Cotardo's Ristorante Italiano

Party of 10 to celebrate a college graduation. Service and food were great. Everyone had a great time. They gave us a last-minute reservation on the day of graduation. Cotardo's is always reliably good.

I came in with a few friends who have never been here before, and they were beyond impressed. The portions, prices, and quality of food were outstanding. Our server Ryan was the best and filled them in on all the details. He made sure we had everything we needed and, though he was very busy he made us feel like we were his only table. Needless to say we were all very pleased.

Went to Cotardo’s today with my family and I had the best Crab Gravy special EVER! This is usually my go to at an Italian Restaurant and Cotardo’s exceeded my expectations. The pasta was cooked to perfection. The clams were delicious and the crab was out of this world. Crab with every bite and the sauce was fantastic. I found out the special was made by Mr. Cotardo himself and what a special it is! I cannot say enough good things about this establishment. The service was also top notch. We will be back again soon.

My family and I have been coming here for years. We typically come as a large party. The most recent experience was with Zach. He greeted us right away with a smile. He was very attentive and very personable. He catered to our every need and never made us feel like a bother. The food was great and everything came out quickly. We'll be sure to ask for Zach on our future visits!

Had a wonderful experience at Cotardos with my family earlier this week. Every dish was delicious, especially the fettuccine, a must-try! And don’t even get me started with their cheesecake! Let’s not forget about Michael, one of the best, most efficient busboys we’ve experienced in a while. He kept our experience here smooth and our table spotless. His helpfulness and friendly demeanor added that extra touch to a delightful dinner. Five stars for Cotardo's and a high five to Michael for outstanding service!

The shrimp Alessandro was so good! This restaurant never disappoints. Even their garlic bread is delicious!

I was introduced to this restaurant in the summer of 2023. It has become my favorite by far. The food is amazing. The atmosphere is amazing though . For the most part we order takeout lately. I get something different almost every time and have never been disappointed. You also get the most value for your money on top of that. I would and have recommended this establishment every chance I get.

We go here once a month for date night! Hands down, the best family, service, staff, seating, atmosphere, and love poured into one small dinner! No matter what we have tried in the menu, it is excellent! We always need take home containers, and love you can byob! We will make this a staple for years to come!

ZACH! Thank you for the great job you did taking care of our large family group for my birthday dinner. Service was spot on with a smile and nothing was too much trouble for you. Made the whole night extra special. Food was also exceptional. Cotardo’s should be thrilled to have you on their staff. Great job. Thank you.

I had dinner last night. The food was phenomenal like always. We had this server Ryan Anton just started not to long ago. It was the best service ever. He was very professional and very attentive. Thank you.

I love coming here whether it’s alone or with a friend . The staff is so welcoming and nice . My experience is always great . Emily is definitely my favorite server . She’s very sweet and attentive . The food is great ! I try to try something different every time . All meals come with fresh garlic bread , soup and salad . Greatly priced and good portions . I would highly recommend .

Go here with my family for dinner. Great BYOB. Lately I've been ordering lunch from here. They have really good deals for lunch, honestly can't beat it. $12 for stuffed shells, their soup of the day, and garlic bread.

I have never done a google review in my life about anything, but for this amazing place I will. Now I don’t have photos to share of the amazing cuisine, but I have a few words to share at least. First the wait may seem long, but Its not. Time will fly trying to get into this place. Secondly, our waiter was amazing! I forget his name but he’s got a man bun lol 😂…He had great manners and spoke very well. He made sure we had everything we needed, food, water, drinks, etc. Lastly food was top tier. We were served bread as soon as we hit the table. Entrees are paired with amazing soup of the day that happened to be the creamy tomato! AMAZING SOUP!!!!!! Along side with a salad. Then came our entrees that were greatly and generously portioned. I had the Spaghetti Carbonara, and my boyfriend had the Tortellini with like a vodka kind of sauce paired with shrimp and scallop. As for appetizer we had the calamari which was amazing. We had walked away with smiles on our faces and my boyfriend saying this is my new favorite place. We will definitely be coming back!

Big portions of amazing food! I ordered pasta with mozzarella cheese and it tasted splendid. I also loved the garlic bread that came when we sat down, it was soft and delicious. Wasn’t too hard to bite into. Waiter was nice and helped deliver food fast. Already took a bite of my food as I took the picture! I’ve been to the restaurant another time before, always good food.

South jersey 5 stars. They make your time there an experience. Complimentary soup and salad with your entrees. Save a solid hour and a half to enjoy it fully. My only complaint is the chicken Marsala was on the sweet side.

Cotardos is one of my favorite Italian restaurants! I have been going here since I was a little kid and it never disappoints! It is my go to. The portions are a great size and you never leave hungry. I love the atmosphere it gives a cozy feeling. Everyone is super friendly and greets with a smile. My server Zach was awesome he was attentive and very friendly. He made sure we had everything we needed and took care of us. I am very happy with my experience at Cotardos.

Zachary was an exceptional waiter. We had a great time especially love the garlic bread. Will be returning soon.

My favorite Italian restaurant to go to. Have been going here for many years now and I am always happy with the food and service. I recommend Zach as a server he makes sure you have everything that you need and is he is very personable and kind.

First time there. Food was to die. Gave you plenty of food. It was 8 of us. And not one of us left hungry. Gave you soup and salad with your meal. And you never feel rush to leave. Waiter was very friendly. And would keep asking if there was anything we needed. My husband and I plan on coming back often. Thank you for a great visit, and we will be back.😀😀

Ate here for the very first time today and have to say the soup, salad and the main dish was amazingly delicious, AUTHENTIC & SUPERB! and the servers were super attentive, friendly and polite. Very highly recommended.