Tocolo Cantina - Garden City

Stopped by for a meal before a trip and was pleasantly surprised. Seated fairly quickly and overall exceptional service. The bartender made an excellent margarita... the blended lychee bits was a great idea, the therefore more natural taste is so much better.
Food was great especially the chicken wing appetizer but personally the best part of my meal was the tres leches dessert and the churros with the goat milk caramel sauce... highly recommended...
The place got really busy but the staff seemed to pull through without noticeable complaints... people just kind of helped each other out.
The decor and overall look of the place is great as well. I'd definitely come back if I were to come to the area again for what it's worth.

Came here to grab a quick bite while out shopping. The place spacious and the seating is roomy. Which is something I appreciate. We sat in a booth. The waiter was very helpful and attentive to our needs. She was able to answer all questions asked and made great suggestions.she informed us that it was happy hour so we got a round of margaritas. Baby when I tell you them drinks hit the spot. They were perfecttttt. It’s been a while since I tried a new spots margaritas and liked them.

I wasn’t really hungry so I opted for the garlic wings “well done”. The wings were delicious. I was very impressed. We also ordered the guacamole and that too was delicious my sister ordered the loaded nachos and was unable to even finish them she said it was good as well.

Over all I was pleased and would like to thank the waitress for her hospitality. I believe she said her name was BB.

I will definitely visit again. Especially with the Trader Joe’s so close 😎

This was an AMAZING find for us!! Strolling at the Westbury Plaza, the light hunger took us to this place and their menu had good Veg options, so decided to try it. The service was quick and the complimentary Nachos-Salsa was greattt! The Enchiladas we ordered were beautifully served and tasted even better! Would definitely recommend it to everyone.

My husband and I were craving Mexican food and decided to try Tocolo since it was the only restaurant nearby. We were a bit skeptical at first since it appeared to be more of a commercial side and we usually prefer authentic Mexican cuisine. However, we were pleasantly surprised to find that the food was not only delicious, but also authentic and well-portioned, all at a reasonable price. The ambiance was cool and the staff were nice. We've definitely found a new go-to spot!

Definitely have the burritos

We decided to stop by late last night and were pleasantly surprised by the efficient service and delicious food. To kick off our meal, we ordered guacamole, queso fundido, and nachos, and all of them were fantastic. Both my wife and I went for the steak fajitas, which turned out to be really tasty, and the steak itself was wonderfully tender. We also enjoyed the virgin Margaritas, which were quite good. All things considered, this is definitely a place worth trying out.

Excellent quality food and service. The inside decoration is very beautiful. Outdoor seating at dinner time is also amazing.

Came here around 6pm on a Saturday. We were seated, and warm nachos with salsa were brought to our table within the minute. I don’t remember his name, but our server was wonderful. He checked up on us several times, and made excellent food and drink recommendations. We ended up getting the overloaded nachos, Baja fish and birria tacos, along with the hibiscus margarita. The food was fresh and delicious! The margarita was STRONG! The service was top notch here! Thank you for the great experience! Will definitely be coming back!

Came here for dinner on a Monday evening with a reservation, but definitely didn't need one. I got their chocolate Chile old fashioned to start which was delicious, and I can be a little snobby about a cheaply made old fashioned, so this one passes the test. The complimentary salsa and chips are good, and were only elevated by the guac that we got with it, the classico, but I was tempted to go with the yucateco. We got the carnitas burrito, which was tasty albeit a little messy to eat with the sauces on top, the chicken tortilla soup, which even on a warm day was still good, and a side of yucca fries which comes with an incredible dipping sauce. Portions are generous and for the price feels like a great deal for what we got. Staff was very friendly, just wish they came to refill water a little more often. Ambiance is nice, and a cute spot for a date or just a nice dinner where you actually can hear the people you're with! Parking in the shared lot in front is pretty ample but it can fill up pretty quick with all the stores around.

We were a bit skeptical at first since it appeared to be more of a commercial side and we usually prefer authentic Mexican cuisine. However, we were pleasantly surprised to find that the food was not only delicious, but also authentic and well-portioned, all at a reasonable price.

Great location and great customer service. Went for dinner last night and it’s been on my bucket list to attend. You have the option to eat indoor and outdoor. The food is great and the food isn’t far behind it, I mean it’s amazing point blank. I would say it’s over priced Mexican food but that’s you to decide. We ordered a fajita for 2 and 1 kids quesadilla and the birria tacos “ appetizer” and 2 sodas and 1 virgin piña colada for $106 plus tip.

Loved everything about this place - atmosphere, food, drinks, service. In a great area too. Guacamole and margaritas were amazing.

Our favorite neighborhood comfort food place. Consistently good food. Attentive service. The cocktails and Tequila flights are just perfect every time.

The food here was delicious. Staff was very friendly and promptly seated us. I was able to make reservations on my phone and received a text message confirmation immediately. The restaurant uses adequate social distancing. Lastly, the food was delicious.
WISH THE BATHROOM WAS CLEANER.

Service is great I enjoyed a lot eating here they had great atmosphere

A great little place in the Gallery Strip Mall in Westbury. Quality Mexican food. The drinks were fresh and strong. The chips are warm, thick and crunchy. Homemade salsa. Good sized portions. Nice looking bar too.

Great Staff ❤ food , drinks and service . Love the tacos ! Phoebe and Andy 🥰great mixologists

Lovely place, and as soon as we sat down, there were chips and salsa on the table along with water. We stopped by to grab food before shopping at trader's joe, and this was right next door. The food was tasty and the service was good, though i think it was a little overpriced for the amount of food.

Experience:
Went in for quick business lunch with a friend and was seated right away. Service was really good and efficient: waters were refilled right away and food came out in order and on time. I truly wish all restaurants are like this in terms of service.

Food:
For starters, we ordered the guacamole and chips and tortilla soup and our entrees were the birria tacos and carne asada rice bowl. Everything tasted delicious.

Overall:
Well priced, delicious food, and great service. I would come back again 10/10.

Tried this place for the first time, food was amazing!! We tried the Yucateco guac, cascabel chile wings, and chicken tacos. Everything was really delicious! Will definitely come back!

Fresh and delicious tacos 🌮
Nice frozen margaritas and relaxing atmosphere.