Fudge N Stuff

I stopped by today before leaving Montauk to pick up some candies and I am so glad I did. The shop is immaculately clean and the lady that waited on me (who I assumed is the owner) was warm and friendly. The chocolate caramels are absolutely delicious and worth every penny. Be forewarned that it is cash only. I will definitely stop by again the next time I am in the area. Highly recommend!

Very good chocolate. not the friendliest but then again if I had to deal with obnoxious pre-teens all summer I probably wouldnt have a lot of smiles either. It was still worth the 3 hour drive out here to surprise someone with fudge from their favorite shop for their birthday.

The fudge is so GOOD! Like amazing. All the chocolate candies were good, the ice cream was nice. Perfect little spot. Great customer service! They were patient and let us try stuff. Definitely a must visit when visiting Montauk!

I stopped by this place on the recommendation of a someone who lives in the area. I was actually leaving town at the time but I really love great fudge. I raced in, bought a few varieties and left to go home 100+ miles away. The memory of this fudge now torments me. It was SOOOOO good! Creamy texture, fresh crunchy nuts in just the right proportion. The store is quite charming & sells vintage candies and more but I was all about the fudge that night. Any fudge aficionado would be very pleased with this homemade confection. Next time I'm within 30 miles, I'll be back!

Small shop with candy, fudge and ice cream. Best part of my day trip to Montauk from Queens with my girlfriend. We tried a few flavors of fudge and each one was excellent. The mint chocolate is incredible but most of all the red velvet fudge was to die for, easily our favorite. The employees were super friendly as well! All in all I wish there was a queens location but I'd probably weigh 600 pounds. Definitely look forward to my next visit when next I'm out in Montauk!

I like creamy fudge. The BEST l have tasted comes from the candy makers in Fudge N Stuff! Mouth watering DELICIOUSNESS that makes coming out to the end of the Island worth the trip! Won't give away my favs U have to go with your taste buds! Old favorites you won't be able to resist. ENJOY!

Amazing little candy store in the heart of montauk. Great selection of homemade fudge. Great ice cream and fresh popcorn. They also have a great selection of loose candy in jars behind the counter. Salt water taffy is great also

Tried first of four flavor we got today. If you are in Montauk be sure to stop in. Can’t wait to try second flavor tomorrow.

Every year we come out to Montauk and make it a point to visit fudge and stuff. We always pick up fudge for our family and ourselves. There fudge is always so fresh and delicious. Our favorite is cookies and cream and the cotton candy flavor. The staff is always very helpful and nice. I recommend anyone traveling to montauk make a stop and pick some up. I promise you won't be disappointed! Tina and Andrew, Bronxville, NY

Friendly owner and delicious fudge

Lots of fudge, candy, and ice cream choices. All of it, delicious. They only take cash, but ATM in store.

It's been a favorite since childhood - and still great! I recommend the maple walnut fudge😊

It's my favorite ice cream spot because it's my childhood in a store. Nothing has changed for 40 years

Super friendly. Awesome fudge. Fun store for kids

Fantastic! I couldn't stop eating the oreo... It was so creamy and buttery!

Felt like a kid again... ice cream and candy like the good old days

Best fudge I've ever paid for, and a great variety.

My kids love coming here whenever we come to Montauk

Ice cream was amazing, two scoops in a cone on a hot day

Amazing place, people are sooo sweet, I highly recommend stopping by! 💜