Rosati's Pizza

I had the best experience here. The woman at the counter was super friendly. I highly recommend ordering the Dough Nuggets. The portion is huge for the price

The first time I ordered I got chicken Alfredo. Everything was delicious and on time.
I ordered for a second time today 02/27/2024 and it’s still what you want to expect from a place like this !
Good hot food in a timely manner.
Plus when I went to pick it up, at the counter she was kind and gave me their deal for pasta since it is Tuesday which was $4 off.
Inside their restaurant is clean and has nice atmosphere.
Deserving of a good review. Will definitely be back to eat.

Best pizza in the entire Madison area. The online ordering for pickup is a breeze. We've not done delivery bc we live too far away but it's worth the drive. When ordering online it tells how long for pickup, and that time estimate is always spot-on. The food is always consistent too, so there's never a bad experience.

Rosati's Pizza of Sun Prairie is the only place I go to for take out food. The menu options are terrific and the service is always perfect. They treat you like you are the only customer in the restaurant and staff remembers their customers. You just don't get that anywhere else.

Got a 14inch Chicago style deep dish pie and it was amazing. Madison west as of right now could really learn a lesson from this place as they use a completely different and far far inferior recipe.

Sun Prairie location Rosatis truly cares about about customer service and high quality! I barely had to wait and although my address was a bit away from them , the pizza was super hot fresh and juicy!! I couldn’t be anymore impressed . Well done guys !!

Their chop salad and Chicago style pizza are our go to order. Great taste and super friendly/fast delivery.

They never fail to provide a great pizza. Both the Chicago style and thin crust are great.

It's never Bad 😔
I wish I could have a Rosati in my Kitchen. It's always Welcoming and the History is on the walls and in the sauce.

The best pizza I've had in a long time! Whenever I'm in town, I plan on getting me some Rosati's pizza!

Solid pizza. It's become my favorite go-to place in SP.
Slices for lunch are great and faily priced.

My carryout order was properly prepared and ready at the given time. It was served to me by friendly staff too. The online ordering is easy to use and accurate in product description. The prices may raise an eyebrow but the quality and quantity of the food justified this. There are also coupons and specials available if needed. I highly recommend the thin crust pizza.

Amisa very friendly staff and food is fantastic. Highly recommend this location always fresh.

Wonderful pizza!
I think this is probably the best pizza in Sun Prairie. We got a 16 inch deluxe double crust and 12 wings. The pizza was great. I'm in love and have a new favorite pizza place. The wings were great also; properly cooked, well seasoned, large sized. I even loved the inside and decor. 100% we will be back. A little pricey, but totally worth it.

We ordered Rosati's tonight. This was the first time we have ordered in a while. The last time we orderd pizza and thought we would try some pasta. The fettuccine was lacking sauce and chicken. The noodles were over cooked. The sauce was bland. The Galic bread was excellent. We did not eat the dinner. We ended up throwing it away. The spaghetti was ok, it was also lacking sauce. I am sorry to say, we will not be ordering from them again. On the bright side the service was friendly. It was a waste of $40.00.

We ordered pizza tonight and it was excellent. The customer service was excellent as always. The Manger was able to give us a credit from the pasta not being so good. We will definitely order again. Thank you for the great service and letting us try your restaurant again.

Had an absolutely wonderful meal. Top notch Chicago Style Pizza. It's as good as it is in Chicago. The staff is super friendly and fun. We decided to go for our 24th wedding anniversary and it did not disappoint. Thanks for an amazing meal and great atmosphere.

We had a wonderful Valentine dinner....delicious lasagna, bread and salad...huge servings so we will have a repeat tomorrow...what a deal. They undercharged us so we plan to go in and correct that. We I’ll definitely tell our friends and we will be back!

I’ve eaten a lot pizza in my life, but the Chicago style from this restaurant has truly changed everything. There’s no going back, only disappointment from anywhere else but here.

In all seriousness, Truly, an amazing pie. These new owners really know what they’re doing!

Got to meet one of the new owners yesterday and was really excited to hear Rosati's is re opened. We ordered pizza, salad, cookie, and fries last night for dinner. The food and service was amazing!!!! Keep up the amazing work!

Yum! The Chicago style deep dish is delicious, perfect amount of cheese and sauce and the dough nuggets as an appetizer are a must! The service is good and orders are always very timely! We are glad to see a new pizza place in the area and this will most likely get added to our list of local favorites!