Pizza Man's Pizza

I traveled over to Newcastle from Ohio to pick up a car part and stopped because we were hungry and found this restaurant. I must say the pizza is excellent. I came back to Ohio to get a slice of New York style pizza from Ohio a pizzeria that I go to all the time and now I hate it because I came to Pizza Man pizza and tasted their New York style pizza And it’s a huge difference. I will definitely return. I think I’m gonna drive up soon. I told my friends we were gonna do a small road trip just to get pizza they’re chicken wings are great as well. I’ve tried strawberry hot wings never had that before, but it was great , the atmosphere was nice. The people were respectful there was a little bit of a weight on the food but overall the food taste in ingredients and freshness trumps anything definitely a must stop and try. I’ll be back soon. !!!!

Happy with food, pricing and service. Not sure why I haven't been here before. Diamond in the rough. We'll be back.

As far pizza shops go in New Castle PA they aren't bad. I've only had their calzone and it was very tasty. The prices are great!

Their pizza has such a deliciously authentic flavor and is eveningly distributed which makes each slice PERFECT. My new favorite place and I can’t believe I waited so long to try!

Great pizza both Chicago deep dish and NY styles. Unique and classic toppings. Fresh basil and mozzarella for margaritas pizza. Great prices and staff was kind and efficient. The atmosphere is relaxed. So much so that I was surprised someone came to your table to wait on you. I assumed that it was paid the counter and seat yourself. There were no instructions as to what to do with the door. And no one plainly told you what the deal was. So it was all a bit of a guessing game.
Being from Philly, green peppers and a Philadelphia cheesesteak made me cringe. So I stuck with what looked good including the buffalo ranch pizza.

I keep saying the same thing..... Great food. Great people. Period.

Stopped by Pizza Man on the recommendation from people we know in the area. Had to get a Philly Steak. It was awesome. So large, I could only eat half. Maybe it was the homemade potato chips that came with it, that I couldn't stop eating. Portions are great for big eaters, very reasonable price.

Service was great.

Food was excellent. Soup was delicious all home made and authentic. Homemade rolls for the meatball sandwich was so mouthwatering. The homemade chips topped it off excellent. The prices are very reasonable. And the staff is very helpful and pleasant. Will definitely be going back here to try more of their menu.

Ok let’s talk pizza 🍕 let’s talk enjoy something ok let’s take a walk down the right lane and get some pizza man pizza ok simple, they don’t just come fast they deliver !

I am here at this very moment enjoying some of the best food ever. Service is great and food is even better. I was just driving through and noticed this cute little pizza place and thought looks like a good place for a quick bite. So glad I stopped definitely will be back the next time I come this wa

This is the best pizza in new castle I've ever had. Always so good. Everything is so fresh and the sauce oh my don't even get me started on it. I wish I was the veggies on it so I can swim in the sauce. So good. Highly recommend this place! Excellent pizza. Super nice staff. And did i mention how good the pizza is! Pizza man pizza is the best!!!

My favorite pizza place around, food is always delicious and hot. Best local pizza place you could ask for, no doubt.

I was raised in PGH. I am known to be very picky, especially with things like pizza. Very. Pizza Man's Pizza brings me home. The crispy edges on that pizza is perfect, the sauce evenly spiced, the toppings are fresh and properly cooked. Their 5 stars are easily earned!

I absolutely love this place. My new ‘go-to’ Their ravioli, stuffed shells, pizza, wedding & potato soups—yum! I have so much more to try. Their sauce is the best and their prices are very reasonable. Highly recommend.

Pizza Man's Pizza is the best pizza joint in New Castle! Everything on the menu is tasty and they have the best wedding soup in the area. I like that they have a pick up window. It's super convenient. The staff has been great every time we call and pick up.

Food was great. The waitress was really nice.

Pizzas pastas and subs are all great. Favorite pizza place in town.

Best HOMESTYLE pizza I ever had. I am a big New York style pizza eater but now I crave their HOMESTYLE pizza. This pizza is worthy of the AGT golden buzzer.

Awesome menu. Haven't had anything there I didn't love.

I always carry out, but their pizza is delicious and one of a kind. We sometimes do the garlic knots and app sampler as well. People are always friendly here and even talk with you as they work. A+