Amagansett IGA

This place has all your groceries needs when you are in the amagansett area! They have produce to bread to meat to frozen foods! Service was good and the place looks clean. I would have wanted more local goods. But check this place out for food!

Good selection and not too crowded. It’s on the expensive side (like most Hampton stuff) but the prices are not completely insane.

Great store, with a marvelous deli, hot foods, delicious cold cuts and more! Only 7 miles from Montauk village.

This is a grocery store, not a supermarket, but they've actually done a nice job given the space constraints. They have a nice variety of items, definitely tailored to a Hampton's crowd. I feel like they are trying to provide specialty items while still functioning as a grocery store and you'll definitely find items you wouldn't see even in supermarkets. Still, you won't necessarily be able to find everything on your list--you certainly won't find the discount version of everything on your list anyway. Prices are high but not abnormally for the areas/items--I've easily spent as much in King Kullen. The produce is generally fresh and they have a good selection. If you're out for the summer, you'll find items tailored to your needs. If you're a local, this is a good spot to pick something up and bigger than the Montauk IGA, but I still run to King Kullen if I have a really big list.

I absolutely love the supermarket, they always have the products I'm looking for and at great prices and added plus is the butcher you can talk to. he will recommend cuts of meat that are a little different than the normal grocery store cuts that you get out of the fridge, and they are just as good and at a great price. Being able to talk to someone who is knowledgeable about what you're doing is priceless.

Facility is easily accessible with more than adequate parking. A wide variety of merchandise available. Organic fruits and vegetables? Ooohhh yeah, they've got it. Prices are reasonable by Hamptons standards.

A huge thank you to Cirillos IGA Amagansett for their donation to the Montauk, Amagansett, and East Hampton firefighters battling the brushfire by the Walking Dunes and Goff Point (July 2022.) When the IGA manager heard what was happening, he were eager to help. I left with a donated cart full of beverages and ice. If battling a brushfire across marshy terrain wasn't hard enough, its also 90º today. Thank you, Cirillos IGA, for providing ice cold water and Gatorade to the those fighting to save our beloved nature preserve.

High quality food at low prices. This place really delivers amazing food that is backed up by their guarantee.

Always great, due to the times the selection isn't that great, but before that They would have anything and everything! I always shop here! Staff is just as great!

The review by Ben Dover is obviously by a disgruntled employee or one of the really crazy sour people who shop there.....and there are many. Ben Dover does not exist....it is a fake name derived from 'Bend Over' get it? and let me be clear......there are many fussy sour people who shop at the Amagansett IGA who have little difficulty in life and are sheltered by the quite village of Amagansett. They are entitled and few people pay any attention to them which makes them very bitter. These are the people who are hyper critical and enter the store looking for a fight because they have so little going on in their lives.... so tell me who you are Ben Dover because that is not your real name. And grow up.

Nice to have a grocery store here

The staff at the Amagansett IGA has worked so hard over the last few months to serve a huge influx of shoppers. I really appreciate all the effort that has gone into keeping this store running.

Clean, good selection of items, easy on and out.

There is a large variety of quality food and produce here. I found everything I was looking for and more!
Montauk's IGA should follow their example.

Low-key grocery store that has a bit of everything. Wish they had more bread choices though.

The Amaganssett IGA is very good super market it offers a lot of choices at the time of food shopping and it can help you if you do not want to cook with the hot food they sell in the back .

Plenty of groceries in modest space with good lighting, extensive produce section including organics.

Great selection priced for the area. Delicious fruits and veggies.

Excellent market, good selection, pricyer than EH IGA, but higher quality and selection in general

Small but clean an the workers are so helpful an friendly.