Home Run Pizza

If we go out for pizza Home Run is our choice. We always get the 12" pizza which is just right for the 2 of us. Thin, crispy crust is just perfect. The toppings are plentiful & nice stringy cheese as it should be. Service is friendly & welcoming. The owner is always visible & you can tell she is very dedicated to pleasing her customers. We were here on a Sunday night & happy to see that many people have found this "hidden gem" . Give it a try & support our local businesses.

Great fish! Don't let the fact that it's a pizza place fool you!

So, new owners. Nice people. Still really good. They are doing a great job holding the torch. Great pizza, Good fish fry!

Pizza was so good! Great service !! We noticed quite a few customers eating fish dinners that looked awesome too! We will definitely be going back!

Went early as a family of 4 on a Friday evening. We thoroughly enjoyed our dinner and the service. The thin crust pizza was just crispy enough. The pepperoni was excellent. Food came quickly.

Our server was fantastic - kind, considerate, and on the ball.

This place has awesome pizza and the best service in Appleton. I used to get their takeout from the warehouse location years ago and the restaurant is just an improvement on the best pizza ever. I have loved coming here for years and am sad to see it closing. We love you Home Run Pizza

We enjoy going here and getting great thin crust pizza. We got a little crazy the last time and picked some random toppings. It turned out ok. We'll stick with the normal selections.

What amazing food! We had pizza and it was very delicious! Fresh mushrooms, home made sausage and pepperoni...YUM! We ate on a Friday night and, in Wisconsin, Friday nights are known for fish fries. We were told by people around us how amazing the fish was, so next time we will be trying their fish. We saw their salad bar and it looked amazing as well. There is carry out and delivery as well. Very nice service and prices are reasonable. This is a very casual place with a nice atmosphere. We will be going there again!

This place ROCKS. My wife and I are regulars at Home Run. We order the 16" Supreme everytime we go there. From the moment you walk in you are greeted with a smile as if you are family. The owner and entire staff treat you so friendly and are definitely about the customer service. We have as of yet not experienced a single flaw in the service or the food. This is the only pizza place that we go to since we found it. The Meatball sandwich is awesome along with the homemade chicken soup. Keep up the great work and Thank You.

Super friendly service, very clean dining area, comfy seating. No nonsense menu. We ordered the home made potato chips and a 16" homemade sausage and fresh mushroom pizza. Both were very delicious. The chips were ultra thin and crispy. Their traditional crust is ultra thin which we enjoy. The sauce was mild but tasty, the sausage was good and fresh, and the mushrooms were sliced paper thin- just the way were like our pizza. The drinks and chips were served right after we ordered. We waited about 30 mins for our pizza, but fresh pizza is always worth a bit of a wait. We will def visit again!
PS- women's rest room was CLEAN with a CLEAN baby changing table as well.

We love this place. Very nice people and always clean. Very good food and a great salad bar. Pizza is so good. The decor of the baseball theme is also cute. Priced right. Highly recommend it. We just wish they would have longer hours. But that won't stop us from going there. So good. 😀

The pizza was good, but what made my experience great was the waitress. The best I've ever had any where. Including upscale restaurants that I've been to all over the country. She was extremely polite, and checked in on us several times. I never had to ask for a refill on my drink. She was there as soon as she saw my glass was getting empty.

This has to be one of our family's go to restaurants! We have always enjoyed the service and food here! Everytime I drive past this place it just brings back all of the great family memories from when we had this pizza during special occasions! I recommend this restaurant.

My wife knows sausage, and she loves theirs! Delivery guy is always super nice and loves Phish, so I know he’s awesome, too. But seriously, their pizza is awesome. The marinara for the cheese bread is fantastic and not just a watery sauce. Can’t wait to order it next weekend.

We were very pleased with the food and service. The traditional thin crust is very thin and flavorful. Their home made sausage is very fresh and seasoned nicely. The service was excellent and the price makes it a real value. We highly recommend this establishment.

Wonderful Covid friendly place !!! Trista was our waitress and she is fantastic. She goes out of her way to accommodate. She helps me with my salad everytime because I am allergic to some of the greens in it. The pizza is great and the bread sticks are to die for !!!

Great pizza! Great service! Setup of seating area is excellent for social distancing. We appreciated being able to dine in and feel comfortable about not being packed in. We will definitely be back!

My husband and I go to home run pizza when we are hungry for pizza. In fact this is the only place we go for pizza. We are always greeted with a smile and how are you? The cook get's an A++. The waitresses are nice and they will joke with you. We went to Home run yesterday and my Husband also ordered a Meatball sandwich and shared half with his brother and both raved about it, THE BEST THEY EVER HAD. Now next time we go again we will bring his brother and his wife a family night. I would give a higher score then 5 stars I give them 100 stars, good food good people you can't go wrong.

Best Pizza I Ever Had In Wisconsin...The Taste Is Great, The Toppings And Just Right...Over All It Was Fantastic...Will Be Going Back Many More Times 🍕

One of the best thin crust pizzas I've had in a long time. Staff was super friendly. Plus they had the football game on, and are big supporters of local micro brewerys. Which will always earn extra points I'm my book.