The Olive Pantry

What a wonderful experience. Kevin was amazingly helpful and knowledgeable. He had an in-depth knowledge of ALL the products in the store. He shared recipes, use ideas, how things were made, where some of them originated and a terrific enthusiasm and passion for their inhouse creations and the world of oils and vinegars. What a GREAT place to gift shop and put together unique packages. The truffle popcorn was excellent, the ice cream options so unique and delicious. Will most definitely return. Kevin was the absolute BEST!!

I visited a year ago and have received two gifts of the products.
I cherish the olive wood bowls. They are beautiful.
I have kept the empty oil bottles but wonder how to return them for refills. I think I saw this service offered.

Awesome olive oils, vinegars and other goodies. Love their homemade ice cream. The owners are super nice and will let you taste and educate you about all the different types of oils. We will be back for sure.

The Olive Pantry has the best Sesame Seed Oil and excellent olive oils. The owners and staff are sweet, upbeat, and knowledgeable! The popcorn is great too!

It’s really a calming but yet out of this world experience. They blow your mind away with their products and customer service. Most definitely coming back ,it’s definitely a one of a kind experience.

This store is amazing! Wonderful products and amazing customer service. My partner and I don't Buy our Oils or Vinegar's anywhere else. I attached a picture of a meal I made using their Blood Orange Olive Oil and Pomegranate Balsamic vinegar. It is definitely a place to check out. besides you can taste it before you buy it so you can't go wrong.

Seriously this place is AMAZING!!! I bought a few things from there and WOW! This is the best olive oil I have had in this country! Only thing that was close to as good was when I was in a fancy restaurant in France. I highly recommend checking this place out!

Everything I have tried has been impeccable! Our current favorites are the spicy Calabrian pesto oil, Tuscan herb oil, as well as the lemon infused olive oil!
The hummus is amazing, full of flavor! And the truffle popcorn don’t even get me started on how great that is! Kevin is so knowledgeable and a joy to talk to! Wish I could rate unlimited stars! Check them out!!

MY TASTEBUDS ARE EXPLODING…You see, I had gone into the store today & while looking around, Kevin offered me a sample of truffle butter popcorn made with their butter infused olive oil & truffle salt. Sold! The flavors just burst in your mouth. Besides the flavorful products they sell, this store is a MUST to check out and support! Not only was the customer service amazing & Kevin was so friendly to everyone who walked in, but it’s a local family owned store! If you haven’t been yet, don’t miss out! Can’t wait to go back and try more products soon.

The Olive Pantry is the best store in Lake Mary! Their selection of oils, balsamics and all sorts of goods makes them my favorite spot to visit on the weekend. Kevin and the team are always willing to help me pick out the perfect combinations. They are a perfect spot if you’re in need of a gift too! Pro tip: Don’t miss their truffle popcorn. :)

My daughter found this place on the internet and insisted that we go. I have to say, for a fancy oil joint they went above and beyond helping us (people with no olive oil knowledge) to find an oil that was suited for all of our olive oil needs! Kevin was exceptionally helpful and had no issue with getting us samples of both oils and popcorn. Everything we sampled tasted amazing, and we are so excited to try all of our new oil flavors out! It's a place we will definitely be going to again!

The best olive oil and balsamic vinegar available locally. Oils and vinegar from around the world and many are infused with the most wonderful taste sensations such as lemon, garlic, Tuscan herb, red apple and so on. Once you try them you will realize what you have been missing.

High quality products in this cute Lake Mary store. Premium olive oils, flavored vinegars, jams, seasonings and much more. Very friendly staff. Great place for gifts.

I had no idea olive oil or balsamic vinegar could taste so damn good! Seriously… just try it for yourself, they’ll literally let you sample ANYTHING in the store, with NO PRESSURE to buy.

Kevin even snuck a gift into my bag, which I didn’t know until I got home, because I was curious about it. They’re not just an awesome, local, family-owned business, but great people as well.

They just want you to leave their store with an appreciation for quality olive oil and balsamic vinegar, and their mission was accomplished. I ended up with an amazing Neapolitan Herb Balsamic Vinegar for my caprese salads, a Dark Chocolate Balsamic Vinegar to adorn some ice cream, and some Spicy Calabrian Pesto Olive Oil for pasta. They are practically sauces on their own, that’s how flavorful they are.

Just stop in for yourself. Trust me. And ask Kevin about weightlifting and you’ll probably get a free workout program on top of it!

Went in for my first time today. Kevin was very helpful and I was able to sample the different oils. Wish I found this place before Christmas but I will definitely be back. Great for gifts and yourself!

The Olive Pantry is an amazing business with amazing farm grown olive oil! It’s distributed by them but the oil comes from a family farm! We use this oil for our special meals and it just elevates it! Dosent smoke as much as store bought stuff and it’s just yummy! Recommend butter for popcorn, burgers, etc. recommend garlic for chicken or whatever really, recommend lemon for salads and pastas !

What a delightful find! If you love new flavors then this is the spot for you. I love trying new sauces and you can try before you buy. Kevin, on of the owners, has a true passion for exotic flavors that he introduces to you world.
Definitely don't forgot to try some of the most unique home made ice cream around.

I loved absolutely everything about this place. Smells so good as soon as you walk in, products are amazing, and prices are so reasonable! Definitely a wonderful place. Check it out!!

When we, my husband and I, visited a year ago, we were so impressed we decided to visit again.
I absolutely love the olives stuffed with the long and hot peppers. Delicious!

AMAZING place! A must-go for any foodie! The proprietors are absolutely amazing, showing a true passion for their products. I could have spent the whole day talking with them about their incredible oils, vinegars, and spices!