Red Wolfe Inn

Typical bar setting.. it can be noisy. Steaks are served in the dish they are cooked in so you get them hot, five star. Great staff and service. Friendly atmosphere.

The food was incredible. Well trained, friendly, and knowledgeable staff who didn't rush you but were really available for any needs in a packed environment that still had enough room to enjoy the experience without being pushed or bumped into. Portions were more than generous for the price. Well worth the trip. I reserved a spot at the bar for me & my wife and would happily do it again. A truly great place.

All time greatest place for an unforgettable, unbelievable, undeniably fantastic NY Strip steak. This is an unassuming little tavern off the beaten path in Warren County. The waitstaff is super friendly. The appetizers are delicious and I cannot stress enough - if you want a NY Strip done right. Then THIS IS THE PLACE.

Have been coming here for years Either for my birthday or anniversary have never had a bad meal love the ny strip with garlic butter and the Service is always great

First time to this well renowned establishment. Terrific drinks, terrific beer menu, epic steaks! Opened with Mussels, stuffed clams and calamari. All very good, though the calamari was on the stiff side. The rolls brought out were splendid and worked as edible sponges while soaking up the sauce from the mussels. For steak entree I had the New York strip, Alpha cut (16 oz), medium (NY strips range from Wolf Cub [8 oz, $27] to Red Wolfe [48 oz, $115]. Came out almost perfect in the cooking and with a glob of garlic butter (extra $) on top, tasted delicious. Paired with a side of dirty mashed n gravy along with a Chimay, I was more than content by the end of the meal. Our waitress was spot on, and younger support staff are learning. Reservations for 1-5 people are "limited" to 90 minutes and for 6+, 2 hours, but we weren't rushed to leave despite running 15 late. The place is small and spots are practically always accounted for, so needless to say the atmosphere has a party feel. Can't wait to come back!

Small yet inviting atmosphere. Excellent food and service. Been here half a dozen times and it has never disappointed.

Just wow. My expectations were high coming in from all the great things I was hearing and they weren't just met they were exceeded. For being such a small place with only about a dozen tables and bar seating made it feel even more exclusive to be able to get a table there. ( reservations are extremely recommended) the menu has a surprisingly large amount of options but everything sounded so good reading it. Started with the appetizer sampler and all five things were delicious. My entree was a 32 oz New York strip. They have lots of options for the size of steak you want which was really nice. When the steak came I was shocked how thick it was. It was like a true Butcher House cut. It was cooked perfectly, very tender, and not over seasoned either. I did not need any steak sauce but I did try they're homemade steak sauce which came in 2 options. Sweet and spicy. I tried the sweet and it was delicious. For dessert we shared a tres leches cake which was also very good. Overall between the great service we got from our waitress and the excellent quality of food we got made this place a definite new favorite place to dine at. The prices are also Fair and you definitely get what you pay for. Wish I could give it more than five stars.

Came with 8 friends for a Great steak dinner, and it didn't disappoint in the least. This is a place you come for the taste of a top quality steak. They don't go crazy with seasoning that masks the meat up. Old school steak at its finest. Thanks for the wonderful experience

Felt compelled to finally write a review after thinking about last night's meal.

You make the reservation a week out. Think about it several times leading up to the date. Day of the reservation you look forward to it all day. EVERY single time we go it's consistently fantastic. Staff is friendly and attentive.

Our first time almost 10 years ago the couple next to us noticed we were newbies by the fact we were looking at the menu far too long. I'll tell you what they told us. The only choice to be made is size, topper, and cook temp of your NY strip steak. If you want to experiment, do that with the apps :) Make a reservation every time. Miss the days before the facelift/renovation and when the wolves were still out back. Seemed less busy then. Secret's out but good for the Red Wolfe Inn, well deserved.

Looking forward to the next meal already.

This is a great local hideaway. Menu is creative and food is always fresh. Cocktail time is a treat, my husband had an Apple Maple Old Fashion which he loved. Gets busy on weekends so make a reservation so you won't be disappointed.

Phenomenal 24oz NY Strip cooked to an absolute perfection of medium rare. Highly recommend their dirty mashed potatoes, the homemade "sweet" steak sauce, and the stuffed mushrooms! Will be returning here soon!

Food is always amazing my ten year old son loves the rack of Lamb the beef brochets are best app on the menu and if you want a good cut of beef that comes out still cooking on a hot plate it's the place to go I go so much I don't even need to look at the menu best steaks in Warren county

Nice little restaurant we came across while traveling through Warren County. Food was great and the service was excellent. Totally worth the wait if you have time.

The food and service were amazing! By far the biggest steak I've ever seen - cooked perfectly. Appetizers were also excellent, especially the chicken wings. The service from Kelly was amazing! Can't wait to go back.

Great local spot for great steaks and friendly service. Highly recommend!

Wow ! What a great expereince ! If you are looking for a mouth watering steak this is the spot. Kelly was excellent and made us feel right at home . Can’t wait to come back and try the French onion soup.

As always great food, service exceptional. Did not realize Tuesday was wing night so went had an appetizer down the road and came back

The garlic butter on the steak is delicious. I ask to go here for my birthday every year it'd that good

Food was excellent. A little pricey, but nothing unexpected for a steakhouse. The atmosphere is that of a traditional roadside steakhouse. Old school and wooden. Great feel to it.

Surprising popular restaurant needed a reservation for mid week dining. Sat at the bar service was friendly and quick. Got our drink order promptly and ordered our diner. My gold standard test is the cheese burger and I wasn’t disappointed. Great menu choices. Busy place and parking could be a problem. Worth a try.