Brother Bruno's Pizzeria Middletown

We all went to this place, expecting to get a great meal, and brother Bruno‘s delivered! We got slice after slice after slice, and they were all delicious. There were many options, and all were great. The staff is friendly, courteous and kind, and they even have an ATM machine. Ask for Italo! There were some animatronic creatures inside, for the holiday, and they gave the whole place a nice touch. I highly recommend this place for pizza, and anything!

Super friendly staff & I love their pizza!! The volcano slice is my favorite; saucy and the best combination of flavors! Everything on the menu is quality Italian food and their prices are great!! 10/10 would recommend for a stop in lunch spot and ordering to-go!

We ordered Italian combo and imo this place got the best Italian cold sub in middletown.

Absolute best pizza spot in Middletown so far! My family’s fave specially my 7 year old pizza obsessed child lol. Always tastes fresh even the individual slices and the decor for all the holidays and the great customer service is just a great extra! Def recommend trying it out when in the area.

What a great group of people, wonderful family making great food! Classic NY style pizza and with a great taste. I love the Italian combo!

Wow....tucked away in a plaza...Brother Bruno's sounded like a real Italian pizzeria. Well...it really was. Traditional cuisine which was excellent. Pasta with a slightly bitter tomato sauce really hot the spot of what a sauce should taste like. Chicken wings were really spicy good. Service was amazing...the staff were great guys...ever friendly. Prices were very reasonable. Will return again next time I am in middletown NY.......pic of my Evel Knievel toy collection....you all already with pasta looks like.....

Best pizza in the area, fast and friendly service. Great chicken parm as well.

Look Forward to having their turkey, lettce, tomato, provolone sub everything I go! Food is so good, service as well, clean n friendly.

This has been my pizzeria since I was a kid and will always be. A trip back home to NY isn’t complete without a Brother Bruno’s trip.

We have been coming here since before our youngest son was born. I remember bringing him inside in his carrier! We moved a little further away years ago and with everything that's been going on in the world we haven't been able to visit for a while. So just a few weeks ago we celebrated ours son's 17 birthday and this is where he wanted to eat because he remembers all the good times and Friday night pizza nights we had here!!!

It had been while since I’ve last eaten food here. Ordered take out a couple hours ago. Pepperoni pizza large size it was delicious. Nice flavors overall I’m very happy customer. Even though it had been several years since I’ve eaten at brother Bruno’s prior to most recent visit/takeout orders. Pizza is excellent and tasty! Whoo! Yeehaw! Yeehaw!😋

Best pizza in Middletown. Friendly service. Can’t go wrong

Only rating the pizza, because that’s all I’ve had here and it’s great! Brother Bruno has been and continues to be one of the great pizza shops here in Middletown. They have great flavor, good crust, ingredients and great service. Definitely my new favorite spot to go to in Middletown. Highly recommend this pizza!

Great wings and really good pizza.
Cold beer at the bar too.
Let's go Mets!!

Food is always amazing. BEST BEST BEST chicken fingers in town. Staff work extremely hard. They are great people with excellent customer service. My go to spot.

I have been coming decades to this perfect pizza palace! This BROTHER BRUNO'S is the best of all...all the different menu offerings are fresh and like homemade. The family and staff there are the most warm and welcoming folks you can ever find. I love the parents...i even call them Dad and Mom from knowing them so long. I love everyone there from Italo who knows how to manage things firmly...to his sister Antonella who redesigned the entire place...to Marlon n Luke...n Billy Barnstormer as I nicknamed him to Tommy and a new Chef.. and others. I always enjoy seeing each of them...and feel they truly care. Today I tried their SEAFOOD MINGLE..with large shrimp...clams..mussels...calamari...it was like eating at City Island seafood restaurants! They even surprised me with a free mini stromboli...which i think would be a top hit if placed as a feature on their regular menu...that was so nice...and made me feel extra special as a longtime appreciated customer. At holidays...the decorations are really magnificent. Best of all they are extremely clean...and have BEER!!!
DRAFT BEER TOO! Nothing can beat the taste of pizza n beer....just ask the leprechauns on Saint Pat's day. BEER IS GRAND! A POOHBEAR KNOWS TOO....THAT 99.9 % CAN BE HAPPY WITH EVERY ASPECT OF THIS BROTHER BRUNO...FROM DECORE TO FOOD TO GIANT TV..BEER AND STAFF..PLUS EASY PARKING ...AND A GREAT SPOT...BY THE SUPERMARKET...DOLLARSTORES...MOVIES ACROSS THE STREET ...AND MORE.
TRUST ME YOU WILL GO BACK AGAIN N AGAIN. THE EXPERIENCE IS BETTER THAN ANY MORE WORDS CAN DESCRIBE. LOVE IT!!!

.Best Italian sub EVER. ALL other food is good also.

Quickly becoming favorite spot over any spot in Westchester. The gravy is just amazing 👏

The best pizzeria in Middletown. All the food is good and the staff are very friendly.

Best Pizza and Italian Combos in Middletown!!