Wagon Wheel Cafe

Our meals were delicious. Burger was juicy and the chicken tenders were the best we ever had. Hand battered. We asked for our french fries crispy and that's exactly how we got them. The homemade ranch dressing is amazing. The owner even came out to talk to us. Small town atmosphere, big time flavor! ❤

Stopped in 1st time today.
Salad bar, hot food bar looked good, but not that hungry.
Had Biscuits and gravy.
It was good.
Nice place.Quite large,nice restroom!

Went for brunch after church with family and really enjoyed it. The food was delicious and bars were fully-stocked until close. The staff were very friendly and accommodating. The atmosphere was charming and comfortable. Price was average for a buffet. Would definitely go again!

Wagon Wheel catered my daughter's bridal shower brunch. They were easy to work with and provided great food at a great price. Definitely consider them for your catering needs. Highly recommended!

Very calm atmosphere, very friendly waitress, husband stated to me that their broasted chicken was absolutely phenomenal. All I could have was the vegetable beef soup and it was outstanding. We plan to return there as often as possible. Different buffets every day.

This buffet diner is absolutely amazing. There owner Penny is an absolute doll, there cook Christine makes some AMAZING FOOD. Would recommend them to anyone in Ithaca looking for some food with that down home feel. There wait staff was all smiles and friendly..this is one of the best places in this little town to get food.

I came to this place with my wife, son and grandparents for lunch.
Food was great and well stocked!
The service was great as well. Server was attentive and very nice.
All in all great experience!
I'll be back! (In a very bad Arnold schwarzenegger voice) Haha
10/10 would recommend.

This is a true scratch kitchen. The owner is awesome! My service was excellent. The only draw-back is the price-$17.99/person-but worth every penny! It is worth it because it is scratch cooking. Examples of what was on the buffet when I went: boasted chicken, meatloaf, country ham-select days only, yams, mashed potatoes and gravy, salad bar with homemade dressings, and an excellent dessert bar.

Good food for a fair price! I would recommend putting some string flag banners or something to let people know you are new. Grub a dubs wasn't good. I'm sure people drive by and don't realize it's under new owners. We will be back. Thanks!

Great little hometown buffet. Friendly staff, delicious food...would recommend to anyone in the area looking for some delicious home cooked food

Food is always great, the dining room and bathrooms are clean. And the price is affordable!

Best buffet I have been to in a very long time!! Will be back for sure. Try the green beans they were delicious!!

Food was good and fresh!! Friendly service. Very clean restaurant all around.

This place is a great restaurant to eat at if you want an amazing meal and great service along with a warm and loving atmosphere

Great place for great food and service honestly love the atmosphere it almost feels like your at home

1st time there loved it I will be back

Great place to eat took the family and they love it staff was great and so was the food

Loved the auction evening.

Best place to eat in town gotta try it out

Staff is super friendly.