Lancaster Cupcake

Always enjoyed the cupcakes at Lancaster Cupcake and my most recent visit did not disappoint!! Soft serve ice cream is my favorite, so I was excited to try theirs. In addition to an assortment of cupcakes, I had the birthday cake and strawberry soft serve ice cream. Not too sweet, creamy, and absolutely divine!! I don't usually have favorites of anything, but I can confidently say that was my favorite soft serve!! The employee helping me was also helpful, kind, and patient. I live out of town, which may be a good thing bc I'd probably come here every day with how delicious everything is!!!

We love Lancaster cupcake! We've gone here multiple times and the cupcakes are delicious! I highly recommend the strawberry champagne cupcake - it's superb. And all of the other flavors are great, too. You can't go wrong with any of them!

Also, the atmosphere of the downtown location is nice and cute. There's also another location about 10 minutes away. Either location is great!

Best cupcakes and milkshakes ever! Even the vegan cupcakes are delicious and I’m not vegan.

Updated Review:
Lancaster Cupcakes Shine’s Again!!
It was my 2nd time ordering these beautiful cupcakes as a gift and the experience was as wonderful as the first time! Natalie, Ray and Lucy at the West Orange Street location are truly angels on earth and their attentiveness, guidance & kindness shined thru with each conversation we had!! Natalie went above & beyond to ensure that my besties who live in Lancaster received the most special Valentine’s Day gift & had the sweetest day!! I am extremely thankful & grateful for the exceptional experience that I continue to have with “my girls” at Lancaster Cupcake on West Orange St!! They have a gained a loyal customer from NYC!! Happy Valentine’s Day!!!

Previous Review:
I had the most wonderful experience ordering Lancaster Cupcakes as a New Year’s gift for my best friend!! Being from NYC, I had no idea where to order cupcakes from in Lancaster and was so very grateful that a friend of mine recommended Lancaster Cupcakes on Orange Street!! It was TRULY a joy working with Lucy and Natalie!! Their warmth, kindness, graciousness & professionalism made the entire experience phenomenal!! The cupcakes were delivered on time and looked absolutely BEAUTIFUL & my friends were THRILLED to have some Lancaster Cupcakes to ring in the New Year!! THANK YOU Natalie & Lucy for all of your help!! You now have a new fan & loyal customer from NYC!!! Run….don’t walk to Lancaster Cupcake on Orange Street!! You won’t be disappointed!! With much gratitude🙏🏽🥰🧁💖🥂💖

Love love love Lancaster Cupcake! Their cupcakes are fantastic by themselves, and getting one as an ice cream split or as a cake shake (like a milkshake) is an absolute treat! They also have cake decorating kits you can buy for special occasions or just because! The service is always wonderful and the inside seating area is cozy! Absolutely recommend for some of the best cupcakes in Lancaster!

My wife and I just got married in October, and we wanted to have Lancaster Cupcake provide our dessert. They gave us a spread of 4 delicious varieties, and they were the hit at the end of the night! Super moist, very flavorful… most of our guests had a hard time deciding which to get! Thank you LC for making our special day that much more special!

Very nice shop! We stumbled upon it while in Lancaster and stopped in for coffee and cupcakes of course! Cupcakes are in fun flavors, were delicious and beautifully made. The shop has comfy seating and is bright and welcoming. The employees were friendly and pleasant. You can get a latte, hot or iced, which we did and they were both made well. Highly recommend!

I highly recommend Lancaster Cupcake. I just had DoorDash delivery with them and it was the best DoorDash delivery I’ve ever had. Not only is there store Q and their customer service awesome but they also make their delivery just as cute. But the most important thing is they make sure the cupcakes are very secure so you actually get everything that you paid for looking just like it should be. This is one of my favorite places in Lancaster and I would love to thank them for their awesome customer service and just been lovely all the way around.

We stopped by the Orange Street location to pick-up 24 mini cupcakes for our granddaughter's seventh birthday and we decided to get something for ourselves. The shop is very cute and cozy. It felt warm and inviting. There are a couple of nice comfortable seating areas where you can enjoy your treats. The staff were all very friendly, patient (there are sooo many choices!), and outgoing. The cupcakes are out-of-this-world. I was told that they were good, but never did I imagine...
We will definitely go back. Parking in downtown Lancaster on a rainy Saturday morning was challenging but it was worth it.

I just ate a Pot o Gold cupcake from here and I'm about ready to drive 2.5hrs to come for more! 🤤🤤🤤 OMG!!!! The service over St.Patricks Day weekend was also phenomenal! These girls are quick and very attentive.🙌 If there more more STARS to give THEY WOULD GET THEM ALL!!!🤩🤩🤩🤩 I'm drooling! 🤤 I'll BE BACK for sure!💯😋🤤 BEST CUPCAKE I EVERRRR HAD!

OMG !!! Such amazing cupcakes!!! We bought 6 and received a discount for each cupcake. Every cupcake we bought was absolutely delicious!! Staff was so helpful. Iced coffee was delicious. Best cupcakes I have ever had . !!! Must go and visit this place !!!

All I can say is OMG!!!!!
These cupcakes are sinful!!!
You have to stop by and grab yourself a cupcake or several...you'll hate yourself if you pass this little sweet gem by.
It is such a sweet and whimsical cupcake shoppe with lots of goodies!
The staff is as sweet as their goodies!
Stop in and give your mouth a taste bud dance of delicious flavors!

Great cupcakes!🧁
We love the Carrot cake and Coconut ones!

This is a great place to have dessert and a cup of coffee. Highly recommend the cupcake split.

Highly recommend Lancaster Cupcake! The cupcakes are delicious and they offer a revolving menu of seasonal and specialty flavors. I love the strawberry champagne cupcakes :)

We got the strawberry champagne cupcakes and we wish we would have gotten more than 2. They were sooooo good! We also got our dogs the dog cookies. I'm sure they will love them also :)

The service was great also!

What can you expect when visiting Lancaster Cupcake? Just Amazing cupcakes !!!! Their flavor is very good and they have so many options to chose from, they offer Vegan options, not that I would choose those, but just letting you know.

You can sign for their frequent customer program and after purchasing several of those you will get a Free Cupcake, Yes.. FREE. Its easy to get to the free one if you eat as many as I do.

Im not a huge hot drinker (coffee or tea) so I cannot talk about their drinks, just that they smell great.

I recommend you this place 100%.

Pet friendly place!

Strawberry Champagne Bar Cake ($4.95)
Delicious!!

Salted Caramel Frudge Milkshake ($5.25)
tasty, rich and flavorful

Pup Treat Birthday Bone ($3)
Looks cute but my pup didn't like it 🤷🏻‍♀

I LOVED IT!!! The flavors of the frosting is chefs kiss! If you have a sweet tooth you would definitely love it. The whole cupcake was amazing and very cute!! I loved the cream cheese buttery flavor! It’s worth the price trust!

I had a great time at Lancaster Cupcake. My friends got the cupcake splits and I got ice cream, all of which were delicious. They have a wonderful selection of cupcake flavors, and the store is clean and the layout is really cute. A sweet place to visit all in all.