John's Of Arthur Avenue

Been here once in a blue moon in the past. Went in last night for just two plain slices to go. Had just coke out of the oven. I don’t really do reviews but wow. Hands down best slice I have had in a long time. Closest to my fav city spots I go to. Def going back a few times a week now as it was best slice I have had in a very very long time. Thank you guys ! Delish.

Great little place for a quick slice or two. Delicious and tasty pizza crust. Generous sized slice and get this No SOGGY bottom. Nice to have pizza that doesn't droop like the old bent carrot on that commercial. Hubby and I like the taste of the crust which is not something we find that often. Tasty not doughy and delicious. A great choice for pizza today!!

I’ve lived in Port Chester for quite some time and have never tried John’s of Arther Avenue. After ordering the Buffalo chicken pizza, I’ll definitely be more of a regular. The service was fast and take note we came in for an order on a Friday night and it was packed with people which was great. I understood why after taking my first bite. First Buffalo chicken pizza that added celery and it stuck with me ever since. If you want a great Buffalo chicken pie, go to John’s!

I can't speak to everything else on their menu because I usually just go there for their Pizza but their slices are huge and very good. They have a lot of different selections and toppings. Give them a try. Also you can get pizza by the slice there and which is very convenient because sometimes I don't want to buy an entire Pizza I just want a slice or two.

This restaurant offers counter service with pizza by the slice, pasta, and salads. The place also does take-out and serves Pepsi products. The place looks new, and well kept. The pizza is good.

The pizza slices are huge. Pepperoni and chicken bacon ranch slices are amazing. Best pizza I ever had in my life, and I've tried A LOT of pizza. Give it a try!

John's of Arthur Avenue is a great pizzeria that has delicious pizza and menu selection. Our food for tonight included Fried Zucchini Sticks that were crisp and flavorful. Our Eggplant Personal Pizza was comforting and satisfying in taste. The grilled Salmon entree sat on a bed of julienne sliced fresh vegetables that were cooked to perfection. Truly a scrumptious meal! The bonus here was the live entertainment by Robbie Rigo. He is quite the talent with a guitar and has played a variety of music from the 1950s forward. No matter your age, he will have your feet dancing like your tummy eating here!

Best slice of pizza north of NYC

Best pizza in Port chester or anywhere else in Westchester. Bigger portions too.

Great place to eat and take out with fast service and easy access for parking.

Best pizza in town! The crust is amazing and cooked to perfection and their red sauce is soooooo good and I don’t even like red sauce. 10/10 highly recommend. The restaurant atmosphere is so cozy and welcoming.

Great food. Comfortable atmosphere. Attentive waiters and waitresses. Pleasurable dining experience. Highly recommended

Very good. I stopped in craving pizza and had a grandmas slice. The pizza is delicious. Both the restaurant and bathroom is very clean. The staff was super friendly and I really like the simplicity of the decor.

Really great staff. Food was excellent.

Always on point. Great pizza, can't beat a $2.95 beer

Lots of different pizza topping specials to choose from. Friendly Staff. There is a stadium size pizza that is so large, it can feed a party. All for a fair price. Check out their plates too.

Got the insane 24" pizza. So much food! But I think it is as good or better than any other pizza in town (Port Chester). They have that nice thick cupping pepperoni which is the best kind. Also the calamari was quite tender and the sauce nicely spicy. A good first experience, will try them again. Possibly next time will order pie crisp/well done.

Excellent Service!! We had the Baked Ziti and Fettuccini Alfredo it was delicious just like GRANDMA used to make!! And top off the dinner with Chocolate Lava Cake and vanilla Ice Cream it was soooooo GOOD!!! Will be returning their soon!!!!

Order from here all the time. Delicious wedges and pizza slices as big your face. Whenever o sit in, owner always greets me with a smile. 10/10 will eat again.

This place is in my top 3 favorite pizzas ever. Their chicken parm is tremendous as well. Besides having great food, Jim (owner) happens to be a great guy and enjoy speaking to him when I stop in.