Casey's

I have to say this was an exceptional caseys, the lady at the cash register was a sweetheart, so nice and personable. The fresh baked and cooked food looked like it was made for a picture and the donuts I ate were fresh like it was morning. I heard customers raving about the guy that prepared the food and made their pizzas. Even to the fact that if he wasn't there working that night they would not order it.
I don't right reviews like this often. However, I was so impressed it was worth the time to write this. November 16 2022, who were the people working at 4 pm this day. They deserve if nothing else praise.

A little drive from the interstate, but cute little part of town to drive through. Friendly people, clean bathrooms. Had a bit of trouble seeing the screen in the direct sunlight to pump my gas. Other than that, good place for a stop.

Kevin absolutely nails it on the pizza every single time. For years I praised Casey’s pizza and my wife wouldn’t try it. Finally got her to give it a chance and she is hooked. Kevin honestly makes the perfect pizza without any question.

A staple for anyone who wants a basic breakfast that is like home. I usually visit both locations but the one downtown is more spacious.

By far best pizza in Paxton and the employees are all really amazing.

Love this place! Friendly service and a clean store.

The employees give excellent service!

Super clean n sooo friendly ..

Love their food! And Lisa is hot!

Casey and Monicals are the best pizza in town

Very clean restrooms and friendly people.

Cleanest Bathrooms Ever!

Best pizza this side of the Mississipi

Great pizza!!!

Clean, friendly, helpful people!!!!!

Good price for gas

Just a nice place

The pizza there are the best

Always friendly.

Great food.....