Antonio's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant

Literally THE BEST pizza place in West Milford!! Not an exaggeration whatsoever. We’ve tried multiple places in town and could never find good dough! They make it perfectly thin and crispy. Freaking delicious. Every bite. We just ate a whole pie (2 of us) and I want another one already!!🤰🏻finally found a great place for pizza. My world is complete. 💖 thank you!!

Ordered late night and was extremely impressed. Every single item we ordered was delicious, especially the bruschetta salad. I was surprised by the other reviews on here because the customer service, delivery time and pizza was excellent. Happy to support a local business. Will definitely be ordering again!

People have given bad reviews based on the delivery service. But I pickup, so my opinion is based on quality of their pizza alone. Which the tavern pizza is very good. It's a specialty for me as no one else has it in the area. Nice folks as well.

I love this place both to eat in and for takeout. Antonio's has great food, with many healthy options and an attentive and friendly staff. My husband and mom both really enjoyed the chicken parm dinner and I love their crispy brick oven bar pies. They even have gluten-free and cauliflower crust, too! I look forward to coming back again again.

Best all around. I love their dinners and are authentic Italian restaurant style. Their Penne Vodka is unmatched from any pizzeria. I have two pizzerias near me and yet chose to take the drive to Antonios.
Their scrimp scampi is amazing as well. I highly recommend it , in fact am ordering from then today again...

I had gotten a Cajun Shrimp Salad and homemade balsamic vinaigrette.
The salad was fantastic, the shrimp tasted amazing and the vinaigrette was absolutely the best salad dressing I've ever had. Also very reasonable prices and nice staff. Will be ordering more in the future.

So happy I discovered them today, pizza ingredients tasted fresh and the overall quality was impressive for the price. Will definitely order again.

We've tried their chicken parmigiana, cheese sticks and a pizza. All were delicious and well made. The delivery guy (properly) wore a mask and was very respectful.

I love this place, great pizza, love their salads and paninis. Friendly staff and good prices.

Great food and great service. New favorite pizza place in west milford.

Great pizza and amazing meals prepared. Very fair pricing

Great pizza joint
Friendly owner
Good crust
Fast delivery

The food is excellent.

A brand new pizza spot? Yes, we gave it a try already. We are still looking for that magical margherita pie! This past week, we gave Antonio's Brick Oven Pizzeria a try. We ordered the margherita and upside down Sicilian aka Grandpa style (very excited to see this on their menu).
Overall, its always great to see a new independent pizza place open up to try "something new." The customer service was okay... they were a llittle confused and had a tough time working their "cash register," again, a new place, new employees... we get it. Most importantly, let's talk pizza.

Up first, the Grandpa aka upside down Sicilian. The freshest dough we have tasted so far. Picture that perfect Italian bread you've had straight from a bakery... this was exactly that. A nice crispy layer at the bottom and very, very, very, soft in the middle. The mozz cheese was melted perfectly right on the the dough with a good amount of sauce on top. There was a hint of seasoning; parmesan cheese sprinkled. Overall, a very fresh pie. The only negative was that the seasoning and sauce was missing some flavor but the freshness makes up for this. If this pie had a stronger flavor, without question, this would be in the top 3 of Grandpa Sicilians, thus far.

Up next, the margherita. Wow. Nailed it. Let's start with the sauce because there was a significant difference with this sauce and the Sicilian pie sauce. Very fresh, you can tell that this did not come out of a large can. There was a hint of fresh garlic, olive oil, and the cherry on top... fresh tomatoes! The basil was baked on, the fresh mozz was spaced out perfectly revealing the fresh sauce. The crust - some may want this to be thinner but it was a traditional size crust that you would see on a plain slice. Again, very fresh dough so we did not mind the thickness of the slice.

A GREAT JOB, Antonio's! You have nabbed the top spot as our favorite margherita pie in North Jersey so far! We'll be back!

We are new to the area and we're delighted to have found this wonderful spot. Ingredients were super fresh, particularly the over the top broccoli rabe! Service was ok, and pizza was made to order and obviously fresh.

Place is permanently closed

We have had pizza from here previously and thoroughly enjoyed it. Owner is very friendly. A bit disappointed this evening as I went there to quickly buy a chicken parm hero. The length of the sub was at least 12 inches. The contents didn't thrill so much. The chicken was paper thin and the bread overwhelmed the meat. The breading top and bottom was thicker than the chicken