Bennie's Pizza Pub

Super cute and cozy pizza joint right on main street. Went on a Monday night, which wasn't very busy but made it the perfect place for a calm easy evening of delicious pizza among friends.
The staff was all very nice and the pizza came out really fast!
I highly recommend the pickle pizza and crab Rangoon! Best part is you can order by the slice which are huge!
Can't wait to go back and try all their different specialties.

The also offer gluten free crust pizzas which is awesome

Bennie's is a fast casual kind of pizza place (walk up to the counter, order/pick up). They advertise slices "the size of your face!" And that ain't no lie! Everyone I spoke to was incredibly friendly. The pizza was amazing (like SO, SO GOOD). The best part is they do pizza by the slice. I got a slice of the dill pickle and the buffalo chicken; my wife got the Hawaiian Hog and the crab Rangoon. They're a bit pricey, but well worth it. We will definitely be coming back.

Bennie's Pizza Pub is a fun place to get a tasty bite. Their unique pizza flavors make them stand out. I've had the Pepperoni, Hawaiian Hog, Meat Lover's, Supreme, Dill Pickle, and Crab Rangoon slices. Slices are cut to 1/4 of a pizza- which is fun, filling, and affordable. When we go, my husband asks for our slices to be cut into thirds and then we share with the group. It's a good way to get a sampling of what they offer.

I don't think the pizza's flavor is outstanding (though it is still definitely good), but they compensate with the uniqueness of what they offer. I think the thickness of the crust hampers the flavor of the pizza itself. Bennie's also hosts live music and has a great drink selection (including seasonal cocktails) at the bar.

Bennie's is a fantastic atmosphere, with great pizzas,drinks and music. The service was great. Food was very good. I Highly recommend trying any specials. Bennie is always trying something new and we haven't ever been disappointed. We will definitely be back. Thank you to Morgan for the fantastic service. We will deffinatly be back to see you.

Best gluten free pizza options in the area. We love the cauliflower crust!

Dill Pickle Pizza, need i say more?! But really, you need to check out the creative pizzas coming out of the kitchen at Bennies! My GF/health-conscious friends - they have multiple options for you! Parking in lot behind plaza
MY FAVS: Dill Pickle Pizza, Cheeseburger Pizza, Broccoli Crust

This is my first time at this place. It's a really cool looking place and the pizza is very good! They sell either the whole pie or by the slice. A slice is like a quarter of the pizza though, so you are getting plenty If you're just popping in for yourself.

I stopped in here for lunch and had a great experience! The staff working were very friendly and fun. The atmosphere was fantastic and the food was excellent! I have been to Bennie's before, for meals and have never been disappointed. A great establishment in Downtown Belleville. Highly recommend!!

Benny and his wife Shannon have founded the most wonderful family friendly dining establishment in Belleville and SCC! We love you guys!

Great food, place has a good variety of drinks. Staff was friendly. The place has a really good vibe and a really nice back patio with plenty of room. The bathrooms were clean and so was everything else. We had a great time there and I highly recommend it if you're in the area. Their pizzas are fantastic!

**UPDATE**
-As of May 3, 2024-
Great to see the owner in the house tonight. It's good business when you see owners putting work in and hands on. Came out here with the kids and as usual it's still a great place, great vibes, clean, friendly staff and FABULOUS pizza! We will be back more often.

Best pizza in the area hands down. Great local business and involved in the community. Generous portions, top notch service, and great atmosphere with many nights offering live music - and not too loud. You want bland food go somewhere else. If you enjoy fresh pizza, salad, etc… do NOT pass Bennie’s by. Remember, one slice is 1/4 of a pizza.

First time there. Read great reviews before going, so we gave it a try. Turned out even better than "Great"!!!! Absolutely amazing!!! The male bartender was awesome. He immediately greeted us and swiftly made us our first round. The female bartender was just as awesome. She made conversation with us even while very busy. Both bartenders worked in sync covering the entire bar flawlessly. Then the owner came by and had conversation with us which was wicked cool of him. Now, about the food...we are from Jersey, essentially, the pizza capitol and Bennie's pies were just as good or better! Ok, now the spicy Bloodymary...A M A Z I N G!!! Surely will return on a regular basis. Thank you for the wonderful experience, Bennie's! <3 C & A

delicious crust its crispy and thick but not to doughy ! I'm so glad every other pizza place was closed at 01:03 AM because this pizza was top notch. We will be back for sure!

An amazing small business. The pizza slices are gigantic, so make sure you're hungry before ordering two slices. There is a great local restaurant feel, and Benny and the rest of the staff is very friendly. The old truck parts on the wall is always a nice touch for the car guy. A must try, if you are hungry.

WOW! The pizza is so much better than a chain pizza place, and the pizza by the slice is so generous, a quarter of a pie is a serving. The people are friendly and it's clean. I feel like everything I come in someone is wiping down the tables touching up the restrooms or cleaning the poker machines. They unofficially push fitzs beverages which are second to none and the root beer "my favorite pairs quite nicely with the meat lovers version of pizza that they offer". GO KNOWING YOU WILL LOVE IT AND THEN GO AGAIN! if you see me there buy me a slice and I will love you forever!

First time there on Saturday. Tried the bbq hog pizza and was good. Needed more pineapple though. Nice selection of beers.

My go to place for a good slice of pizza, garlic cheese bread and an amazing Bloody Mary!! They also have a fantastic selection of bottle, can and draft beer, along with great mixed drink selections.....

I went to Bennie's on my break because a coworker was telling me about it. When I first came in I was confused because of the ordering process. I ordered 2 slices of pizza and they were huge!!! They were delicious and I'm excited to go back.

Really unique toppings - don't miss the dill pickle pizza! I like the casual walk-up concept and live music was a plus.

This is the best pizza anywhere and for the same price as most fast food meals. Great place to refuel while shopping on Main St. Live music too. Hawaiian BBQ today was so good.