Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant

My boyfriend and I visited Tony’s from Illinois and from the moment we walked in our waitress made us feel so welcome. She gave us many recommendations of what to do in Cape May and answered all of the questions we had. We ordered a 16’ Pepperoni Pizza and it was DELICIOUS! The prices were more than reasonable and we left with full and happy bellies. If you are visiting the area, you HAVE to check this place out!!! If we make it back, it’s the first place on our list.

They have really good pizza. Came here since it was close to the dock for whale watching. It is an affordable place to eat. And the pizza was one of the best ive had. The place was clean and quite. They were open early. They also provided pizza on the boat we were in. I really like the location too. Its right by the water, just a short walk across the street. Will definitly come back if we ever in the area.

THE place to stop before you get to your destination and unpack. The pizza is outstanding the best in Cape May. Friendly atmosphere. Had the chicken Alfredo which was great. Calamari and chicken wings also great. Reasonable prices. Nice view of the harbor as you enter Cape May from the parkway.

Great food for affordable prices. Medium pizza is HUGE. Large menu, excited to come back and try the pasta!

Great place: excellent pizza, great red sauce meals (chicken parm, baked shells, etc! ) and good steak sandwiches. Service incredibly friendly and welcoming . We first found after giving up on an unreasonable wait at a more famous seafood place 🦞 🏠 nearby, and never looked back . We are already repeat customers and plan to continue.

ordered this chicken, spinach & mushroom pizza to take home on our way out of cape may. very tasty, crispy crust, very friendly. will definitely go back

Is there anything better than a good pizza? Yes, a great one! Simply put, the thin crust at Tony's is the best! We also had the cheese ravioli, which was to die for, delicious garlic bread, and the salad that came with it was so fresh and crunchy!
We were in Cape May for the day, but this was our second visit. Did the same last year. We will be back again! Not sure we want to wait another year!

Great customer service, good pricing on catering trays, delicious food! If you're in Cape may, you have to stop by tony's!

Pizza was great!! went two days in a row kids loved it..

Megan was our waitress and was phenomenal, welcoming and incredibly personable with our 4 year old. We'll be coming back here and I can assure THE INTERNET that she's the reason why. As far as the food- we ordered Pizza and French fries (two of New Jerseys gold standard foods) and they were spot on. They were both perfect flavors for a day in an ocean-side town, honestly it's the world's greatest summer combination: salt air, melty pizza, and crispy fries. NJ knows it's pizza, and parents recognize the importance of hospitality: Tony's got both!

Missed our fishing trip (tears), stopped by to catch our breath and plan out our next step. Was not disappointed pizza was great, the crust was like crispy butter melting in my mouth

My daughter's coach ordered pizza for the team after the last game. The pizza was delicious. We asked him where he ordered from and he said Tony's. A few days later we wanted cheese steaks and we figured that if there pizza was great then we would try them for cheese steaks as well. I'm so glad I did they were very good and you got cheese steak meat with every bite.

Place was very clean and the food
Amazing . To Bad I live far up
north Jersey of not this would of
Been my spot for pizza

New York style pizza. The ingredients were very fresh. The large pie is huge. We had a wonderful waitress who goes beyond to accommodate patrons.

Missed out on this little sleeper for years. Had great pizza right under our noses Looking to just fill our stomachs but instead got a fantastic treat. Pizza came out hot and was absolutely delicious. Mozzarella sticks were very good. Our server was beyond friendly and helpful.

Hard to find a decent pizza at the shore that doesn't make you sick from all the grease but these guys are good. We have started getting them every time we come down now. Tried their wings the other week and are hooked!!! They are like chickie and pete's wings and if you ever had those they are addictive.

Tonys pizza was a quick stop before boarding the ship. The service was geat and the staff engaging. We bought a large 18in pizza which was perfect..

Guarantee you, like me have driven past this modest and nearly invisible little place a zillion times without a thought. Found out how we've been foolishly missing out this past Labor day when all the dining places in town were rolling up their sidewalks and we wanted to grab a bite before we head home and every eatery was shutting down. We stopped in this, hidden in plain view, little gem and had a Fantastic large plain pie (that could rival any of your area/boardwalk favorites) and some tasty mozzarella sticks. A terrific friendly lady took great care of us and made it an even greater experience. This restaurant earned it's inclusion from now on, into the "must visits" on our Cape May/Wildwood excursions and should be part of yours as well.

I’m from West Virginia and felt right at home. This place has amazing pizza and awesome service! 10/10 recommend!!

Went on vacation to the shore and was headed to cape May from Philly. We were all hungry as a family and came across this pizza place in Cape May. We decided to order a meat lovers Pizza and it was delicious. Side order of chicken wings and mozzarella fries. Server was 100% and no issues whatsoever. Thank you for the delicious food. Definitely worth it.