Island Slice Pizzeria

The food is good considering all the other places . Expect a 15-20min wait time in rush hours. The pizza base is excellent , sub is delicious. The staff are very friendly .

Nice place to grab a slice or a whole deep dish pizza. Salad was really good.

Island Slice Pizzeria is certainly located. They are very friendly, accommodating and fast. We recommend this restaurant.

Got in right when they opened and got our food immediately. I wasn't expecting anything great but I was pleasantly surprised with the food - especially the bread sticks. Thick, fluffy, and garlicky. Also, every other restaurant was packed and expensive. The prices were on par with a non-tourist town and it wasn't busy at all.

Service was good. We ordered the large pizza with sausage & mushrooms and a sub sandwich.
Pretty crowded but that didn’t stop us from telling people to back up/move away from our table so we can enjoy our meal, despite the rush.
Tables need to be cleaned/cleared better but the bussers did their best.
I highly suggest bringing your own disinfectant wipes to wipe the tables.

Lots of seating. Very yummy and delicious pizza!!!! A slice of cheese or pepperoni is $5.50 which is a nice deal for the island. Very kind staff.

The food was awesome. The service was second to none. We had a group of 22 our orders were taken all at once and all of us received our food together. A great experience.

The pizza and bread sticks are delicious! The pop was just okay because it is not carbonated.

The pizza was made fresh and was delicious! I recommend this place if you are looking for some good pizza for a decent price. Spent a little over $40 for 6 people to eat.

Very good pizza, but yes a bit pricey,but if you think about the taste, atmosphere and counter help friendly staff, I'd rather the price.

Been here 3 times in the last 4 years. Never disappoints, staff is friendly and pizza is great.

Expensive but honestly for the island... it is probably one of the cheaper options. Conveniently located across from the pink pony. Order a pizza and save some for later. The best option in my opinion.

Have to stop by here every time we go to the island. Love their pizza and the prices are good too.

Little pricy! But guess only pizza place in the island! Best for quick orders, we didn't want to spend too much time in restaurant and this place worked well for us, got order in decent time, we were out quick!
Loved the breadsticks!

This was the best pizza we've had in a while. We got the deep dish. It took a little longer but it was worth the wait!

Discovered this place after the Lilac Run overnight in June 2022. The pizza was great. I did take out to head back to Chippewa Hotel. Long line, but all workers were efficient and soon my pizza was ready. I will return again in September when I do the 8 mile. Carbs are good.

Good place if you want quick bite to eat.

If anyone vegetarian i highly advice on their Veggie/Gluten Free Pizza. As meat eater, i decided to get one for me and my wife since she vegetarian, to split, and it was really good. It can get little bit crowded during lunch time. But with prices/costs of everything around. You get good quantity/quality food.

The lady who took are order was very pleasant to work with on our order.

I've been coming to this pizza place with my family since I could walk. Great staff, fast service, and great pizza. One day, I hope to continue the tradition with my own family. Island Slice will always be a lunch stop after biking around the island. Thank you for so many happy memories and great food.

One of the more affordable options for a family. Excellent pizza. Quick service. Central location.

Had a great experience at Island Slice Pizzeria! Their gluten free pizza was delicious and a fair price. The service was great and the atmosphere was awesome. They made it easy to order and the wait time for food was short. The tables were well spaced out and they made it easy to wait comfortably after ordering. If I had to leave anything negative it was just that they didn’t seem to have a garbage can inside for trash, however, there was a public bin just outside so it wasn’t a big deal. Overall great experience ! Would highly recommend !