Pagoni's Pizza, Inc.

Owner and staff were very friendly and our pizza and breadsticks were great. Restaurant and bathrooms were clean.

Completely worth every penny. Blows every other place out of the water. Thanks for the friendly service and phenomenal food. This is now our go-to for pizza and Italian.

Pagonis has been a family favorite for a decade. Quality of ingredients is consistent and stands out when compared to other alternatives. Reasonably priced. Welcoming atmosphere. Love that the buffet option is accommodating to special requests. Never had a bad pizza here!

Wonderfully friendly staff. Pizza is made just right. The atmosphere is cozy. Love their Italian hot beef sandwich too!!!

Pagoni’s Sicilian pizza is absolutely the best! Hubby went outside our norm and tried the Italian beef sandwich. Truly amazing! They have the freshest ingredients and are always happy when you walk through the door. Lydia was our server tonight and did a fantastic job! She was so friendly and attentive. If you haven’t tried their food yet, What are you waiting for???

Pagonis made me change my perspective on food. I have never liked pasta of any kind, but once i came to pagonis i found a love for all kinds of pasta and other italian foods. The workers are so kind to me and my family, and my food is always on time when i order delivery. The restaurant is kept very clean and it feels great every time i walk in.

This is my favorite pizza place in the valley! They have a wide variety of foods that are all great. Our favorite is the Sicilian style pizza they have. They have great customer service as well.

Love this place my second time visiting and I have to drive 1.5 hrs. to get here. But I do and while visiting family. The staff makes you feel welcome and like family that is how you run a business. Can't wait to visit again.

Stopped by when we were in town for a Packers game (go Lions!) and wanted some Italian. My son and I both got pasta and it was outstanding. Service was great (Lydia was our server). If we are ever back in the area I would come back!

This is one of the best pizza joints in the area. I used to order almost every day when I worked next door to their old location in Neenah. Good times.

Ordered the margharita pizza and jalapeño cheese sticks and both were delicious!! We r in town from illinois visiting friends and was told about this place and we r so glad we tried it! Definitely a must try!!

Best chef salad and great pizza, too!

Every time we go it's the best quality and best food, me and my family have been coming here for years and don't plan on ever breaking that. Hands down the best pizza in the area!

Dine in, take out, or delivery this place is delicious. The owners and employees are super nice. So far they has not been one thing I did not enjoy. Thx!!

Got a pepperoni pizza delivered. Sauce is great, crust is above average, just the right amount of cheese. Pizza is well seasoned, very good. The ratio of ingredients is excellent, just a bit heavy on sauce for my taste.

Here you can find the authentic Chicago-style pizza, it's delicious, they also have a buffet in the morning.

Food is great but the customer service is even better. I have always had good experiences with this place. They treat you like your business has a meaning. I am someone who values respect and good customer service.. I love the pizza and garlic bread!

Was in the area for work from Chicago, and I must say this pizza tastes exactly like Chicago pizza! Authentic and very tasty…Owner is a great guy too! Nice spot to have hours away from Chicago. Go get yourself a slice of Chicago!

Love love love Pagoni’s! So underrated! Not enough people know about it. AMAZING food, awesome atmosphere, and even better service! Abby was our server, she was very attentive, personable, professional, and adorable!

Great pizza, pasta, and sandwiches. Great staff! Consistent quality.