Old Square Country Store (Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Poly Furniture)

Great selection of unique and quality groceries and goods. Always clean and pleasant staff. Their made to order deli sandwiches are filling and delicious and on homemade bread. We stopped yesterday and they had homemade hand pies as well for the 2nd Saturday of the month. A great lunch stop for anyone travelling along Highway 5.

It's a pretty good little place, they have a pantry that allows you to buy expired goods that are still fine, like frozen things and dry/canned goods at heavily discounted prices.

They also have a fine selection of deli meats and other freshly produced bulk goods. You can get there just down the road from Centerville Walmart.

We just moved in the area and we are so happy we stopped here! They have everything to fresh made sandwiches to Jellies to butter. The ladies were very nice. Store was SUPER clean! We will definitely be back!!

Great place, great people, great food. Jeremy has a heck of a store! Cheers!

Thay make the best sandwich's. Ask about there wraps Thay got ham & turkey any kind of meat & cheese on it! Thay put lettuce onion tomato two kids of peppers to choose from and whatever dressing you want!

GREAT SANDWICHES AND SERVICE. Our family was visiting for 3 weeks and we did our shopping there. There fresh baked bread was awesome.

Very nice store with lots of dried goods, snacks, and delicious cheeses and meats. Great place to get a made-to-order sandwich for lunch or dinner! They have a couple of tables of you want to eat in too! They also have hard ice cream and other snacks and baked goods. Can also get great Amish-built outdoor furniture either on-site, or they will take custom orders. Very reasonably priced and always friendly and helpful personnel. I routinely buy cheese from them and my wife and I, along with other family members, have bought furniture here and have not been disappointed. If you are in the area, I highly recommend you stop by.

Update: Needed some spices for a rub I wanted to try and the store had what I needed as usual. Very nice grocery store to grab bulk staples to restock your kitchen. Deli counter for a wide variety of meats and cheeses.
Update: Visited this morning looking for some sliced deli meat & cheese. Picked up Old Fashioned Loaf, sliced, Roast beef, sliced, and Ghost pepper/Monterey jack cheese. Also picked up some bacon jam and arrow root powder. Love this place!

They have a nice selection of discount foods. Their fresh lunch meats are great! And of course you have the homemade baked goods.

Friendly and helpful employees, and wonderful ice cream!!! Never been there before. But I'll be sure to go back sometime.

We absolutely love how friendly and family oriented all the staff are. Never had a bad experience there.

Always courteous workers and good clean environment with a beggars pantry attached with many discount items

Very quaint store. Had to get some pretties

It’s a cute little store, with plenty of amenities. The ice cream is quite delightful – I recommend the strawberry when they have it. The bulk foods are good, with a huge variety of items to choose from. Lastly, the sandwiches served are often a tasty treat for those that live nearby. The service is generous and very helpful.

I love that little store...it is clean, friendly staff and has a nice variety of grocery items. The lunches they offer is very good and prices are very reasonable. We stop in the store as often as possible as its owned by a young couple just trying to make a living. You will not be disappointed.

This is my favorite Amish country store. So many things that I can't find anywhere else! Great pies, and a huge selection of candies, even breads of various types, and old fashioned cola in glass bottles!

favorite place to stop for an awesome sandwich on the way back from Lake Thunderhead.

The store does have a small selection, however everything was excellent quality. My sandwich had no skimped ingredients and made on home made bread.

I go every chance I get for the mustard pretzels! And the kids an double scoop ice cream! They are always friendly and will chat while serving! Nice not to feel rushed and unwelcome these days!

It is a terrific little store located on the Cincinnati Square, they have about everything you can think of a lot of gluten free products wonderful ice cream, desserts, pies it's like an old-fashioned time store and the people that run it the customer service is awesome anyone coming from Unionville Missouri or Centerville Iowa and other places around stop and enjoy and if he's not stopped yet you need to you're missing out I'd rate it a 10 but you can only go 5 stars. Best little store in our town even if it is the only one!! I love our little store.