The Paper Store

The staff are very friendly and helpful! They have a great selection of gifts with a wide range to fit everyone’s budget and preferences. It’s great to see people in the industry that actually seem to enjoy what they are doing and are willing to help the customers :-)

Quite a large selection of all different kinds of things you may not have realized you wanted until you stepped foot in here. I just needed things to wrap presents and they have plenty of options to choose from. Located right in Garden City so regardless of where you parked, you can easily walk to all different kinds of stores and restaurants and get a lot done efficiently.

One of my favorite Christmas shopping stops. I can always find a great gift or two here. Nice mix of different types of things.

Who knew making cake out of slime with a thing? The paper store did. While I didn't see any reams of paper to buy they do have slime cake kits! 🍰 Ours didn't come out looking exactly like the outside of the box but it was still fun to make...and later squish!😂

The staff there is excellent! They are super helpful with anything you need, including putting stuff in for order if not available in the store.

Love the new larger space! Huge selection of all kinds of gifts to choose from. Still has a great selection of cards, gift wrap and this time of year, ornaments. Great place!

Place has great knick knacks and clothes, greeting cards, jewelry. Cute store to stop in for any occasion. Staff is very friendly and helpful.

Got a bee for my friend, everything's a billion dollars but these guys weren't so that was especially awesome.

I had the absolute pleasure of meeting Mike. He was over the top helpful and friendly! He helped me find really fun and great deals! I actually had fun! Also, Barbara greeted me when I walked in and talked me into another great purchase!

My husband and I were in last night browsing for Christmas gifts. Tony was fantastic. She helped educate us on the rewards program and even found an extra $5 off coupon in my email. We bought several gifts and ended up saving a lot too! She is great at what she does! Thank you for a wonderful buying experience. We love this store and will continue to be repeat customers.

I always enjoy shopping there

Forgetting to buy the Christmas Special Delivery Singing Plush Snowman, I called the store (1-25-19) hoping maybe one would still be available to buy. A very friendly and extremely helpful store associate, named Lisa answered the phone. I told her what I was looking for, and she said she would check the store for me. She returned, apologizing, telling me the bad news. Lisa said that she would check the computer for other stores in the area, hoping to find one for me, & mentioned a couple that still had some in stock. She was going to give me the info., I needed but I had nothing to write with in rental car.
She asked me for my phone # .
How many people would call back, tell you that she left your name & number with a store, put one on hold for you, and give you the store hours??!!
How awesome is that!!!

LISA...It is great to know that someone like you can take the time, and go above and beyond to help someone.

We need more people like you!!! A+++++

It sure makes you feel good when you can do that for someone.
Next time I’m in the store, hopefully you will be working, and I can tell you I’m am the person that was so grateful for your help!
So glad you answered the phone. You made my week.

KUTOS to you, Lisa!

Thank You, Nancy Miceli

Love love the Paper Store! I've shopped here for many years even when it was the Hallmark Store. They have a great inventory where you could find something for everyone. U can use your Hallmark coups here. Also, just read their sign today that they accept Yankee Candles coups.

What a happy store! A little of everything and fair prices.

They have such cute items I just love the Holidays and the Paper Store always suprise me

Such a fun store. Always a great selection of things. A little of this, a little of that!!

How can you go to this store and not find something to buy? I love to browse. They offer a large variety of items. Give it a try.

Always fun to shop here. They sell hallmark cards for every occasion as well as tons of great gifts, books and candles.

It's like a candy store on steroids! Wonderful, professional and extremely helpful staff and store manager. I'll be back real soon. Thank you

Great selection of cards n gifts