Carlos' Pizzeria and Bar

I went here during a snow storm to grab a pie... to my surprise they also had a bar 🤗... I ordered my large cheese pizza pie and decided to try a chicken calzone... Both were delicious along with the garlic knots I ordered.. I'm from NYC so my pizza expectations are high! This place did not disappoint....My true delight was my strawberry margarita that Megan, their new bartender made! She has a sweet, genuine demeanor that made my trip awesome! Thanks and I'll be back again 😃

I always enjoy ordering and eating here. The staff are friendly and attentive. The food, authentic and original. Haven't had a bad meal as of yet. This is the go to for family friendly service. But the also have a bar if you just want to sit down and watch a game, or just talk. It has a bit of everything.

I went there with my family had a wonderful dinner prices are right The quality of food is fantastic overall it was delicious and that's going to be the number one Italian restaurant

Food is great , dinner at the bar is amazing . All great people and employees. Ryan is one of the best . Grandma pie is my favorite.

I missed them during renovations but OMG was it worth it!
So nice to have a casual but super nice place to sit down and enjoy a meal in Middletown.
Could they be any more AWESOME???

This is a nice place to eat. Plenty of parking. Customer Service was good. We only had the Pizza and Garlic Knots. The Pizza and Knots was well made and taste good. My family ordered a Meatlovers Pizza and a Plain with Garlic Knots. I will go back and try other dishes in the future. I recommend this place for Lunch or Dinner and take out.

This place is awesome! Their menu and food are amazing and their bar is both aesthetically pleasing and fully stocked. Their Moscow mules are phenomenal. Also, their bartenders are knowledgeable and efficient. Highly recommend. Will return regularly

I am over the moon with the quick service and delicious food this place has. Other local pizzerias have a sauce so acidic that it sends me to the hospital every single time, but not Carlos. Their food tastes 1000% better than their competitors and I’m going to be a customer for life. My favorite is the chicken parm… they deserve all the praise for their hard work and dedication they put into their business!!!

Friendly staff all the time, everything on the menu is excellent. Always fell welcomed, drinks and desserts are great. This is a great place for a quick drink or lunch date if you’re short on time. Dinner is a must!!! Keep it up Ladies and Gentlemen.

The food is excellent! Love the staff. They're so friendly and personable.

Great neighborhood place to stop in for a quick delicious bite to eat. When I asked for something with eggplant, the server quickly created a pizza slice with eggplant --YUM.

Lunchtime seating is cozy with tables hugging the wall in the bar area. The open area seating was roped off the day we visited

Carlos was incredible!!!! I had them cater my party yesterday. They had forgotten the rolls at first, no big deal. The driver went and got them and returned within 20 minutes. I had a tray of meatballs that everyone was raving about. Also pasta and sausage and peppers. The food was incredible!!! The prices were very reasonable!!!! I would highly recommend Carlos to cater any party!! I will definitely be using their services for my next event!!!!

I've been going to Carlos' since they opened for both dine in and take out. Pizza and entrees. I've NEVER had a bad experience or meal. The staff is extremely friendly and accommodating. Cesar is exceptional and always greets his customers with a smile. Looking forward to my next visit and seeing the remodel.

Just had my daughters bridal shower there.. staff and food were exceptional…

Started coming here after a terrible experience at another Middletown pizza place, begins with a B and ends a S a year or so ago and absolutely love this place. I order a pizza and garlic knots for my family every week and have never been disappointed. Owners and staff are very friendly and unlike other places it seems like they actually appreciate the business.

Had several different slices of pizza from the display case. All had a crisp crust and delicious toppings. Fast friendly service from Carlos at the counter. Newly expanded Dinning Room from parties. Great place for pizza or a full dinner.

Carlos has delicious food. He is very friendly to all his customers. He will chat with you ask you how everything is and if there is anything else he can do to make your dining experience great. He appreciates everything his customers tell him. I highly recommend Carlos for eating at or ordering out. All the meals we have had were great!!!

I love their White Broccoli pizza. They chop the broccoli small so every bite is delicious. Only thing they don't use garlic on them like most places. But everything I've eaten there has been fresh and delivered hot and tasty

Great food and great staff. I eat there everyday..

It’s a nice little place. They are flexible on what you can order. It’s very clean and the food was fantastic. Definitely worth a try! Bring the family. Also they have very large portions. I ate about half of mine and I was able to eat it for lunch the next day