Eric Cotter Agency Inc American Family Insurance

Eric has gone above and beyond my expectations for my insurance agent. The timely response to my insurance needs has help me with my business decisions. The office staff has been very helpful and professional.

I just got done transferring all of my vehicle insurance and our camper to the Eric Cotter American Family agency. Nikki was my point of contact for that. She was very quick to get me quotes for all of the different options available. It was easy to understand and she walked me right through it. Nikki was very knowledgeable, explained things very clearly and I never felt rushed. I was searching options because we were adding a teenage driver to our insurance. She offered me so many different discounts that it ended up being impossible to say no to the prices! Thank you so much for taking the anxiety out of all of this, Nikki!

Being a first time home buyer is nerve wracking to begin with and then to think of trying to figure out insurance on top of everything else is just as nerve wracking. I wasn’t sure of everything I would need on my policy, Nikki walked me through all of it and made sure I had everything I needed and wanted on my policy. Not only did she help me with getting my policy in place, she also handled everything insurance wise with my Mortgage Lender to make sure that everything was taken care of there as well. Nikki always followed up throughout to process to make sure that when the closing date happened, there was nothing I would have to worry about with the insurance. Nikki made this entire process a breeze and headache free and went above and beyond. Would highly recommend for any of your insurance needs!

I worked with Nikki and it was a great experience. Quick, easy, thorough, and saved me money compared to what I was getting through other insurers. Definitely recommend!!

It was so nice to have a professional insurance agency to work with! So many times, the agents with other agencies either don’t know or don’t care about their customers. Nicole was very quick with answers and made the whole process seamless. I recommend this company to anyone looking for great service and great rates.

Nicole was so delightful to work with when I was searching for auto insurance. She went ABOVE & BEYOND to help me get the coverage I needed. She always gets back in a timely manner & is very attentive to my needs.

Nikki has been amazing to work with- very responsive, professional and open to discussing options that make sense for me and my family. Highly recommend!

Nikki!! What a Rockstar!!! I had a client of mine reach out to Nikki for her insurance needs. Nikki communicates very well and keeps close contact with all parties involved during the process. Thank you Nikki for all that you have done.

Eric Cotter has been extremely professional to work with! I have been thoroughly impressed by his punctual responses when I have had questions. He is very knowledgeable about insurance plans as well! I highly recommend Eric to be your insurance agent!

Nikki was great to work with! She made sure I understood all my options and that I chose the right coverage for me.

The Eric Cotter Agency and American Family Insurance have been great to work with. Eric's agency is very responsive to meet my insurance needs.

You won't find a friendlier agent to work with who will what is best for you. Eric and his staff are always helpful and responsive whenever I need to contact them to service my personal and business policies.

Great follow through and customer service.

Nikki Gilbert helped me get home and auto insurance. The process was simple and I saved money. I appreciate the expert help!

I purchased life insurance from these professionals. Service was excellent and the process explained in detail. Would recommend this Agency for all your insurance needs.

Nikki was great to work with, she was very helpful answering all of my questions. Thank you for all your help!

Eric and his staff are extremely knowledgeable and easy to work with. I would highly recommend their services to both Homeowners and Business owners!

Nikki has been fantastic to work with and is quick to find answers to questions and respond.

Eric is very knowledgeable and a wonderful trustworthy agent to work with.

Very friendly, easy to do business with,highly recommend!!