Paul’s live from ny pizza eureka ca

Outstanding pizza. We went for the 18" and had leftovers. They sell by the slice and had 11 flavors to choose from. Would be sure to visit again when in the area!!

Excellent Pizza, Excellent Beer, Friendly Staff.

I will however not comment on the interior because the social media person bullied me before for the use of words to describe it, sadly not everyone has perfect eloquence to do so.

Love the large pieces of pizza. I really dig the sauce and ample cheese. I could have used a little more pepperoni though. The vibe is chill but bustling with busyness. Lots too do in immediate area. Quick walk to anywhere in old town!

Nice pizza place, great variety, huge slices, and fun atmosphere.

Got a very large, great order doing gig work and was told they were backed up on their deliveries. I said, "No problem. I'll have a slice of cheese pizza while I wait."

I should have put a coin or something recognizable next to the slice of pizza because it was ginormous.

This was the only time I was grateful to wait for an order because,
It took so long to eat the slice of pizza!
It was that large & delicious.

I may have been able to choke it down faster, but it was so delicious,
It warranted being chewed with respect.

And, I was able to keep up on 3 different significant games in their dining area.

Ever go to a place and they only have one game on all of their screens?

They ran the Gambit.
Awesome beers on tap I didn't enjoy because, I was busy delivering & evidently, taking a nice break to eat some fabulous Pizza!

We’re not from the area and we asked one of our friends that is, where the best pizza was in Eureka and he told us to check out Paul’s Live from New York!! Very open setting made for larger groups! You can order whole or by the slice pizzas! The have a special everyday that looks very appealing to the eye! The taste and the crunch was perfect!! I will be coming back when I visit again!! 💯

AMAZING pizza. I would absolutely drive back out to Eureka for more.

I haven’t been here for a while with Covid and their closure, but I was very happy to see they back up and running!
I live in CO and travel here a few times a year. Paul’s is the BEST!! I’ve never had a bad pie here.
It’s the closest thing to NY’s finest, I’d not even better!!!
I’d give it 10*’s…

My adult daughter accidentally ordered an item different than the one that she wanted. We were not aware of this until our food was brought to our table. Upon seeing this, we made an initial comment about it but being that it was our own fault and not of the facility, we took ownership of it and carried on. Minutes later, the manager took it upon himself to personally deliver to us the item that she had meant to order and without additional charge. This will have a lasting impression on me.

I like their pizza here for lunch time. I had the "Rumble in da Bronx" and "New Amsterdam" slices. Both are awesome. The people who work there are cool. Always had a good time for a lunch break.

Walked in here after attempting to go to 3 other restaurants that were all closed on a Saturday night. There was a line out the door and the smell of NY style pizza wafted in the air. Plenty of seating, large portions, pizza by the piece or size, and friendly staff. This joint is buzzing.

I decided to try the cheese ravioli. Seriously. I was craving pasta. The sauce was heavy on 🍅 flavor. I could have used some more spice here. However, the ravioli was delicious and salad fresh. I would definitely go back if I am ever driving through town again.

I am a regular at Paul’s! Hands-down the best pizza in town! Service is always great. Restaurant is always clean and pizzas always cooked just right! My favorite is the Godmother! Although it’s more popularly referred to as the Godfather. The gluten-free crust is amazing!

We were in Eureka for only 2 nights and ate here 3 times. It's that good! It's the best New York style pizza I've had outside of NY!

The staff was so lovely and the pizza was delicious!!! We got just a Hawaiian pizza, and the dough was perfect texture...a little crunchy but soft. The toppings were delicious and the sauce was zesty! Best way to eat it is definitely folding it like a taco! My boyfriend and I had some fun messing around on the ancient arcade machine while we waited...though it is definitely worse for wear and hardly worked. But I highly recommend the garlic knots! Those were delicious! All around great pizza place with friendly, casual staff 😁😋

Huge delicious slices! You gotta fold it big. Great topping options, and cozy wide open dining room.

After many disappointing pizza experiences along the Northwest coast, I was hesitant to try another pizza place, but something about Paul's said this was going to be a great experience. They did not disappoint! This is the best pizza I've eaten at a restaurant in a long time!

We received it molten hot. The smell emanating from our box made it very hard to wait for it to cool. The ingredients are very fresh and high quality. That cheese is off the hook! The crust was also tasty and perfectly foldy. It was an excellent taste of NY. Thank you for the wonderful experience, Paul's Live From New York.

Absolutely loved it! Best pizza I have had in a long time. Really enjoyed the environment. And the customer service was fantastic! Definitely a great place to grab a good slice! ✌

Paul's is the only pizza place I've been to in CA that could survive in New York. They'd do much better than survive though, this pizza is good as any slice I've had in NYC. And if my review doesn't convince you, Paul has a stamp of approval from the goodfella himself, Henry Hill.

I don't get to Eureka much..... but when I do I go to Paul's.

Drove all the way from Modesto to try this pizza and did not disappoint.