Brother's Pizza II Cape May

Walked in and the slices options were small. What would you like? the owner asks. A Spinach and a Sausage slice. I will make them for you - he says. Cool. I head to the cooler for my pineapple soda and settle down at a table. Super chill. Liking the Nat King Cole music I hear very softly - soothing. I needed to just chill. Soon my delicious slices emerge. We both smile as he was happy to make these just for me. A great lunch. Thank you!

By far one of the best pizza places in South Jersey! The pizza is absolutely delicious and the sauce is fantastic! Also the wings are great! Plus the service is wonderful!! I highly recommend Brothers Pizza 2!

Very nice place , Staff very professional and friendly. The food was amazing , I have shrimps and french fries and a Calzone and it was delicious. Also and important the place very clean I definitely recommend this place. Thanks so much.

Came from San Diego to see my son graduate from bootcamp found this little gem best fresh pizza great simple ingredients!! Yum we took a box to go! We had the margarita pizza with white sauce it has the best taste and pesto and olive oil great crust. Great service super friendly

We went down to Cape May for vacation and saw this pizza place right next to where we were staying. I have to say this was the best decision. The food was so good and the staff was so friendly!!!! Definitely recommend it if you are craving pizza. :)

Have been coming here for years, and have always been greeted with friendly, welcoming service. Their pizzas are made with tasty toppings and the crust is done just right. Wonderful pizza all-round. Picture is from the pizza I ordered to-go tonight.

My family ate here and we all loved it! The staff is very friendly and the food was spectacular!

Such a sweet staff! Pizza was delicious and perfectly done. Thanks for a great dinner!

The Stromboli was one of the best I have ever had it was large, full of steak and cheese
and the crust was perfect A+

This is the first time I’ve had pizza from Brothers……Well, be still my heart! ❤ I’ve found the best pizza in Cape May! Five Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I’ll never go anywhere else!

Simply the best pizza I’ve ever eaten!!!

Always good pizza and close to Cape May Sunset Point.
A great combination for a sunset dinner

There’s gotta be a new owner. Last time I went it was horrible pizza was doughy and not cooked all the way. I stopped by to have a slice before heading to the beach reluctantly because of my past experience but to my surprise it was actually really good. Thin well done slice not greasy at all it was perfect hopefully they keep it up. I have yet to try their other food yet though

Best pizza in West Cape May! Their crust has that perfect crunch when you bite into it. Pure pizza heaven!

Subs were just as good- freshly made to order and they didn’t scrimp on ingredients.

Clean, friendly, seems to take COVID seriously.

My wife and I recently retired in West Cape May. We’ve always been extremely picky when it comes to our pizza. We tried Louie’s, Cappaletti’s, Blue Moon, Jake’s, etc. I mean their pizza is decent but nothing special. Then we tried Brothers. We’d bought other items from Brothers but had never thought about pizza. Well, the joke was on us. Tremendous pizza right under our noses. Consistent, reasonable, and delicious. Our quest for great pie is OVER😀

We recently visited Brothers II Pizza in Cape May. NJ and the service and pizza were excellent. Eventhough we got there near closing time the owner was very gracious and allowed us to sit and enjoy our pizza without feeling rushed. Would definitely go back the next time we go to Cape May.

Love this place! Every summer when we come down to Cape May, we eat here after a long day at the beach. Great food; small, cozy, clean space. Outdoor seating. Staff was wonderful. This one waitress catered to our every need with a smile. I don’t know why they got bad reviews before, but I think they improved a lot.

This is the pizza from which I judge all others. The crust is thin but not droopy or soggy, the tomato sauce is well-seasoned and flavorful, and the toppings are fresh. We shared a pie with onions, mushrooms and green peppers with extra cheese and it was just right with a Cape May IPA. The Chicken Parmesan sandwich was delicious and full of well-seasoned meat and the red sauce and cheese. No big, gluey Chicago style pies for us!

Great pizza ever! Second time back here. The pizza is great, cheesy and saucy. Great customer service, cleaningness is great and employees very nice and respectful. Food is done well and in good temperature. Perfect. We live in New York and we will keep coming every time we are on vacation.

Comfort food to keep you warm even when the summer season is over. Ordered a Chicken Cheesesteak Stromboli and it was extra juicy & cheesy just like I asked. Pulled fresh from the oven & delicious. Owner even made sure I had extra sauce to go with it. Very friendly staff. Will come again!