Red Gamay Wines & Liquors

WOW! What a store! Recently wandered in there based on my sister's recommendation and I'm so glad I did! I met Anthony (owner) who was SO knowledgeable and nice, the selection of wines and spirits was unparalleled, the overall atmosphere of the place was amazing. I will not be going anywhere else. If you're in the area and need a unique place, look no further my friends.

I found this place by chance. To my surprise, this place had one of the most unique selections of liquors I've seen anywhere. You won't find low-quality, over-glamorized brands here. Instead you will discover a curated selection of quality labels at amazing prices. The owner Anthony's passion and in-depth understanding of everything on his shelves was incredible. He introduced me to rarities that I never knew existed. I don't typically leave reviews but my experience at this place was too enjoyable to keep quiet about.

This is one of the best wine and liquor stores on Long Island. Anthony knows his wine, and always provides a unique and informed suggestion… His reps have also offered wonderful suggestions. Altogether, Red Gamay has a wonderful staff, as well as a formidable knowledge of their product.

Stopped in to stock up for Christmas and get client gifts. Excellent selection, great prices, and the owner was very knowledgeable.

The owner Anthony is knowledgable, warm, and extremely helpful. Not to mention he keeps the store stocked with a great range of options, including some selections you wouldn't find in most other stores. He also offers a great etching service which makes for a great gift in a pinch!

Highly recommend stopping by and paying this store a visit.

Place is the real deal. If you like following whatever brand the latest celebrity has endorsed this place is NOT for you. They only sell QUALITY products. If you want top quality, rare, and variety of it. This is where you go. The guy who owns it is like an encyclopedia as well. Nice to see a place where when you ask a question the person knows exactly what they put on their shelves.

Red Gamay is a very unique wine store - the new owner is extremely helpful and knowledgeable. I can walk in and tell Anthony what I'm having for dinner and be recommended the perfect wine. On the other hand, if I need some sort of liquor for either myself or a gift he can recommend something and even tends to have samples on hand so I can try it first. They do tastings on Fridays and Saturdays so you can go in and try something you've been wanting to try or just something new. One of the things that really stands out is how clean and welcoming the store is. It's easy to go to a section and pick out what I came in for. The other thing that stands out is the impressive Spanish wine collection they have. The prices are always fair and I always leave the store with an education. Highly recommended.

The owner, Anthony, is extremely knowledgeable on wines and liquors. The store carries really cool tequilas and Mezcal. Whenever I'm looking for a rare wine or liquor, I find it at Red Gamay. I've placed many holiday orders here and the owner always works with me to meet my budget.

one word: AWESOME
We are local customers who always pop in and out whenever we need a supply. Anthony always guides us and recommends what we should purchase based off of what we are looking for. Excellent selection.
Recently, I wanted to surprise my husband with a rare bottle of tequila. I called here first and Anthony went above and beyond to find out what he could do for me and was very up front and honest about the cost and delivery. Thank you Anthony for sticking to your values and treating your customers the way you do, We wish you all the success you absolutely deserve!

Excellent and unique selection and fantastic recommendations. This is my go-to wine and spirits shop. Definitely worth a visit - you won’t go anywhere else!

I stopped at Red Gamay while visiting the area this summer. I'm a passionate (and picky) bourbon lover and was ecstatic to find some great options on the shelf at Red Gamay. Anthony was great to work with and he even offered to reach out to me in the future when some of my favorites are released. Highly recommend Red Gamay for all your Long Island wine and spirits needs!

There’s not a better liquor store around. The selection of wine and liquor is the best I’ve ever experienced. The owner is extremely knowledgeable and helpful every time I’m in the store. I 100% recommend this store

Besides the always evolving, varied and eclectic selection of wines, another reason this is my favorite wine store is the fact that the gentleman who owns Red Gamay knows EVERYTHING about every bottle of wine he sells. When asked he has always provided me with excellent selections.

Recently stopped in, they have a nice selection of wine and spirits, a great Tequila selection too. I had a few questions and Anthony was very helpful, looking forward to coming back!

Anthony is amazing. Friendly, professional and beyond knowledgeable. I don’t have to guess if I’m picking the right wine for a meal, I simply tell him what I’m having and he picks the perfect pairing every time. If you’re unsure about something, he’ll let you sample to make sure you’re happy with your purchase. If I could give 6 stars I would. You will not be disappointed.

Excellent selection and service at this family owned gem. I come here 2/3 times a week and there’s always something new and interesting. Anthony is very knowledgeable and pleasant.

Big thumbs up!!! Anthony, the owner, went above and beyond in helping me in selecting (long distance) a variety of wine and vodka to give to friends for the holiday. He packaged them beautifully and delivered them himself. My friends are thrilled with their gifts and said Anthony was just so nice when they met him at delivery time.

Red Gamay has new owners and they could not be better! They're friendly, kind, knowledgeable and always ready to give a recommendation of a new wine or spirit. I love walking into a store and seeing the family hands on, engaging with customers, with obvious care and concern. For instance, on New Year's Eve, Anthony stopped me from grabbing my usual cheap bottle of Korbel champagne and suggested that I try the real deal - it was a bottle I never would have grabbed and it was such a hit with my guests. This is not your average "run in, run out" liquor store experience (unless you want it to be, I guess). Definitely check them out!

This is a small shop but the selection is really special - if you're just looking to run into a liquor store to pick up a bottle of Malibu or a cheap bottle of wine, fair enough, I might recommend going elsewhere, but if you're looking for some of the most gorgeous Malbecs around you'll be very happy here. We went in for one bottle of wine but ended up leaving with two, as well as a bottle of Stolen Rum which is nearly impossible to find outside New Zealand and Australia. The woman behind the counter made excellent recommendations and was super friendly - I guess we didn't encounter whoever the other reviewers did. We will be back next time we're in town to see what they have on the shelves!

Was driving by the store this week after visiting my wife at work and decided to go in and check it out. Walking through the door I immediately noticed the store was immaculate, clean is an understatement. I was greeted by both the owner Anthony and a young lady working the register. The customer service was second to none, the selection was excellent and the prices are on point. Highly recommended!!!!