American Pie Pizzeria

Diet bike family owned well respected.

Stopped here by chance passing through. I still brag about the pizza every chance I get. Absolutely amazing. Looking forward to the next time I'm in the area.

That is the best Pizza in Barnsville. That will be my Christmas meal ! For sure ! Nice customer service too. Again really good fresh Pizza ! 100%

Pizza is some of the best around. The dough is great, not too thick and not too thin. The toppings are always plentiful - something other Pizza places tend to skimp on. Love their Greek Salad and "Betty Salad." Always seem fresh and taste great. They are a little more on the "expensive side" of local options, but you pay for what you get. The food here is worth it to me. Lastly, the cinnamon butter balls....they're sooooo good if you have a sweet tooth and don't mind the extra calories. There's a drive up window too, which is convenient for picking up call in orders.

Had never eaten here before.. the pizza is really good. You can tell it's a handmade pizza as the crust was uneven not like the big chain style crusts. The ingredients were plentiful and staff was very nice. We will be back!!

Great family atmosphere! The prices are affordable and the pizza is great! The customer service is outstanding.

Very nice pizza place very good pizza I'll stop there again

I drive 30 minutes to get this pizza and never regret it. Hands down the best pizza and best local pizzeria in the area. I honestly compare it closest to the pies I got in NY years ago, and it holds up well. All that, and it's not overpriced compared to chains and definitely most local pizzeria. They even still have a buffet which is a miracle in these times and blows the comparables out the water. They did seemingly change a recipe on their Butterballs recently and I feel the previous iteration was more natural as compared to the new one, but it still doesn't detract from them.

The $6.99 pizza buffet was the best! There garlic knots are amazing. Plus they have pretty good variety of pizza. The staff are very nice, I was helped immediately and even asked if I had special request a far a pizza I wanted on the buffet. They also had a dessert pizza which was so good. It had cinnamon, sugar and icing. Overall, this place is great quality as far as pizza and price.

For the first time in many years of service there was a mix up . The staff went out of their way to make it right and boy it was the best pizza ever! Thanks for your continued grade A service , great job ,and thank you! Best pizza in this town ,and best crew of people . Thanks Kelly!

If you are looking for a decent pizza buffet with a decent selection of pizza, this is a good place for that. I have never been disappointed with the food here, but some should note this is probably the greasiest of the pizza you can get in Barnesville. If you're a local who still hasn't come in to the new location, don't worry the quality hasn't changed. A couple of issues to note. 1st and this is a big one for me, the new location has tons of space, but the buffet area (where you get your pizza) barely if at all utilizes that space, so just like in the old location it can get very, very congested when multiple people are trying to partake of the buffet. Next, the seating. There are only so many seats with normal back supporting chairs (drastically more than the last location which is a marked improvement), if it's crowded you are going to have to sit at a stool which might cause some discomfort for many customers. My favorite slice? Chicken bacon ranch.

We had a great time. The pizza buffet was amazing!! The bbq chicken was my favorite. It included a drink and dessert pizza. Staff was very friendly and this is a local hang out place. Saw lots of folks we knew while we ate.

The young lady, Amber, made sure we had our food while it was still hot and fresh. We didn't wait long and it was so good

I live in NYC and I've had pizza from all sorts of places, made by almost every type of way. However, while visiting my brother in Barnesville for the holidays we tried out this place. Hands down the very best pizza I've ever had! Not exaggerating. I've been back in NY for about a month now and I'm still craving for this pizza! 10 Stars if I could!

This is some of the best pizza in Georgia. The crust is fantastic and the toppings can be more than just your basic pie. When this place moved, I could not figure out where it was for years. I didscovered it again last week and have fallen in love again with the butterballs and chicken bacon ranch style pizza. I would recommend this place for parties of 1 all the way up to parties of 20. They have a great ammount of space to host you and you will be singing American Pie as you leave.

Love stopping here when its pizza night or eating lunch at the buffet. They offer the best pizza selections. The ingredients are so fresh, and the butter balls are so yummy! They also have a lot of discounts and specials they run. Definitely recommend this pizzeria if you have not had it before!

Best pizza place in town to me honestly ! We always order the large 24” pizza with a cinnamon pizza and let me tell you the cinnamon pizza is the best !! We’ve only had the pepperoni and Hawaiian pizza and they’re both good . Family oriented, friendly staff . Definitely check them out .

Consistently good, restaurant is always clean as a whistle, and the teens who work there are nice and keep busy (I never see them ignoring customers just to chat with each other or look at their phones). Our kids love it and so do we. Thanks for a great place we can keep coming back to, American Pie!

Great pizza!! Crust is very good!!

I was concerned because the taste and quality had begun to go downhill. It seems things have picked back up. My last two orders have tasted great