Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Proud to say I had my first gelati here. Spent all dsy on the beach and this was a welcome cool down. The staff here were very kind and patient as I tried to figure out the menu. Can't wait to go back l.

You pay a premium for water ice at this location, but I needed my fix. As a tourist, I only order swedish fish flavor...but they have other choices

Rita's is always good. Everything is fresh and tasty. The new owners take their time to make sure that everything you order is correct, this does make the line take longer than you might think but the service is great when you get to the counter so it More than makes up for a slightly longer wait.

My son was heat exhausted, so to cheer him up, the woman gave him one surprise gummy bear on top of his water ice- it’s been 3 weeks and he still plays “ice cream” and “puts” one special gummy bear on top. She made a wonderful impression and only added to our love of Cape May.

Amazing ice and custard. Madison and Avery were a great help, getting my group what they wanted as quickly as possible. Such hard working staff, and they were so polite. Will visit again!

Ritas always has consistent creamy custard mix. Delicious homemade water ice. Their feature flavors like birthday cake and swedish fish are a hit with the kids! Lines can be long sometimes but it's worth the wait. No krunch kote

Delicious ices and custards, friendly service, great prices!

Friendly staff and consistent product expected from Rita’s. Outside of building is a bit run down, but interior seems clean and well-kept.

Friendly staff. Great product. Quick service. Went here 3 times during our vacation and the service, staff and product were all consistent. Recommended for families on Vacation.

A pleasant place to get, and eat ice cream, or water ice. A little room to eat inside, or you can take your purchase on the go. You can get your ice cream in a cup, or cone.

A little expensive for frozen juice, but delicious. The island fusion Italian ice is amazing.

Great custard, fantastic view of the ocean.

Great staff and excellent ice custard creams

Wonderful custard and friendly employees, very busy!

The best water ice, very refreshing on a hot day.

Favorite place in cape may to get a cold treat

Great Ice and Custard at a reasonable price.

Ice cream and service was great

Friendly service.

Fabulous!!! Delicious!!!