Sugar River Pizza Co. - Verona

Place was very busy which we know why now. So we opted to sit on the patio to avoid the long wait. Very sunny and very warm which rightfully so; it's outside. Might I suggest a sunscreen at least so you can at least enjoy your time outside even if it is sunny and warm. We did end up taking it to go. Our waitress was amazing! On the other hand the pizza was unbelievably great!! I strongly suggest chicken bacon ranch(right) buffalo chicken(one with ranch on it) sausage, pepperoni with ranch sauce! Absolutely delicious!!!!!!

All the food was delicious. Really enjoyed the chicken fettuccine Alfredo and cheese bread. The quality of the build your own pizza was great as well.

Second sugar River pizza location we have visited. Food was awesome! Staff was ok our waitress needed a bit more training. Forgot straws for us and other tables. Forgot to put in our appetizer. Didn't get us refills.

Had a great experience here!
Pros:
Pretty reasonable prices
Lots of yummy dishes to choose from
The cheese curds were good
My husband was able to taste a spotted cow for only $1.50, which was appreciated.
Waitress was nice
Food tasted good
Cons:
Had to wait about 30 minutes to be seated
The bread that came with our alfredo dishes didn’t taste good. It looked delicious, but tasted so plain, I didn’t even want to finish it.

Thanks to Sugar River, I will never enjoy ranch dressing anywhere else again. I got a strawberry gin fizz mock-tail, side salad, spinach artichoke dip, and Amazon pizza. Filling and plenty of leftovers for lunch tomorrow. I can still taste the ranch. I don’t know what they did, but I need that bottled in a grocery store ASAP. I’ve never tasted a more refreshing or delightful dressing. Not too heavy and the dill was extremely refreshing. If you couldn’t tell, the ranch made the most impact. Everything else was delicious as well, but I’m stuck on the ranch.

This was our first time trying Sugar River Pizza and it was truly something to write about. In this world of hit or miss resturants this place was a big hit! We started with some of the best fried pickles and wings my son and I have ever had. Perfectly fried and juicy with the house ranch which we are now in love with. The half garden salad was huge and so fresh. We ended up with 2 pizzas and both were perfectly crispy and amazingly delicious. The Figgy Pie was savory and a bit sweet so satisfying and my son's pepperoni was stellar. We couldnt stop talking about it on the way home. I am kicking myself for not coming here sooner. The service was wonderful and our server was so personable and knowledgeable I believe her name was April. The outdoor patio was shady and peaceful on this hot day. 10 out of 10 will definitely end up being one of our favorite spots from now on! Thank you!

Love the atmosphere & plenty of TV’s for sports. Best pizza around! We had the Maple My Bacon pizza and the smoked Gouda mac bites

The chicken parmigiana was one of the best dishes I’ve ever had for takeout. I also tried the Mac and cheese bites and fried raviolis. Both appetizers were fabulous and would 100% order again.

If I find myself back in Verona I will absolutely walk to this place again and order the same meal.

I tried the new spinach tortellini with smoked pork and Cajun Alfredo sauce it was delicious! Friendly staff and good service. Will definitely come back.

i’ll be sure-gar to eat here again! wonderful service & just a lovely time! the pizza was solid & the pretzel bites were so good!

I love this place ever since it opened on the outskirts of Verona. Not only is it very personable and friendly, but they always have every game going on and friends and family laughing. I great over all experience! But what is phenomenal is the pizza! I’m a sucker for a good barbecue chicken pizza and this place is hands down the best in Madison.

I love their food here every bite is so delicious.
I highly recommend them to anyone in the area.
Thank you McKenzie for taking such good care of our family It's not easy taking care of a big family.

I went w a friend during dinner time and got a table with in ten minutes. There was plenty of parking right outside and the building is nice. We sat inside but there is a patio. The servers were polity and knew the menu very well. We got chicken wings as an app and they came out amazing. The wings were golden and perfectly crispy. Also not breaded which I prefer. We got two pizzas split into four different specialty topping for a little extra $ but well recomended. I would definitley suggest sugar river pizza to anyone looking for a delicious and affordable option to chain restaurants.

We had a 16 inch brunch pizza. It was delicious and 1/2 the pizza came home with us as it was too much for the two of us too eat. Highly recommend.

The server was super silly and friendly. She gave me a great recommendation to order the shrimp. She wasnt wrong. It was amazing. She gave us pitchers for the table for refills of drinks. That was nice because then we didnt have to wait for refills.

Tons of variety on their pizzas! Love that the dough comes in 3 thicknesses. Great tap selection with flight options. Good place for families. Was busy, be prepared for a little wait, we went around 5pm on a weekday, had 7 people and only waited about 10 minutes, but it was already busy at 5. Great to see and good atmosphere.

Stopped over for dinner while staying at the hotel nearby. Ordered a large pizza to go, was ready on time, picked it up and headed back to the hotel - where I found out I got the wrong pizza. A quick call and they were very quick to remake a new pizza. A brisk walk back and picked up the correct pie.
Pizza is very tasty (a large has ten slices), the staff is great, highly recommend stopping by.

This place is SO GOOD. Seriously. I moved here from a big city and was bummed after not being able to find any good pizza places. 3 years later I try this place and DAMN it’s goood!! Highly recommend!!!!

Did online order and curbside pickup. Everything worked easy and smoothly. Got the sugar creek meat lovers and it was phenomenal. Great flavor, crispy crust, just plain awesome. Also got the local mix beer 6 pack which was a unique offering. Loved all of the beers that were included.

they have the best wings you will ever have. they are spicy but not to spicy to the point where it burns your face off. and the mac n cheese is also really good would recommend