Bridgewater Bakery

I submitted photos of a dream cake I wanted for my mom’s birthday. They did such an amazing job, honestly the cake not only tasted incredible but it looked beautiful! Cannot thank you enough for making it so special.

I've ordered custom items a few times from Bridgewater Bakery, and every single time, they create a cake or cookies that are even better than my inspo photo AND absolutely delicious, as well as reasonably priced! I couldn't recommend their creations more!

My 7 year old loved his birthday cake! They made the entire process very easy. We received great service at an affordable price and left with a beautiful and delicious cake! I’d recommend them to everyone!

I’ve been ordering from this bakery for a few years and they never disappoint! Nicest person who pays attention to detail and is just a pleasure to speak to. The cakes are so delicious! My guests always complement how good they taste! All in all the best bakery in town! Some of the cakes I’ve ordered are attached! She is very talented!!

OMG! Emilia was amazing and this cake was absolutely delicious. She made it just like I wanted and it was sooooooo good. We have found our new favorite place for all of our cakes. Thank you so much. You guys were really great. Thank you

A-MAZ-ING! They make so many great things here that I don’t see anywhere else, egg custards that taste fantastic, a variety of mini pies, breads, loaves, cupcakes, cookies, and basically anything else you could possibly want. It’s all great, high quality baked goods. Showed up here last week and excited I did. I even showed up yesterday looking for the mini egg custards tarts but the owner doesn’t make them until Thursday so she let me pre-order them along with two mini pumpkin pies and gave me a call the next day when they were fresh out the oven and ready to go. Love this place and the service

I ordered this cake for my daughter’s cake smash. It was exactly what I was looking for and photographed beautifully. Added bonus was that is also tasted great! They were able to accommodate my order on short notice and recreated the picture I provided perfectly. Really great experience!

For my daughter's 1st birthday, I decided to do a Winter Onederland theme in colors blue, white and a touch of silver. I visited Bridgewater Bakery as well as emailed Donna two weeks in advance of the celebration to place my order. The first photo (Hayley Cake) is what I sent to Donna (the baker) as an example of what I was looking for. The other two photos are what she created. As you can see, she far exceeded my expectations! The cake was absolutely beautiful and it tied into my theme perfectly! Everything on the cake was edible, from the snowflake confetti to the silver beads, to the number 1 which was made of white chocolate. I couldn't have asked for a better result! Also, the price was much more reasonable than the other bakeries I had visited prior to discovering Bridgewater Bakery. This will be the bakery I will be using for all of my special events. Thank you so much for adding that special touch to my daughter's special day.

I just moved to Bridgewater and went online to looks fora bakery that would make custome cake based of photo we share that is equally reasonable too. I found this cute Bakery. I picked up my cake for my daughter s first birthday Cake smash photoshoot and ordered a tall Unicorn cake which turned out so beautiful and equally yummy that we all ended up eating. Thank you so much Bridgewater Bakery for this sweet memory of yummy cake.

My daughter recently moved to Bridgewater from Sussex County. She ordered this cake from you for my 50th Birthday party. MY cake was absolutely perfectly decorated and delicious. My daughter says it was just as she imagined it would be. Thank you!

The "Bridgewater Bakery" is the BEST hometown corner bakery shop that I've experienced in a LONG time!! 🍪🍩🥧 This quaint shop is filled with beautifully decorated and delicious cookies, pies, breads, eclairs, tarts, and holiday specialty items for Easter & Passover. Stop by and give them a try! You'll be pleasantly surprised!!

When I ordered my cake from here, Donna, the owner, promised me magic. And boy did she deliver. She made me a cake to celebrate getting my citizenship and created it so when you cut into it the cake was red, white and blue! My guests simultaneously gasped and oohed. The effect was brilliant. She also hand-made 25 individually wrapped stars and stripes cookies. She was lovely to work with and her prices were very, very reasonable. I highly recommend her bakery. Thank you, Donna.

We ordered a last minute cake for my daughters 2nd birthday party this past January. The owner was so kind and noted the exact type of design and flavors we were looking for. The cake was made beautifully and was absolutely perfect for the party. I have to give this a 5 star rating but I wish I could rate higher especially for the taste. It was the perfect balance of sweetness and melt in your mouth texture. This was the best cake we've ever had and that too for a toddler's birthday party! I look forward to many more celebrations in the future to give this bakery some more business. They deserve it!

I can’t express how amazing this bakery is! Best service, best tasting cakes/pastries, and affordable. They made our wedding cake and we went back for our baby shower cake. They will be away during our baby shower, so we have to go somewhere else and I don’t want to!!! Couldn’t recommend them any more. Go here!

I cannot say enough good things about Donna. She was fantastic to deal with, detail oriented, professional, punctual, knowledgeable, and super creative. My husband and I met Donna a week before DD's 2nd birthday and got 2 cakes that exceeded our expectations. One cake was shared with family and the other was sent to daycare to be shared with munchkins & staff. We were so happy with our decision! The cakes were super fitting and above all unbelievably delicious. Looking forward to our next order. Thanks a lot Donna.
Fondly, the Bridges

I'm so glad my hubby and I found this place. I only have great things to say. We are from Allentown, PA and drove all the way to Bridgewater, NJ because of all the great reviews for this bakery. We were not disappointed at all. We met with Donna, who was very passionate and accommodating when we showed her the cake and cupcakes we wanted for our baby shower. She was delightful, helpful and went above and beyond to make our baby shower special. She is very passionate and dedicated about what she does and it shows in her work. She puts in soo much effort and focuses on every details (regardless of how small or big the design is). We received so many compliments for the cake and cupcakes; it was very fresh and not too sweet. Thank You so much for making our baby shower very special:) You are my favourite bakery from now on.

This is my go to bakery now. I have ordered cakes from so many places in NJ that it's almost a little crazy. I love this bakery. It is convenient for me, but more importantly all of their cakes have been outstanding. They not only look great, but are absolutely delicious. Always fresh. They made a Fortnite cake for my son's birthday and it looked FANTASTIC!! Everyone said it was absolutely delicious. It had two tiers and both were so fresh. Highly recommend giving them a try. Their prices are VERY fair for custom cakes.

AMAZING!!! DELICIOUS!!! GORGEOUS!!! I can't thanks any more about this bakery. The owner so sweet and kind she was able to accommodate to give her such a short notice for my wedding!!! She did an AMAZING JOB!!! Thank you Bridgewater Bakery to make my 💒 wedding day so amazing. My guests were so happy and very excited to taste a such great cake!!!
Thank you!!!

This bakery gets 5 stars!! Today my Aunt turned 87 years old. She is at Somerset Woods Nursing Home. I live in Washington, DC. I arranged for a birthday Zoom call with our family who are all out of state. At the very last minute I decided that I wanted her to, at least, have a cupcake to celebrate her birthday but none of the bakeries delivered on such short notice. I made one last attempt and called Bridgewater Bakery to ask if they could deliver a cupcake wirh candle to my aunt in the nursing home. Not only did they make the delivery, but they did it at no charge. So as the only form of payment they will accept, I am writing this glowing review. Thank you, Amelia and Bridgewater Bakery. You exemplify the true meaning of human kindness.

What an absolutely AMAZING job Bridgewater bakery did for a 30th anniversary. From ordering, to making the deposit process easy, to delivery...A+! Then, to cut into a gorgeous cake to a perfect 6 layer rainbow? Fantastic. Thought that was it until the taste. Everyone was RAVING! Reasonably priced. Awesome everything. You’ve got a new customer for sure!