Paesanos Pizzeria

My family has been coming here for years. All the food here is amazing! Regardless of what you order you'll have delicious food.

I've been going here for years. I always have a great experience. I usually get the Stromboli which is amazing but today I tried the Sweet Chili pizza. It is exactly what it says, sweet with a little heat, and delicious.

Ordered from here for the first time....simple, plain cheese Sicilian pizza.....amazing, soft yet hearty crust. Wonderful flavor and very satisfying.

Love it here! Never dissapointed, the staff is friendly and learns faces quickly and although they are always busy they are also always friendly and accomodating. If you're looking for quick, good and unpretentious then this is the place for you. Love it!!!

This is my favorite pizza place because they have great pizza

My family and I came here to eat on our way to see the fall colors, and the food was absolutely delicious. It took about 20 minutes to get ready, but that was because it was a bit crowded. The portions were great and there were a ton of options, too. And the pizza was absolutely perfect. Just the right amount of cheese and crust, and ample toppings. To finish it off, the service was excellent. The staff were super friendly and patient, and when we asked something of them, they hurried to do it for us without hesitation. Amazing place to eat, and I definitely recommend it for anyone in the area.

We have been eating from here for the last 10 years and the service and food is amazing. If I could give more stars I would

The Best Pizza in Liberty and among top in County. Always Big Variety! Always Great! Recommend Margherita slices!!

Great pizza & friendly staff :)

Our absolute favorite pizza place. Hands down. We moved away for a few years and everytime we came to visit or was a must stop! A variety of pizza toppings like the cheeseburger and chicken marsala or the sweet chili chicken...I love this place. I've had others, but Paesanos just does something a bit better. Their loaded chicken salad is delicious, also! Haven't had anything disappointing.

I think if you want pizza and your in the area. This is a good place. There pizza is DELICIOUS. The dine in take out and delivery are great the always on time. Anyways. This is highly recommended

I have been coming here for many years the Best pizza place in sullivan county. I will continue to be a loyal customer

Best Pizza n Ny hand down matter of fact everything I've had here is BUSSIN

This place is my childhood! I have so many memories here and it always reminds me of my mother !!!!

Nice people, good prices and delicious food.

Deserves 5 stars!! Grew up on this pizza, moved to Florida 2 years ago and every time I come up this is my first stop. Best pizza around <3

Alright, folks.... I’m literally typing as I eat because it’s just so good right now these people deserve a 5 star. FIRST of all, I ordered delivery... super fair prices and amazing phone service. Was simple, quick, and efficient all at once. The food arrived about an hour later. (Was warned of this so NO issue there) Delivery guy is new, and he’s super sweet with a chipper bearded smile. ^^ BUT.. WHEN I TELL YOU... I opened my food to steamy perfection aroma. Okay?! And the flavor is remarkable and he quality of my Alfredo sauce was perfect to taste. The bread was still soft and hot! Salad and drinks cold! And super filling! I’ve been eating here a LONG time so the fact I haven’t given a 5 star review yet BAFFLES me! Apologies on my end but THIS PLACE... is hands down best in Sullivan county!!

The absolute BEST pizza in all of Sullivan County, NY. So glad it's in our little town!

The pizza was the best ever. I guarantee this will be the best pizza you will ever have

Usually I get delivery but for one person it may be a bit expensive ($10-20). I ordered a specialty garlic pizza with chicken Caesar salad. The crust is soft, not soggy and ready to fold. The sauce is sweet while the cheese melts perfectly as to not make a chewy crust. Secretly I ate a whole small pizza in one sitting so it must have been to die for!!! I was super impressed with the house made dressing, shaved parmesan and grilled chicken in my salad. If you decide to take out, the cost is a bit less. I always order two slices of pepperoni to go for a mere $6. The Gambino's are hams and definitely on point. I would go out of my way to visit. I am looking forward to trying more options on the menu. As far as I know, this is the local favorite. I would approve. You are definitely missing out if you haven't tried Paesanos.