Tosco's Pizzeria New Windsor

We asked for a cup of their marinara sauce before we ordered There sauce is not sweet thank god!
I find a lot of pizza places make their sauce sweet like candy. I don’t know why . It’s Small place but there pizza is excellent.

I had lunch here and the food was delicious. The lunch special was a great deal and the pizza slices were very big. The gentleman behind the counter was very nice he went out of his way to assist me and he even cut my kids pizza a certain way for them.

Pizza is delicious. I got the "crazy chicken" which has a good mix of BBQ, Buffalo, and chicken bacon ranch.
Service was quick and the girl was nice.
It's definitely a mom and pop type shop.
Only thing is, it's extremely hot in there so don't plan on sitting there to eat cause you'll sweat like no tomorrow.

We used to live in ft. Montgomery and we go to bear mountain pizza all the time. after moving to cornwall, we ordered from 2 places near us (1 was featured in hgtv (not sure why, theyre not very good)) but it was a disappointment. Then a friend ordered from this place for her kid’s birthday, lo and behold, we found the one! It’s even better than the bear mountain pizza we used to go to! Thank you, Tosco’s! We love all the pizza specially the pepperoni. They have an XL size too which is 24” which equals to 2 regular slices and much cheaper!

We also tried their salad. So much grilled chicken. Everything is just delicious!

Ordered two 24” inch pizzas. One Meat Lovers, the other Veggie Lovers and 20” inch white pizza for family gathering. Best pizza in the area by far! Everyone loved it and came from different areas in New York and said the pizza was great !

Incredible! The largest pizza pie I've ever seen. Warning, the XXlarge pie needs an empty trunk to bring it home. The taste is authentic NY pizza at it's best. You're gonna need napkins for this big boy.

When I am doing laundry and im hungry I always come here the pizza I don't like it I LOVE IT I love that everyone is kind here!

We just moved here from Rochester, NY and we've been trying to find a good pizza place! Well, we found it! I took my daughter here for lunch yesterday and not only was the food amazing, but the customer service was awesome and the owner was super friendly. They even offered to cut up the pizza for my daughter. It was so good I had to have my husband try it so here we are ordering one day later. Again, the best customer service over the phone, especially considering it's a Saturday night. The girl on the phone was patient and very nice. I won't be ordering from anywhere else! We are so happy we found a great place that values its customers and has great and hard working employees! Also a super nice dining area!

Hungry? Come here! I love Tosco’s my favourites are the penne a la vodka pizza, chicken caesar salad and my new fav is the fried dough it’s dangerously delicious ❤

If I could give this pizza 100 stars I would! Like... omg. The crust to cheese to sauce ratio is perfection at it's finest. This is where I'll get my pizza from now on. 🤌🏽

QUALITY pizzeria! CLEAN environment,courteous staff. Fresh food, large portions,excellent prices. Was impressed that even their side salad was excellent. Something I would put together for my own family. Dark greens,cherry tomatoes, cucumber, roasted red peppers and onions. They care about quality and excellent customer service.

Excellent quality food for reasonable prices. Best roasted red peppers around, and they add them to pizzas and salads. So good I don't need dressing with the salads. Pizza sauce is the perfect blend of sweet and tangy. And the garlic knots are made fresh daily.

BEST PIZZA IN THE LOCAL NEW WINDSOR NY AREA. THEY MAKE THE BEST FRIED DOUGH PLUS THE CHICKEN BACON RANCH PIZZA IS UNREAL. LOVE IT.
Sal the owner is the nicest man I've met for years now. I've bought from his business for over 10 years. He has 4 or 5 restraunts in the local area. All are excellent.

You guy have the best lasagna by FAR...besides mine lol! It is very flavorful, WELL put together and the SALAD 😍! Your drivers are always so polite! I usually don't do reviews but you guys deserve it. Keep up the good service 😀👍

Great subs! I go here routinely, or get subs delivered. Pizza slices look good too, although I have only had them twice. One was great, one was okay.

I'm new to the area but Toscos is hands down my favorite local pizza joint. I respect them like I respect Chick Fil A. If Toscos messes up on my order, the truth is I messed up on my order and they give me what I deserve. Delicious and fantastic.

Their mozarella sticks were amazing. Perfectly done every time. Chicken bacon ranch, they do amazingly! Been going here since I was a kid. BF and I order from here weekly. The mozzies are better with no parmesan so make sure to tell them if you want no parm. Best place in New Windsor! Thanks Sal!

We love love love food here. Best pizza place in town, and the prices are great!! My go to pizza place from now on! Also the girls at the counter are always super friendly and helpful!! A++ y'all!!

Came here for a bite with my friend . Ordered a penne slice. Every bite had me close my eyes (no exaggeration) their penne slice is the best I have ever had. Girl behind counter very nice. Will definitely order from here now on !

When I was a kid I loved that sal and his wife who owned Sal's . They are very friendly and inviting.I always felt they make there food with love and the freshest ingredients. From all the pizza places around New Windsor NY Sal's wins my vote for best pizza ever made. I love the sauce the cheese they would perfectly put them on evenly on any of your order. I am sad to see Sal's pizzeria giving there place to tosco's pizzeria. I hope tosco's keeps a few of Sal's recipes on there menu . If you do please call it Sal's tradition and under it is a few of there items from there last menu. That would be great to honor them in that way because they told me they where at that location for longer then I was alive. I will miss Sal's but tosco the main thing I like is how you changed the inside but when winter comes please keep the only 2 benches from Sal's !!! Plus Sal's I thank you for always excepting me giving you just change for my meal if I bought anything from you and I hope we were your #1 best neighbors and consistent customers ! Goodbye Sal's I will miss you!! But thank you for all those wonderful and tastes years of Italian food . Goodbye Sal's pizzeria 😥. I would like to give a shout out! Tosco's pizzeria Welcome to the neighborhood🙂.