Cobbetts Pond Pizzeria

Always friendly, great pepperoni pizza. Go for the spicy fries over the regular, trust me!

Amazing pizza, can’t stay away. Highly recommend this place and the staff is great!

If you guys like club sandwhiches. This is the place. Anytime I'm craving a turkey club they always do it right. Served with delicious fries ontop of it all. 10/10

The people are fantastic. Service is great and prices are very good. The food is excellent. It is a regular stop.

The pizza was delicious! We ordered cheese with chicken fingers as a topping. It tasted like chicken parmigiana. Grilled chicken with broccoli, tomatoes and feta were another favorite pizza. Best of all, the crust. Perfect mix of soft, chewy and crispy! Definitely recommend!

Listen to me. This pizzeria is on point with flavor and consistency. I've never eaten here before. They're doing it right spend your money at this place if you're around the area or just visiting like me. I have no idea why they don't already have five stars. It's on the same level as Luigi's from Portsmouth nh. Excellent pizza. I might drive here 2 hour round trip once a week just to eat this pizza. I know good food very well. There is lots of love being put into this food at this place.

I had a very pleasant experience with this Pizzeria. My order was incorrect and I called the shop to make it right, which they did, right away. They were very gracious and apologetic. It was an honest mistake which they handled gracefully. Will order from Cobbetts Pond Pizzeria again!

Stumbled across this place while stopping to get gas after blackbelt ceremony and let me tell ya, i am glad we did .. everything we got was delicious and the staff was awesome. Showed up with a party of five 30min before closing time asked if we could dine in they said yes didn't feel rushed at all, ended having a nice conversation with the gentleman after great place

Great team here, great pies, sandwiches and salads!

This is easily the best pizza place in Windham and I’ve tried them all over the last 20 years. Great pizza, subs and salads and the prices are good too. On top of that, it’s a family owned business with the same father and sons running it since it opened. If you want great food and a staff that actually cares about you and the quality of the food they serve you, look no further than Cobbetts Pond Pizzeria.

First time going here and definitely won't be the last. I got the basic cheese pizza but I swear it was made with love. It's was so good. The service was fast and efficient. Hands down the best little spot.

Cobbetts Pond Pizzeria came recommended as one of the top five pizza joints in Windham - and they were correct. I'd venture to say they might even be the best! Super yummy pizza, the restaurant was delicious smelling and the guys behind the counter were really nice. Can't wait to eat there again!

Fantastic pizzeria! Pizza was perfectly cooked and delicious and staff very kind. Will be back for more in the future!

The pizza here is a grease fest. And im not talking about some gross mess. Im talking a real old school greasy pepperoni pizza. Its like the cure for a hangover and depression baked to perfection.

Im not sure what it is about this place, be it fresh ingredients, or just the comfort food appeal, but something here really rocks. There isn't another place i can even think of that makes a pie quite like the one found here. The flavor is so satisfying, the grease is so indulgent, and yet, I don't feel like absolute garbage after eating even a whole pizza. Good job everyone.

Nice people serving tasty pizza.

We get delivery all the time and the food is great. We get anything from pizza. (Pepperoni obviously!) to Cheesburgers. To Grilled chicken Salads. And my life loves their Calzones. The deliveries are so fast. The delivery guys shoes are on fire when they arrive. Pizza pizza!

moved to Indianapolis IN 1997. was sitting here wishing I could have a steak and cheese from there. never had one as good. worked there in 95" and 96". great food!!!! wish they shipped it here.

Ordered from there the first time last night food was great and it’s now going to be our go-to spot! Delivery was spot on in time even in the weather and they are they have some of the best pricing for subs in Windham!

Oddly, it's hard to find a good pizza these days. Coobetts Pond has one of the best. They are more expensive than typical but I'd rather have something I really enjoy.

Delicious food and extremely friendly and professional employees.
Thank you for always making us feel special.