Sugar Crazy

Sugar Crazy is part candy store, part craft kit and toy store, and part camp store. Given the pandemic they also have a large assortment of fun masks and hand sanitizer.

I stopped by because they have a small selection of nut free candy and ice cream (A La Mode). The majority of the nut free candy is from No Whey! (which is free of many other Top 8 allergens) and Sweeties Candy Cottage (these items are labeled with "NUT FREE FACILITY").

The A La Mode ice cream is separate from the rest of the ice cream and they use separate scoopers. In terms of selection/availability, they offer all of the typical nut free flavors (partly cloudy, cooks, speed bump, etc).

Prices are pretty typical for allergen-free products: more than what you'd pay for other candy. Will definitely keep stopping by for my nut free items!

Thank you so much for donating 50 backpacks to United Way of Long Island. What an amazing difference you have made for so many of our local students in need. I am so very grateful - and it was such a pleasure meeting you both! Thank you again!

Visited on 8/6/2022. Amazing selection of candy and cute toys. They also have pre-made chocolate/candy trays to give as gifts. Yes, they are higher priced BUT they are a SPECIALTY store. They have things that you can find elsewhere AND other items I haven't seen in years. Staff were great too. Added to my favorites list.

What an awesome store!! With this new fidget craze with the kids, this is the place to go! Aside from every kind of candy you can imagine and ice cream and clothing and masks and novelty items, the fidget toy selection is second to none!! It’s definitely a little tight to walk around but only because they have so much to offer! The staff was very helpful and eager to help. Loved it! My daughter is making plans with her friends to go back!

Iconic store located in a beautiful shopping center in front of country pointe. The store is not only filled with delightful treats, it caters for nut free children as well! To top off the delicious treats of chocolates, candies, and even candy sushi! They have a wonderful display of gadgets and cool items to keep the entire family entertained. Absolute 5 star rating!

Candy, candy and candy. If you have a sweet tooth, this place will be your sweet heaven.

Sugar Crazy is such a fun place to bring the kids! Mine are constantly asking me to take them back. The ice cream is so delicious and there are so many choices. Something for everyone. The staff is helpful, professional and pleasant. I am so impressed with all the merchandise. Such a great selection. So much to choose from. The area needed a place like Sugar Crazy. Thank you!!

So happy to find a place that carries a la mode ice cream by the scoop. My son with peanut, tree nut and egg allergies was so excited to be able to get ice cream at a "real" place. They are super careful. They change gloves and use a new scoop for every flavor.

Great Squishmallow variety with restocks on rare Squishmallows almost weekly! Line start’s at 8am when they open at 10am on restock day.

They limit one style of the same Squishmallow per party (ex. May only purchase Benny OR Brina.) Their prices are kept very close to what Kelly Toys sells them for, anywhere from 1 to 5 dollars extra depending on the size of the Squishmallow.

Will definitely be returning for another restock!

What a HAPPY PLACE Sugar Crazy is!!! It’s deliciously colorful and sweet as could be. This is THE place in town if you’re looking for an ice cream sundae that will be everything you could possibly DREAM. They have quite a selection of yummy desserts and is a paradise for children and ANYONE who is just CRAZY for SUGAR! If you’re looking for a specialty shop that specializes in creating smiles, then this is YOUR “go to” spot in Plainview. The employees are professional and extremely friendly...SUGAR CRAZY is such a fun addition to our community!

So many creative and fun desserts, treats, and gift ideas! Can’t find sundaes or candy concoctions anywhere else in the area like here! Service is great and the aura is just so electric and fun. Highly reccomend for any age group!!! Go and find your inner sweet tooth!

They are amazing, I needed a donation for American Cancer society event I was having and they made a beautiful basket donated to our event!! I am so greatful they helped out and donated to us! The basket is amazing!! Thanks again for supporting the event!

The owner is so nice and the candy is good! A little pricey but what candy store isnt. Definitely tailored to 5th grade girls and the flock of them in there for a birthday party was a little frightening but that's just me.

Outstanding place and unique. It's a kids paradise. Many selections to choose from. Super clean as well. The owner is extremely nice and friendly. I'll definitely be coming back.

Wow one of the best place I ever had ice cream and very friendly service

We do business with Sugar Crazy and I have to say that they are extremely professional and easy to work with. The review below that gave these guys a 1-star because it cause him/her to gain weight... oh gosh..what a joke. Don't stress guys! Keep up the great work!

Lots of good quality children's toys, including fidgets, which is all the rage in primary schools nowadays :). Good parking right next to the entrance.

This place has so many things to offer, they have ice cream, candy, desserts, and many cute accessories. My favorite part is that they have nut-free ice cream options which is hard to find. The owners are very sweet.You MUST check it out!

So yummy! Not a typical ice cream store. It’s an experience. Crepes, shakes, crazy ingredient ice cream, candy and toys! Really fun to do with the kids!

Love this place had my daughter's 13th birthday party with a bunch of girlsand they got all kinds of candy and shakes the owner was really cool to close the place down for us after hours little pricey but overall very cool