Geno Nottolini's Pizza

I made my order for delivery. The lady who answered the phone was very polite and helpful.I'm a fan of hot & spicy food, so I ordered the diablo wings, boy did I meet my match! I only ate two, the fire was real! The lady who took my order told me they where very very hot. I also ordered the honey mustered wing they where delicious and helped cool me off😄. Delivery was fast. Next time I'm in town I will order here again!

Great food! Always warm and delicious. Ordering delivery will take an hour but we’ll worth the wait. I just order an hour ahead of dinner. A great place to order anything from a Gyro to a Pizza. By the way I’m bias to their Gyros because they are delicious and always heaping full. Would and have recommended to friends!

I never rate places. But i had to rate Genos/Mi Ranchito because my family orders from here all the time and we love they're food! Never had a problem with theyre food, always done fast, always taste amazing, always great customer service. Plus they have $1 tap beer! Cant go wrong with that. I love coming here for Mexican food, and today i decided to try theyre enchiladas, I was NOT disappointed. Beyond amazing, I dont understand why theyre are so many complains, sometimes restaurants have bad days (trust me i would know I used to work in a restaurant) I always say try giving the place a second try! Cant judge from one mistake. Although they are really busy all the weekends I still come here on the weekends with my friends! Because they play good music, they play a little bit of every genre! I love that and have the best dances. Bartenders are lovely and easy to talk to they make sure they're customers are happy. The owner is very nice and cool. I'm like a regular customer here haha.

Best hot garlic wings in town!!! Now i love legend larry wings but Geno's r way better. So much more juicy an alot more meat on the bone. We ordered delivery an they r super fast. Only waited about 25-30mins. I highly recommend this place!!!!

Love this place! Pizza, motz sticks with their marinara sauce. I could drink the marinara sauce buy the gallon it's absolutely THE best marinara you will ever come across.

I'm not sure who wrote the previous crappy reviews but I'm from Waukesha and this one one of the best pizzas I ever had. Food arrived warm and fabulous. I compare it to several high end itlation restaurante pizzas I've had, Roma, fellipos, etc....keep it up Geno. You're fabulous!

This place IS AMAZING!! They have the best Gyro pizza I have ever had. I even had my friend drive up from Illinois to taste it and he was in heaven! We will be repeat customers

I made my order for delivery. The lady who answered the phone was very polite and helpful

Best late night munchie spot. Pizza is great but I usually go with the pasta. Strawberry margaritas Are bomb too

Haven't actually eaten there yet . Read all the reviews and their average is brought down by people making multiple identical bad reviews . Most of the bad reviews are about management and staff . New owners , almost all of the food reviews are 5 🌟 . Give it a try and decide for yourself

Foods delicious, there open till 2 am, 7 day a week. I reccomend the calzon with a side of marinara sauce.

Great sized portions at reasonable prices. The food was excellent!

Great food, serves till 2am, which is important and Mexican food and burr! Owner is great and is my homie.

Great Chicago style pizza crispy crust. Fresh toppings with tomatoes sauce on top

Food was ok. The service wasn't great.

Great pizza!!! the staff and owner are very polite and friendly

Always good food and the staff is super nice

For a pizza joint, their tacos are top notch.

Favorite place for carne asada fries and drinks

Genos is the best in Sheboygan hands down