O'Malley's Lakeside Tavern

As soon as I walked in here I felt like "I was home." It is so cozy! The staff are extremely friendly, the food was delicious, but our favorite part was being able to walk out onto their dock and enjoying the view! I definitely recommend stopping here!

Food was amazing!! Views were fabulous! Service was fabulous! Great spot to grab a bite while doing a wine tour!

Arrived at 6:20 via boat and had drinks and dinner at the bar. Had the Thanksgiving Wrap that was made specially for me since I have a shellfish allergy, it was very good with side of great Mac and cheese! Burger was also very good as Well! Good atmosphere, music, location and new beginnings to a wonderful location. Can’t wait for the tiki bar and live band by the dock! Cayuga lakeshore living, cheers 🚤🌈🌞
It is not the same but change is good. All the best to Steve in Myrtle beach, the foundation was set!

The menu has totally changed since my last visit about 1.5 years ago - loved the meal and the ambiance. They were also very accommodating for my food allergies. Will definitely be coming back!

The atmosphere is fantastic, being right on the lake! It is a fun, happy, laid back and welcoming environment. The staff are so friendly and quick to help with whatever they can!
The food is consistently excellent each time we go! Best burgers and shrimp tacos we have ever had!! Salads are fresh and full of flavor! Wings are delicious! If you’re looking for a fun casual place to enjoy great food on the lake, look no further! We don’t live close by to here but it’s absolutely worth the drive!!

Super cute pub! Service was fast and piping hot. Very yummy! We had the fish and chips. Fish was wonderful and fries were seasoned well and crispy. Came with coleslaw that was also yummy!
Great experience!

Great hospitality by Phil, Olive, and Amy. Such a welcoming atmosphere that the bride-to-be all but demanded we return before our trip’s end. Food (small but elevated tavern menu) was prompt and flavorful, a pleasant surprise. Impressive drink selection, quaint wooden bar. Plenty of outdoor seating within walking distance of the shore.

Staff, especially Kyle, was very friendly and helpful. Good selection of wine and beer. Empanadas, tacos, Mac and cheese, and fries were delicious. Live music was enjoyable to listen to. Great environment, definitely recommend.

Bartender Brandon was the best! The garlic parm wings were perfect. Side salads were huge. Black bean chipolte burger was fabulous. loaded tater tots were great, too.

Absolutely amazing place!! All staff members are so friendly, there is so much care put into the whole experience. Food is incredible! Highly recommend the fried chicken, mac n cheese is also delicious. Plus, the lake view is gorgeous. Very different from the previous O’Malleys. Will 100% be coming back!

This was our first visit since the new owners. We had a lovely lunch. We've been going there for the last 20 years or more. Great to see it open again

Great spot. Busy parking lot which is always a good sign. Outdoor seating available. Right across the street from the lake. Friendly staff. Fair prices. Cool cabin vibe.

The food was amazing and the staff was so friendly and accommodating. Highly recommend for a good meal and friendly atmosphere

Wonderful to have this great location reopened and under new management that's doing their best to to deliver a quality experience. The addition of a bar on their deck is brilliant and makes a huge improvement. Their menu has been right sized and features better selections. The staff is friendly, fast, and committed to keeping the good times rolling.

Wow!! What an amazing place to relax and enjoy great food and drinks! Such a transformation!! Great hospitality and you can see how much hard work was put into making this place what it is today!! So thankful to have another fantastic place on the lake to visit!! 10/10!!!

Great food, service, and atmosphere with beautiful senic views of the lake and docking available 😀

Stopped here on a whim on my way back from a random finger Lakes Road trip… Lobster rolls are amazeballz!! And my margarita is pretty damn good too!!!

Very nice, relaxing place to stop while visiting the winery's. Gorgeous views. The food is very good and our server was great!

Great food! Very ambitious menu. It was the best lobster roll I've ever had. No joke.

Built like a rustic hunting and fishing cabin, this place has a great bar and lots of seating for lunch and dinner - including spots outside overlooking Cayuga Lake. A bit off the beaten path it's well worth a stop here if you're out touring the wineries on the lake.