John's of Arthur Ave.

The best Calzone and some of the best pizza we’ve ever had!! So cheesy and soft and perfect flavor combos. The place had a great aesthetic and super friendly staff as well!
My only complaint is how hot it was in the restaurant due to the ovens- making it an ideal takeout/delivery place but not good for sit-in in hot weather. Probably fine in the winter though! Was the perfect road trip rest stop- will be making coming through Milford to stop here a travel priority in the future when possible.

I want to say a huge Thank You to Colin the owner!!!! You and your staff are amazing!!! We were in Milford again for work from Wisconsin. The staff provide the best customer service so I will always come here to eat!! The pizzas are pure artwork and I highly recommend a slice of the Motown Detroit pizza. I also love the ‘salad’ bowls!!! It does not disappoint! Again, love this place and thanks!!! 💕💕💕

The best pizza! We travel from NJ (passing at least 10 other pizzerias) to eat here. My husband loves the Detroit style pizza, and I love the gluten free cauliflower crust - it is delicious! And the service is incredible!

Hands down best pizza in the tri-state area, I grew up in milford strictly as a Joey's pizza kid but man I have not been back since trying John's, never been disappointed. The graffiti pizza is my all time favorite and their desserts are also amazing especially their toasted almond cake 100% reccomend!!

We live locally and go here all the time. We have celiac disease so we need gluten free. They are able to dress up a gluten free pie shell like no one else. And are able to do the pasta dishes in gluten free as well which are also fantastic!

This is still an excellent pizza place, and I've been ordering from them for over a year. They have a loyalty program that you can sign up for, which lets you keep track of your purchases and get discounts as you go.

They also have weekly specials to get pies at a real reasonable price. I recommend using these!

The staff is extremely friendly, and the atmosphere inside is definitely nice for your typical pizza place.

This is the best pizza in this section of PA that I've tried so far. I recommend!

If you want great food in the heart of Milford PA then this is the place to go. The staff is super friendly, the atmosphere is comfortable and the food is off the charts. Check out John's of Arthur Avenue when your in town for.a great meal

The owner Colin is great. Sam at the front counter is super personable and great at suggestions. The pizza is amazing. It's hard to find good pizza in the Poconos. Their Detroit style is better than any place at the Jersey Shore. I go all the time, highly recommend!

Excellent pizza. Exceptional crust, excellent cheese and sauce, quality toppings. The only thing holding it back from being perfect was it was a bit too greasy. They do have a great selection of pies though. Better than any place by me in Sussex.

Great pizza. Great service. Everybody's polite and courteous. When you order a pizza with double cheese from John's, you GET a pizza with double cheese. Unlike other Italian restaurants in. the. area. Great mozz. and their sauce isn't overly salty where that's you'll taste and you'll need 64oz of water after one slice.

John's is our new go-to pizza shop.

Visiting from the Bronx, I am happy to say the pizza was banging(really good for you older folks) and the staff was friendly. I ordered the chicken bacon slice, crust was crunchy with a perfect balance of ingredients. Wifey ordered the sesame chicken slice. 😛 Money well spent.

Best pizza in the area, no question. And their staff are really helpful and considerate.

Highly recommend their dill pickle pizza ! Don't knock it 'till you try it !!!

Very yummy food! We got their menu in the mail and figured we would give it a shot. Pizza is nicely thin crust; but not too thin. The garlic knots have amazing flavor and homemade! It's not that big inside but it's definitely homey like with the fireplace. Definitely going to go back!

The 21.99 deal is amazing, love it every time. In an area where too many pizzerias overcharge for middle of the road pizza, here you can count on a consistent, quality pie and amazing value on the deal. They have always been well staffed too which helps to keep the service fast and friendly. Highly recommend.

Best pizza ever! Great service as welll 😀

The pizza is fantastic and the prices are good. Cute pizza shop with outdoor seating.

Good food, great service, great prices! The wait staff is awesome in this restaurant. They are a bunch of nice young ladies. They check in often and make sure your every need is met. Caesar salad was good, Broccoli Rabe and Sausages over Penne pasta was also very good. Enjoyed the chocolate mousse cake especially! Will definitely come back again. Everyone enjoyed themselves-both the atmosphere and the food were enjoyable.

Pizza, wings, knots, and soda in a combo deal for around $35. Can't go wrong.

Favorite pizza ! nothing compares. I make sure to go every time i’m in Milford