The Hilltop

We had a great Saturday night dining experience here with friends. The Grouper and Walleye were fresh and cooked perfectly. Green beans were tasty, too! Prompt friendly service.

We were in Cross Plains and saw that this place had great reviews. They have great food too. So good that I forgot to take pictures. They serve you rolls with honey butter to start. We had side salads with homemade dressings. We shared a large piece of salmon with fries and a filet with au gratin potatoes. Everything was delicious. We had carrot cake for dessert. It was pretty good. I should have asked them to warm it up. It is always better that way.

A terrific old school supper club spot. Service, atmosphere, and food were all great. Would recommend dynamite shrimp and prime rib, of course with old fashioneds. Definitely coming back again!

Awesome to have an old school supper club back in operation!

The food was excellent, the drinks were strong and the patrons were as friendly as the bartenders and waitstaff.

This place brings back memories of how supper clubs used to be.

Arrive early, make reservations, enjoy the cheeseball and crackers at the bar before dinner and order an old fashion brandy sour with a slice of lime. Save room (if that's possible) for dessert and one of those tasty ice creams drinks!

The secret is out, this place has it figured out!

Made a one day visit to Madison, and decided to have dinner at a "Supper Club" and this did not disappoint!! Had a rustic vibe, but clean, well appointed and felt updated enough as well. We were informed that a group of 45 was ordering as we arrived, and the hostess let us know that we may have a longer wait, but if we odered quickly they might be able to sneak in our order ahead of thiers. They got our appetizer in(cheese curds omg so delightfully light and perfect) and our dinner order came out shortly after, so they really pulled it off. Our food was perfectly cooked(filet, and fish fry) and the service was attentive and welcoming.
I was impressed and enjoyed every minute of this quintessential Wisconsin experience. Only 10 or 15 minutes from the west area of Madison, we stayed at a hotel in the mall area. Check this place out!

Been by The Hilltop hundreds of times, should have stopped years ago. The service and atmosphere were amazing. You can't go wrong with the fried perch and au gratin potatoes. Delicious.

Great supper club, has all of the expected nightly specials. Went for fish fry both the cod and perch were great! The service was perfect, very attentive and new drinks were on their way before we finished our first round. The atmosphere was pretty calm and the dining area is deceptively large. Room for very large groups.

Traditional Wisconsin supper club with an excellent fish fry on Friday. Wonderful staff and owners.

Delicious drinks, waitress was awesome. Friday night fish fry at a Wisconsin classic supper club is completely worth it. Family had steaks which were perfectly cooked. I had the perch, so delicious, breading was so light. Cheese curds.

This place on the outside doesn't even begin to tell the tale of what's going on inside. I would highly encourage you to give this place a try, the staff was lovely, and the prime rib on Saturday is destination dining. We had a lovely meal in a great atmosphere and will be coming back!

There are so many wonderful, delicious things about this family owned business, I don’t know where to begin. The Hilltop is a Supper Club in the truest definition. From the friendly hostesses, the bartenders speed and the servers efficiency is only topped by the chefs magic. First things first, a must have …an old fashion of course. They muddle the sugar cube with the goodness. Complimentary homemade cheese balls are set out at the bar on Friday and Saturday. ( They are also on the menu, so order 1 to take to your next party) My favorite menu item is the combo. A 6oz fillet and 4 shrimp. The filet is so tender, a butter knife will cut it! The shrimp can be ordered grilled, fried or bourbon glazed. Homemade soup, deserts and other goodies are amazing. You will leave here with a happy tummy and heart!

Went with 9 other friends for our monthly supper club/fish fry night and it was incredible. Great drinks, fish fry and you definitely have to save room for the ice cream cocktails to end the night on. Randall, our server, was also sensational and the bartenders, while we waited for our table, were attentive and fast, especially with how busy it was on a Friday night. Will definitely return!

Always awesome. If you want consistently great food, Hilltop is your place. Filet and shrimp were perfect! Generous on the ounces of steak and perfect season on some very large shrimp. All accompanied by an old fashioned like only a supper club can make!!

Delicious Friday fish (baked cod) dinners, with great old fashioneds.

Myself and 2 friends dined here for the first time and we're very glad we did. All of the food we ordered was delicious and arrived at the table hot. The one steak that was ordered was a perfect medium rare. Mary Ann was our server and she was excellent. The kitchen's timing was impeccable and Mary Ann took great care of us. She is a rarity today. I'm so glad we added the Hilltop to our supper clubs to try. This was number 21 on our list and will be one we will happily repeat. A classic not to be missed. Come early!

First time here. Food was great. Crackers and cheese spread at the bar was excellent. Had the fish fry and it was great also. Next time we'll try the steak.

Made The Hilltop our road trip Supper Club destination last weekend with friends. Great atmosphere and friendly staff. Food was the best! Cheeseball and crackersat the bar just like the old days at the supper club. Juicy, thick prime and yummy ice cream drinks for dessert. Highly recommend!

Great supper club experience. Prime rib was excellent!

Justin was a amazing waiter, food came out hot. Beer could have colder.

I cannot say enough great things about The Hilltop! Each time we have gone, our food has been amazing! We had our holiday work party there this year. They were pretty busy that night, and I can tell you the service was still seamless! Very organized, great food, great drinks and friendly staff! Highly recommend!