Borrello’s Pizza And Pastaria

Very good meal! We stopped by after a walk on the beach nearby. I highly recommend. I love to cook myself, and can recommend this place. The food is made fresh, completely homemade.

Fabulous meal. Shrimp Alfredo isn't on the menu but they personally made it for me. Generous portion, and oh so good!

Cool family owned pizza place; They've got some brews on tap too. They sell impossible burgers here, which are pretty good and serve drinks with paper straws. Vegans got burgers down.

Delicious! The best thing crust pizza in SB. So yummy. Don' t miss out, this place is a 10. Very family friendly. Small but well curated wine menu.

Loved the casual atmosphere. The restaurant was filled with family pictures dating back 100 years and the owners treated us like family. The food was made to order and the service was great. The clam chowder and lasagna were fabulous!

Great restaurant. Nice outside seating. Fantastic pizza and great glass of wine. Also had great service. Really a relaxing environment. It's now called thario's kitchen which threw us off a little in locating the restaurant which is on santa Claus lane. Highly recommend this place!

The best Italian food ever. We loved the lasagna and there's always something delicious on the specials the food is top-notch and the desert is worth every single calorie. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable and just downright nice. This will be my stop anytime I'm in the Carpinteria area

Food was good and really inexpensive; we are from out of town and the main reason we always come back is the friendly atmosphere and awesome service. I'm assuming it's a family run business and they definitely make you feel like one of their own! Highly recommend!

Charming restaurant visited with family and friends. We all loved our pizza and pasta choices; the waiter and chef were very personable and took great care of us. I highly recommend you visit for a lovely evening.

New team, really delicious authentic Italian food. Lasagna was delicious. I usually do lot care for bolognese and it really impressed me. Salads and pizza were also really high quality and really good.
Really worth it.

THE SLICE, and Spaghetti with Sausage, had fresh Basil. Garlic toast, oh and the salad fantastic the food was absolutely fantastic. Location, right on the beach. The walls had the "hole in the wall" Look. Very nice. Prices were very good. :)

Five stars from us... we happened upon this restaurant and were very pleased. The food was awesome, fresh and authentic Italian. We met the owner who was very inviting. Anyone traveling through Carpentaria or living there they must give it a try. We will definitely be back.

Decided to stop on our way up to Pismo. Glad we stopped here. Worth every penny and every bite. Food is excellent... Fresh.. And absolutely delicious. The Futtucine Primavera was soooo good!
The pizza was great!
On our way back from Pismo we shopped again and picked up pizza to go.. My girls and I absolutely loved it.

If you're like me, a business traveler who rarely risks a local place anymore because so many are just awful; this is the exception. Nice people, prompt service, relaxed place and excellent food. Seriously considering getting a meal to go for tomorrow because they're closed.

Awesome food, and an all around fun little place. We randomly stopped in on a drive up the coast, shortly before closing, and the staff was super accommodating! I would definitely stop again!

Had Lasange and Pizza which was both very very good and authentic Italian food. Lasagna took 30 mins which means it was freshly made - awesome! Service was good too. Lovely place.

Really authentic Italian food and delicious! Staff were lovely and very attentive. If u love Italian food, you'll love this place!

Best gluten free pizza I have ever had!! Service is excellent. A must while you are Carpinteria, or passing through.

Great food, friendly service, and it's dog friendly. Our waitress was so nice, the atmosphere was relaxed and very welcoming.

I love this place it's nice tha food it's so good everything its home made and the owners are amazing nice people this place it's a place for everyone kids love to be there and go inside the kitchen they also have board games to play it's like a perfect place to be with anyone family friends love it 🥰😘