Old School Bagel Cafe

This bagel cafe.......I'm from New York, and all I can say is, it tastes like home again. One of the only things I miss about ny is the food. And now I don't have to miss some of that so much.The manager is so nice along with all of his employees. The decoration is relaxing and modern. They show all the bagels available and I love their menu sign. Most of the drinks are self serve. Their coffee was amazing and they even had chocolate milk for my son. The menu options go on and on. So many different combinations between the toppings, schemers, and bagels. The only hard part is what to decide. I was surprised to find they even had a menu option for my picky eater. He loved the pizza bagels. My fiance got the French toast bagel with hazelnut spread and it was just gooey with filling and every bite was lovely. I got an everything bagel with egg and cheese on it and everything was cooked to perfection. This is now one of my favorite breakfast location. Thank you to the whole team for the fast service and the lovely atmosphere.

I highly recommend stopping by! The food and the atmosphere is amazing! I visit here a few mornings each week with my friends. The manager Cora (Kora?) is absolutely half the reason we like to visit- the other half is the cream cheese! Cora’s always as excited to see us as we are to see her!! Will be back soon!

So delicious! Clean and friendly. Great prices. Love this place

Had a great onion and garlic bagel today and the girl working was very helpful and kind!

The old school bagel cafe really is one of the best places you can go in Oklahoma. The nice employees and delicious bagels make for an amazing lunch!

I LOVE this place! The staff is SUPER friendly and professional! I pop in here for a blueberry Bagel toasted with honey almond cream cheese and an iced tea chai latte about 2 times per week...YUMMO!!

I was surprised to find such a good bagel shop!
Different cream cheeses and bagels of all sorts to choose.
I was surprised to find the bagels and cream cheese so decently priced.

Best selection of bagels within 50 miles! Bagels are big and tasty! Get yourself a baker's dozen and some made to order cream cheese for a real treat!

This morning I decided to ride my motorcycle to Stillwater and saw the Old School Bagel Cafe while riding. I am not one to write a review, but I felt I had to! The girl who took my order greeted me with a sincere good morning and the girl who brought my order to my table had a huge and sincere smile. Clean restrooms too.

I will be back!

They are in the process of moving to the Strip, I believe between Wooden Nickel and Nooki. I like the “everything” bagels. But does anyone know if they are open yet at the new spot? Couldn’t get an answer to my call so probably not. Hopefully they will update the address on their website as soon as possible, and also their Facebook page (pretty out of date...)

2/21/20
Still closed as far as I know, still in process of moving?? Altho oddly, there appear to be bagels from them being sold in OSU library Cafe Libro...(??)

Warmed up jalapeno bagel with a walnut decaf coffee is pleasing. Good wifi. People there are nice and caring. OSU type of atmosphere. I've upped my rating from four to five stars, as this place is quite nice.

Best bagels I've had in Oklahoma. Not exactly a New York bagel, but pretty damn close. Cashiers are always friendly 👍🏻

I walked in and was presented with the most beautiful blueberry bagel with decadant honey almond cream cheese. My salivatory glands began sweating profusely at the sight of such grandness. A lone tear rolled down my cold cheek filling my heart with such joy and peace at the mere thought of tasting the delicate masterpiece that had been presented to me

My lox bagel was so delicious and filling, and the latte hit the spot!

Great place with great food. The best part is the coffee though. Best coffee in Stillwater in my opinion. Try the firecracker bagel with the jalapeno cheddar paired with the Costa Rican or kona coffee, (cant remember which one it is right now) for a great meal.

First timer... Love the Everything Bagel with plain cream cheese... Great place and staff...

Local treasure. Just try getting a decent bagel anywhere else. Also, it seems counterintuitive not to order a bagel here, but their salads are huge and delicious. Very well staffed and clean.

Great bagels! Lots of options for types of bagels, meats, spreads, and sauces. Plenty of opportunity to customize it to your liking. Several good salads available as well.

If you have'nt eaten at Old School Bagel then you can't say you been to Stillwater,they use fresh everything, friendly staff and very quick,you dont have to wait long .so stop in and grab a bite several fresh bagels to choose from.

I've had lunch and breakfast here and it's always been fresh and delicious! Service is always great!!