Williamsburg Pizza Omaha

Great pizza!

We ordered the Cup & Char Grandma pie and it was amazing! The crust was crisp and chewy. The sauce and toppings were all well balanced. The garlic knots were also very good.

I will 100% be back to try one of their Brooklyn round pies.

Had been wanting to try this place for a while, and was happy we finally did! They have 4 large booths that fit 6 people comfortably, so we opted to dine in. The girl at the counter was really nice and recommended some popular pies to us newbies. Ended up getting the Margherita and the Cup & Char. The Marg was good, but the C&C was legit. Great flavor and excellent crust. Even though they were getting close to closing time when we were finishing, the staff was very courteous and didn't make us feel rushed to get out of there. We'll be back!

Amazing authentic NY pizza in west omaha of all places.
Crazy that this is available, at fairly affordable prices. Square grandma pizza is great, dough has a good chew, crispy crust perfect. There is a very stark difference between grandma slices, and circle slices. If you go back to back you really get a taste of the cheeses from the circle pie, and the tomato sauce on the grandma. It's a very fun way to change up dinner.

Garlic knots are a must, literally no reason not to order these.. Meatballs were fantastic as well, better if eaten day of, but they still reheat fine.

Everything seen in the first picture was for 2 people to try most options, we spent $56 and ate on it for multiple days. I can't bring myself to even think of going anywhere else for a take out pizza order.

As my boyfriend said, “best pizza I’ve ever had “! He doesn’t make comments like that at all. I thought it was great but the crust was a little too overcooked for me. Toppings were delicious! Highly recommend! We had delivery.

Delicious pizza! Vegan options are very good . Crispy, chewy crust and piled with toppings . It doesn't get much better than that!

Even after a 35min drive home this pizza was still one of the best I've ever had. Will 1000% be back to try it fresh out of the oven. The crust was amazing and the ingredients are premium. We now understand what everyone was raving about. The garlic knots were better than any I've ever tasted. You get what you pay for here!

Hold onto your taste buds, because Williamsburg Pizza has arrived in Omaha, Nebraska, and it's an absolute contender for best pizza! As soon as I heard about this New York-based sensation making its mark in the heartland, I was brimming with excitement, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint.

I dialed them up the moment they opened, and the phone lines were practically buzzing with anticipation. It's mind-blowing that this place has created such a buzz right from the get-go. And let's talk about the pizza - specifically, the Bianco Brooklyn pizza. It's like a cheese lover's dream come true. The Ricotta piping, oh my goodness, it's like a taste explosion that takes your cheesy cravings to a whole new level. Picture this: a perfect blend of flavors, a crispy crust that's got that ideal crunch, and slices that are big enough to satisfy any appetite.

But the excitement doesn't stop there. We also went for the char and cup grandma pizza, and it was an absolute revelation. Slightly thicker and square, it's like a pizza adventure you never knew you needed. The pepperonis on that bad boy, they curve up - yes, you heard me right, pure pizza magic!

And don't even get me started on the garlic knots. They managed to create the most perfect blend of a crispy outside and a gooey, flavorful center. Honestly, I'm scratching my head wondering how they pulled off this culinary wizardry, but I'm loving every second of it!

I'm going to shout it from the rooftops: Williamsburg Pizza is a must-visit, a culinary gem that's making its mark in Omaha. I'm beyond thankful that this New York tradition has landed on our doorstep. This place is a culinary revolution, and I'm already planning my next visit. Trust me, you need to experience this pizza paradise!

Order taken right away. Had our granddaughter with us, so we asked to have her slice come out first. They had it ready in minutes. She loved the pepperoni. We had the Grandma pizza and added meatballs. First time having New York style pizza, loved the flavors and crust. Manager was very personable and helpful, making sure that we had everything fast.

This place makes some seriously incredible New York style pizzas. At a glance you wouldn’t expect much from how this place looks on the outside, but once through the door it feels like what you would expect in a New York pizzeria. The menu has something to suit everyone’s taste, and everything can be customized. I got the apple bacon pizza and added pepperoni. I was blown away by how good it was. I’ve never had apple on a pizza before, but I gotta say it was really good. I definitely will be returning here to try more items on the menu.

My husband, our children and I love the variety of pizzas. Perfect for a family with kiddos or picky eaters. Crust is perfect and all the toppings are fresh. We enjoyed very delicious New York pizza. This is our new favorite spot.

As someone who grew up in Jersey, I have been mostly disappointed by pizza in Nebraska. The pizza I had last night (large Bianco) was by far the best pizza I've had in Nebraska and better than many of the pizzas I've had back home. And the garlic rolls were delicious as well. Will definitely be going back to try more of their pies.

FINALLY made to Williamsburg and we were not disappointed. Just wished we lived a little closer. My husband's new favorite spot for NY style pizza.

Got take out from Williamsburg Pizza Omaha tonight. Ordering on the phone was easy, online ordering isn't yet available for Omaha. I had to call a couple of times to get through, but eventually did. No sweat. The wait for picking up was about an hour, which worked perfectly for me since I needed the time before arriving. The food was ready when I arrived and the checking out was quick. I paid and I was thanked. Tipping wasn't evident, so I'm not sure if this is customary here.
But!
The cup and char grandma pizza was outstanding, and the garlic rolls were absolutely divine!
Instantly our new favorite pizza place. Plus it's in West O, which is kismet.

The hype is real, it's delicious! We got the Paesano, sausage, roasted red pepper mushrooms and basil. It was grandma style which I thought was a thinner version of Detroit style, and excellent! All the ingredients were very fresh and the crust had a soft crunch that pulled it all together. Called in right at 11, efficient ordering experience and hot and ready when we arrived.

Clearly I review many places but this by far is the best pizza spot in all of Omaha! It’s authentic, fresh, tasty and whats not to like about any of that!? I can’t pick a favorite pizza but I can say the crust is my favorite! The meatballs are my high praise! Cheesy and huge with that perfect amount of sauce! Wish I had more pictures but yes, go, go, GO!!

UPDATE-Williamsburg quickly became one of our top pizza spots in Omaha. The pizza we originally didn't order-the Grandma cup and char pepperoni - actually became one of our favorites. We have ordered about 9 times now, and we LOVE it! They are definitely a 5+ star pizza joint, and I have updated my review from a 4 to a 5 and have deleted most of my original review.
Original- I will say that even though we didn't order the grandma cup and char pepperoni, it is amazing. The sauce, dough, fresh basil, everything was phenomenal, and I will definitely go back based on this pizza alone! There is absolutely nothing like this pizza in Omaha, I assure you because I've been to them ALL. I love love mushrooms and truffle, but I will say the Tartufo is not something I would order again. The truffle was great, but the mushrooms were not sautéed long enough, and they were piled all over the za so not as heavenly as I was hoping.

Friday is pizza night and we thought we’d give Williamsburg a try and see what it was all about.

Wow!!!!! The pizza was amazing and the staff was super friendly. The pepperoni was my favorite with the charred pepperoni’s. The Tartufo is just as good, and was my wife’s favorite.

We will definitely be ordering again.

This pizza was amazing. Got the margarita and the cup n char pepperoni. It was obvious how fresh & high quality the ingredients were. I plan to go back regularly. Highly recommend!

Best pizza in Omaha, hands down! Tried their lunch special and was so good and so filling. Total came out to around $10…hard to find places with such high quality and reasonable price.

Tried The Brooklyn with anchovies added and the Margherita and they were both fantastic.