Jersey Mike's Subs

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I recently visited Jersey Mike's and had an outstanding experience! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted warmly by the staff, especially Matt, who went above and beyond to ensure I had a fantastic meal. The sandwiches were fresh, delicious, and made exactly to my liking. The atmosphere was clean and inviting, and the service was prompt and friendly. I'll definitely be returning, thanks to Matt and the entire team at Jersey Mike's for providing top-notch service and scrumptious sandwiches!

I pick up lunch from Jersey Mike's West Caldwell at lease once a week. My favorite sandwich is the #7 (Turkey Sub).

Matt and the team are super friendly and professional. They always get the order right, make a perfect sandwich and say "Thank you." It is so nice to visit a local shop that truly appreciates your business.

Matt and team also keep the shop pristine.

I will be heading back to Jersey Mike's today at noon for my #7!

Jersey Mike's provided an exceptional dining experience from both Matt, Chrystal, and Tommy! From the moment I walked in, the welcoming atmosphere set the tone. The freshness of the ingredients and the perfectly tempted bread left me craving more. Plus, the staff's friendliness and efficiency ensured my visit was nothing short of delightful. I’ll definitely be back for another delicious meal at Jersey Mike's!

These are phenomenal and very polite! They know how to treat a customer with our most respect and makes everyone feel at home in Jersey!!!

Matt and everyone there is amazing...they are super friendly and provide excellent service....they always smile and make the best subs ever...i will always come here.

The service was impeccable. Quick wait time and food was amazing. Matt, Krista, and Kyrie were especially nice helping my disabled friend order their food. Will be coming back soon.

Jersey mikes is THE go-to spot. The sandwiches are outrageous and the customer service is very good. To name a few, Jude, Jaquan, and Matt do an amazing job of catering to their customers and always give 110%.

I always love coming into this location! All the employees are very polite and efficient, and the restaurant is very clean. Crystal and Tommy are fantastic!

Mike is a great guy. Welcoming family owned and operated establishment with great food. I like the lettuce, very finely chopped.

Crystal is very professional and friendly. Please acknowledge her hard work. She is an asset to your company.

Khair, Crystal, and Matt were super nice accommodating to our specific large order for our party. They really went above and beyond for us and couldn’t be more grateful. Thank you guys

Quan was the best employee I’ve ever had the pleasure of meeting at jersey mikes he showed such dignity and respect to me and made the sandwich just how I enjoy it

This team took care of me today for my birthday. They are a great group of people. Definitely grab subs here!

Jude, Matthew, and Quan were amazing and made quality sandwiches. Great experience all around, i don’t understand the low reviews.

best sandwich spot ever team was fantastic especially brandon at the register such a great smile and great energy for me and the customers behind.

Great food at a really positive atmosphere. Jude, Matt, Jaquan, and others do a really good job with customer service.

We ordered a bunch of subs for an impromptu Family gathering And Crystal was very helpful and cooperative with all the special requests!

The staff is clean, sharp & professional - Best Jersey Mike's around! Tommy is always around and super friendly!

Crystal & Tommy are the best!! Super friendly and incredible service all around. Very clean restaurant, my goto Jersey Mike’s here in Jersey!

Brandon was very respectful and extremely helpful when I needed it. He is an incredibly handsome and distinguished young man.