. Now let's talk about the food, my wife had one of the specials Marsala Mino Pasta, it was outstanding, I had a special of all specials wasn't even on the special menu. I had broccoli rabe over diced clam sauce with shrimp, thanks to Brittany and the fantastic Chef👍.

We had a great time at the Edgewater restaurant. 4 of us were very happy with our meals. One was not the hostess and waitress went out if their way to try and make the unhappy person satisfied and their persistence did the job. We all walked out happy and satisfied.

Note: they were very crowded. When the offered us an “outside table”, at first we were hesitant. But Theo outside area was actually under an awning and fully enclose with see through curtains. It was as nice and warmer than the “inside” room.

We can’t wait to go back.

Such a cute atmosphere here - service was great and they had an outdoor seating area with heating. Food was delicious, the margarita and rum punch pitchers were super yummy also! The view is great and all around, this is an amazing place to grab dinner around sunset!

The view is nice and the staff is very friendly. Rachel was my waitress and although it was crazy busy she tried her best to be attentive to our needs. The food was great and great portion sizes. The only thing was my steak was spicy, but do not remember if that stated in the menu. Their desserts are amazing especially the chocolate cake. Little pricy, but it is the hamptons.

Fast service, super friendly staff and delicious food, the atmosphere was also really nice.

We got there around 7:30 on a Sunday night and were seated quickly. Honestly really good experience all around!

Delicious authentic Italian food. Tonight we had meatballs and chicken parm. The servers are very friendly and it’s a beautiful room with a beautiful water view.

The restaurant just re-opened after 2 months of closure. Staff members are very friendly and attentive. Food is served fresh and price is just right. Very cool ambiance.

Truly a hidden gem! Never knew this place was here and always see it packed inside and out! Decided to try it tonight and we were blown away. Prices are fair, which is hard to find around here. Food was amazing, everything we got was delicious and portions are so so generous. The pizza was my favorite but so was everything else!!! Thank you for an amazing meal!! We will definitely be back

Their garlic bread and mussel dish are amazing. Great food with big portions and also has a cute patio

I had a delicious Frutti Di Mare and the service was excellent! Nice, comfortable atmosphere.

Nice dinner with a nice atmosphere. Perfect outdoor summer setting

Food was so fresh and delicious. Amazing service. Highly recommend this restaurant! 10/10

Walked in expecting a solid meal, walked out having eaten one of the best meals I ever had. Family agreed.

Absolutely delicious food and great service! The lobster pasta and pistachio icecream was very good.