Cappy's Seaside Pizza & Steaks

This is our preferred Local "Pizza Parlor" as we say in South Jersey. Quality Pizzas with a wide variety of Toppings, tasty Appetizers and some of the best Salads you can get in a Pizzaria... but they keep where they buy their Lettuce a secret! The friendly Staff know like Family since we get Take-out there so regularly.

In my opinion best pizza in Cape May. I stop to get the Buffalo chicken pizza always hot and saucy. I like the place so much that I have their limited-edition tie-dye shirts.

Yom Yom Yom!!! Best pizza in the area of Cape May county!!! Many people have the same opinion, give it a try! You won’t be disappointed!!

I can't speak to any of Cappy's other food, but I ordered a margherita pizza for pick-up and was pleasantly surprised at how good it was. My only complaint is that they advertise "fresh" basil on this pie (which is traditional) and there wasn't any, just dried spices. Nonetheless, it was good, with lots of flavor, and I would order it again. But come on, Cappy's, get some fresh basil leaves. Even frozen leaves would probably work.

UPDATE: Real basil leaves now! Thanks, Cappy's. The pizza was great.

Great service!! Driver went all the way back to the restaurant to get my wife ranch dressing that we forgot to ask for. Pizza was really good too. Very pleased. Thanks Cappy's.

Recently under new management and very lovely customer service! Had an amazing slice of margarita pizza 10/10 would go back again for lunch :)

Best pizza in cape may/wildwood area hands down and exactly what you want from a pizza place in terms of atmosphere

I've always eaten pizza here when I'm up for the week or passing through; now that I'm stationed here I find myself eating here about once a week with my family, expanding out to more than just pizza by the slice.

Pizza by the slice varies greatly depending on the time of day or day itself, but I always find something I like. The cheese steaks are awesome and well sized for the price. Seating area is small but a lot of times we get it to go.

Staff is the friendliest of any Jersey business I've been to. Parking is also pretty awful, but not their fault. Highly recommend for a quick lunch or dinner. Typical beach prices but worth it for the size and quality.

I really liked the pizza. Got here right before closing and I ordered a few slices, they made a whole pizza for us instead, because it was cheaper and fresher that way. The two guys working inside were really friendly and did an awesome job. I was told about this place from a Facebook Veterans page. They do provide a military discount which is much appreciated.

DELICIOUS! Italalin sub is STUFFED and the white garlic pizza and the buffalo chicken pizza are fantastic..nice thin crust that is just crisp enough! Reasonable prices and they deliver. They are also very friendly which is an added bonus! I highly recommend this place.

Cappy’s in one of best pizza places in all cape may county and jersey shore. This is the type of place you go out of your way to go to and should command a line similar to Manco’s in OC or Sam’s in wildwood, it is on that level. The regular plain slice stands on its own as a super quality pizza with amazing dough and crust. You can not go wrong ordering anything and the slices are BIG. But hands down my favorite thing on the Menu is the Broccoli white slice with ricotta. It’s almost always available by the slice and is amazing, a must try.
Summer 2020: Everytime I have been here (and it has been a lot )the whole staff is in masks, they collect payment behind a pelxiglass wall, and practice safe social distancing. They are also happy to walk it out to you if you wait outside.

What a great sandwich.

Thanks again

Awesome food! Fast service for not too pricey. Fun fact : the owner not only runs an excellent restaurant but is also a great math teacher in PA! Love ya Mr Capp! Hard working dude right here.

Wanted to treat kids to pizza night takeout. Excellent pizza! Ordered Phat Johnny, Margherita, plain cheese, a half eggplant parm and half chicken parm combo pizza. Dough good, great ingredients, super nice staff.

great eggplant pizza, veggie pies, great delicious eggplant sandwiches made by roy, delicious everything . im vegetarian. great owner and friendly nice ppl-very nice place i am local year round. great place to sit at old fashioned counter or by windows. also breakfast stuff i think.there is laundromat next door and a wawa so kill 3 birds with one stone on way to beach. cappy opened a 2d place as well a few yrs ago-

We tasted a few different places on the island and cappy's wins for their Margherita pizza. Thin crust and fresh ingredients. Excellent.

The best pizza that I have had since I moved to Florida 9 years ago! I was in Cape May for a couple of days and tried it...Delicious.

Always good!! Home for the holidays 🎄

Best Cheese steak subs. Fair price. Pizza is good bit rather enjoy the delicious sub

Delicious pizza! I always eat here when I visit Cape May!