Mama Renie's Pizza of mcarthur

Nice place, the food was so good we got the buffalo ranch pizza, PB pie, and bread sticks and it was some the best we've ever had. We will be back.

I have now been here twice. Once for dinner and once for breakfast. Both times have been amazing. Service has been great and the food has constantly been no less than excellent. I had the buffalo chicken pizza and the biscuits and gravy. Both are so amazing and I would order again. I recommend for anyone coming by and feel like this is one of the best places in the area.

Prices, friendly service and “right tasty” food! Been here three times this week and EVERYTHING has been good!

It was Halloween night and unfortunately they ran out of 2 of the desserts we wanted. The pizza was fantastic as always! :)

Excellent food service and atmosphere. Country fried Steak is awesome

Great food. We have had the pizza before and it is always good. This time we ate in and pizza was even better. Cooked just perfect and plenty of toppings. Service was a little slow, but was a busy Friday night. Definitely recommend.

When staying at Lake Hope, we came here for breakfast and dinner. The food was delicious and the prices were amazing! Also great selection without being overwhelming. The inside also had a cozy local vibe and friendly staff. If you’re looking for a nice meal (that happens to be at a reasonable price), Mama Renie’s is the place to go!

The food is great and such a bang for your buck. Portion sizes are huge compared to what you’re paying for! I recommend the calzone, their pizza sauce is to die for.

I stopped in randomly for lunch and had a great meal. The tenderloin sandwich and fries were hot, fresh, and delicious.

Food is always great!! Good service! Some food it kinda high price for what you get. Pizza is the best in McArthur.

Been many years, food atmosphere and service was top notch! Will always be a lifer!

We were in town for a weekend. The service and food were so good here that we ended up eating here for three separate meals. Best omelette I've ever had!

I Love the small town places with great food. Their pizza has homemade dough and sauce and is fantastic. Although the building smells musty, the food and atmosphere is great. Their menu has other lures too. Full breakfast until 11a and steaks for dinner. I definitely recommend this place to anyone.

We went here because it had a good star review. Do not be scared away by the dive bar look from the outside and inside. The bar looks and feels old, but the staff is super friendly and the pizza was amazing. My wife and I ordered a 16" half pepperoni half veggie pizza. I was blown away by how good it was. The toppings were great and the dough was crispy. If I am ever back in the area, I would definitely go back.

We ate breakfast and it was delicious and service was fast and friendly

The pickle fries are amazing here. The rest of the food was really good. Laid back atmosphere. The ladies were very friendly.

Another day of riding my motorcycle in rain all day. So I stop in MacArthur Ohio and was going to find a place to dry out and warm up. Well I was able to dry out but they had the air conditioner on so low that my teeth were chattering. Any the food was prompt and good, a long with exceptional service. Great little place to eat and drink

Got the meatballs sub special! Yummy 😋

Great food! Not just pizza, although the kids loved the cheese only and the cheeseburger specialty pizza. The fish sandwich and the Philly cheese sandwiches were delicious as well.

We absolutely love this shop. Ice cold beverages, killer pizza with the best mini pepperonis we've ever had.