4 Brothers Pizzeria and Restaurant

Best pizza in Greenwood Lake hands down!!! We ordered for pick up a large pizza half pepperoni half hawaiian and it was delicious!!!! Mozz sticks were really good too I would just like them a little crispier. I will 100% come back 🫶🏻

This was exactly what I wanted tonight. Not fancy, laid back,good price, good pizza! You can get a big slice of pizza or a whole pie. They have other food options too.

Oh wow. Swinging through on a hike and had to satisfy that hiker hunger. Ordered bruschetta that came piled high and was so deliciously fresh, and a small calzone, which was huge and I'll be packing some out tomorrow!. Bread for each was super soft, but my bruschetta was still toasty! I noticed later that they added a little hole in top of the delivery tray so it didnt get soggy! Smart.
This place is such a win, and from what I can tell, possibly the most reasonably priced around. Also they deliver, which is awesome cause I wasn't walkin anywhere today!

We were staying down the street and decided to try this place. The pizza was really good and it was ready in about 20mins.
We went during the day so it wasn’t too busy

We had the Italian foccacia at a party at Greg Deckers house recently. It was amazeballs. Ordered it today for a family party. Everyone loved it! The number of tomes my sister said ‘this bread is amazing’ was nauseating. It was a big hit. You have new customers in West Milford. Also, the girl who helped me place the order on the phone was so nice!

If you’re not coming here for their Crazy Chicken slice, you’re wasting your time. Not to say their other pizza is “bad” but the Crazy Chicken pizza is the staple of their business. Highly recommended. Whenever I’m in the area this is my “go to” pizza spot.

This is me and my family's go to place. Aside from their delicious pizza, we've eaten their crispy bbq wings, and it's an 8 out of 10 in my opinion. Their penne alla vodka with chicken is pretty good as well. I recommend it!

Pizza had a nice crisp thin crust and the fried calamari was tasty. Service was also excellent

Nice owner and keeping safely first. You have an option to eat inside or by the porch or by your car. Pizza is thin crust and crispy very NY city style . Yummy and delicious.

If you are ever in or around Greenwood Lake NY, you have to make a stop at Four Brothers. The Food is great and plus the size of the slices are the size of two slices at Planet Pizza. The staff there makes sure that you leave happy and satisfied. It is worth stopping by you will not be disappointed.

Great food, huge portions and a really cute patio where you can enjoy your food :)

Very busy but staff was cranking out a lot of pizza fast. Very good.

This pizza can go toe-to-toe with some of the best in NYC. The crust is thin. The sauce is perfect and the size of the slices are generous.

The pizza is really good. We ate in, and the slice was huge. My 4 year old is really picky with her pizza (and everything else she eats) and she loved it. She even ate the leftovers when we got home.

We order from here at least once a week, and we love everything we have gotten. The salads are huge and generous with meat and other toppings, which is unusual to find! Pizza and garlic knots are great. The Italian club sandwich is delicious too! They have a huge menu with a great variety of options. Definitely recommend.

Pizza roll and Chicken parm sandwich were delicious. Nice outdoor sitting area with lots of shade. The plants make this a nice little nook even though it's right by the busy road.

We were so hungry I forgot to take a photo.
We were staying at "The Breezy" they could not accommodate us to a table, you would think they would put small tables outside the rooms so we can order room service 🙄
Their loss. So we ordered delivery to the Breezy, we ordered 2 pies 😋 they were perfect, just like Long Island Pizza.
.... Definitely 5 star pizza.....

This is the best pizza in the area… by far. I live 25 mins away and will make the drive anytime we are having pizza.

In my opinion, the best pizza in the Warwick area! Love the wings too . We are customers for life!

Came here after a day of apple picking at Maskers with a group of 12. They had outdoor seating which was nice for social distancing. We ordered 3 of the pizza, wings, soda special. Best pizza we've had in a long while. Wings were really well made, just enough sauce. This was the perfect little gem to end the day. We will definitely be coming back.