The Ice Cream Shop

I can’t speak for the ice cream, but the breakfast sandwiches are excellent! Real eggs used - not the liquid eggs, fresh ingredients and many different sandwich options. The staff are very friendly, restaurant is clean, and prices are comparable to other restaurants in town. Highly recommend! Can’t wait to try this for lunch! Keep up the good work!!

Lovely new ice cream shop in downtown Hagerstown. Went today with my daughter and boyfriend. We had large portions for reasonable prices. Delicious South Mountain Creamery ice cream. We will be back!

This was a fun find along the Washington County Ice Cream Trail, and I was so surprised to find the ice cream shop on dual highway - I had never noticed it before. The ice cream was very reasonable priced and there were a few different flavors to enjoy. I got Lemon Crunch, and it was delicious. I'll definitely be back again to try some of their other options when I'm nearby.

OMG ... first visit was today and it surely will not be my last. A soft icecream fantastic and I was not disappointed. But they have so many other things to offer including Breakfast and Lunch sandwiches and that's another reason for me to return. The young couple running the store were supper friendly and courteous and helped make for a great experience ... I'm hooked.

Such a cute little ice cream shop! The staff is super friendly, and the food is delicious and well priced. We will be stopping in again soon!

This is a cute little shop with some of the tastiest ice cream around. I highly recommend the cold brew chip ice cream in particular. This is a must stop in Hagerstown.

Great little shop with friendly ladies running it. Good local ice cream for a good price 🥰

First Nostalgic Ice Cream Shop I have ever seen! I love the atmosphere and the Ice Cream. Family Friendly

Delicious ice cream, sandwiches and coffee. Friendliest service :)

First visit here. I had a banana split, my daughter had an ice cream cone.
She enjoyed her ice cream and the size of the serving was generous for the price. They were out of cake cones so they offered her a waffle cone instead but didn't charge her for the upgrade, nice.
Pros on the split: The ice cream is local and tastes like it. Homemade texture and flavor, it was fantastic! The split used the 3 traditional flavors, vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry. All were delicious.
The price was also reasonable. $5.99 + .75 cents extra to add wet walnuts, so a large well topped banana split for under $7 doesn't seem unreasonable with today's prices, especially considering how good the ice cream is.
Cons on the split: no strawberries, just a strawberry sauce with no actual pieces of strawberry in it; in my opinion, this takes quite a bit away from the banana split; also, the banana on it looked great but was green and too hard and even though I love bananas and eat them daily, the only thing I didn't finish on this banana split was the banana.
All in all, a good visit. I'd definitely go back because of the quality and value of the local ice cream, but I'll likely not get the banana split again.

Girl moved at a snails pace and the ice cream was icey. It was faster to apply for my marriage license than to get a single scoop of icey ice cream. Staff was friendly, though, and shop was clean. Prices for ice cream are good for portion size tho.

I want to like this place so badly. It's a cute little shop in a great location. I've given it three tries, and today they were out of: milkshakes, floats, peanut butter, several hand dipped ice cream flavors, and all soft serve (a hand written sign taped to the front door said they had 3 flavors of soft serve today). I offered to correct the sign if the employee would hand me a marker. He declined and said it's fine. He seemed more interested in perfecting his toss of a pen into a cup than anything to do with selling ice cream.
The other employee seemingly misheard my order then had to make a substitution because (surprise!) they didn't have what I paid for. That one issue could be avoided by repeating orders back to the customer before making the items.

Save yourself the trouble and go to Big Dipper.

Service was horrible. Staff was rude.

Employees are openly rude, terrible service