Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Had a great time here with my girlfriend for date night. The atmosphere was welcoming and good vibes. The waitress was very polite and courteous. Very fast service. The food was delicious 😋 especially the spaghetti 🍝 "the pictures do not do it justice." You must try it! We ordered a little bit of everything just to take a couple of bites of each and were pleased with all of it. My girlfriend had a mixed drink, and it was mixed very well "not to strong but not weak either." I would recommend going here for dinner 🍽 it was a refreshing experience to have such great service and food. Also, we were seated right away. Our servers name was Morgan, and she did an awesome job 5 stars 🌟! We will be back.

Food was pretty good! Mine tasted great and so did my husband’s but his was a tad cold in the middle of his pasta, but he said it still tasted delicious. Our waitress was super friendly and helpful! Overall a good experience.

They brought back the Whiskey Bleu Burger and I can not express how amazingly delicious it is! Food is always hot and fresh and if there’s ever any mistakes, it’s fixed quickly and kindly. It’s busy often and sometimes just way too loud, even on the dining side so that’s why atmosphere get a 4 instead of 5. Still absolutely worth going to!

Me and my girlfriend love these restaurants this one is one of the better ones went here this time while working had a calzone it was very filling!!

My husband and I eat here often, today we had Kris as our server and he was a tremendous server! Food came out fast, warm, and delicious. He was very attentive and kind. I highly recommend!

Been a long time since I last ate in old Chicago, today was passing through Casper
I can say the whole restaurant gets the big WOW!! Staff up front during busy hour all had warm smiles and sat us quickly.
Then got another warm greeting from Edel, all I can say from the beginning to the end I can say he hit it out of the ball park. Great service hard to come by,thanks for manger stopping by to check on our table and many others. If you are very hungry and passing by do make a stop...

5 stars again, the crew absolutely went out of their way to accommodate us, service is fantastic, During out of state travel and Friday evening rush. Fantastic garden salad to complement the Chicago 7 pizza. 😊 Thank you.

Portions are huge, so it might be best to share a meal if you hate taking food home.
Server was friendly and attentive.
Space is noisy, so those with hearing aids or wanting a quiet background might think again or visit during slower hours.

I am a truck driver and was rolling through town and had a little extra time, so my wife picked me up and we came here for lunch. We had the pepperoni pizza rolls as an appetizer and they were spectacular. We got our entrées and they were cooked perfectly like usual. The waitress was training another waitress, and both of them kept up on our drinks like they can read our minds. That is one thing at any dining restaurant that I always look for is if my cup runs dry. We were offered dessert, but had absolutely no room for another bite of anything. We were quite pleased with the experience.

Food is amazing here, the service is really good with low wait times normally, it is super loud here though. It is certainly a proper sports bar. I don't drink so it would be nice if the dining section had better sound insulation but overall it is one the best places to eat in Casper.

Everything was spot on. Our waitress was really nice and don’t even get me started on the cheese sticks. Overall I loved it and will be coming again.

6 gals for happy hour on a Saturday. Great food. Very reasonable. Would go back for happy hour for sure.

It was more about the service than anything else. We had about 30 family and friends with kids meet at the Casper location on a Sunday afternoon. One server handled our whole section. She didn't get flustered, frustrated or upset with the changes or demands of the customers. She handled everything with a smile and knocked it out of the park. You need more like her!

Ashley was a great waitress and helpful all around and a hard worker thank you Ashley for serving for us!!

Pretty solid for a chain restaurant in Casper. Beer is cold, food is hot and typically very consistent. The lunch deal with a personal pizza, all you can eat salad and a tall boy for like a 10$ is great.

We had a big party (family visiting for the holidays). The waitress was very attentive, and the food was great.

Service is great! Food is always great! This is the thai pie, it is so yummy!

Wednesday night kids night and happy hour. Family of four we ordered a lot of food and managed to pay 35$ before tip. 2 dollar kids meals, 8 dollar per tall order of wings during happy hour.

Absolutely delicious pizza! Expensive at almost $30 for a large thick crust, but hands down the best chain pizza I've ever had. Wow!

Great place to watch the game. The thin crust personal pizza was really good, had the perfect amount of crunch.